Subject: intake air velocity & low RPM
From: ACRE NL
Date: 1/10/2002, 10:04 PM


Not Mach 1 according to Taylor it is Mach 0.45
Skin friction losses in the pipe well below Mach 0.45 are in
addition to the Mach number effect. Large pipe.. lower velocity..
skin friction is proportional to velocity squared... lower drag.

I think a good analogy is a woofer speaker.
The larger the cone the more efficient the speaker. It couples
better to the air around it. It is related to impedance matching.

It is easier to start a large mass of air moving with a large hole
and large piston. When the piston or rotor attempts to get as much
mass of air as possible moving it is better to do it with a large
hole and a large pipe.

Another analogy is the large rotor diameter on a helicopter. Max
thrust at zero vertical velocity.

The Mazda Lemans engine is simple and absolute proof of this
concept. When somebody builds a rotary engine that generates more
power than the Mazda Lemans engine at the same RPM with a smaller
pipe and smaller port I will believe other wise. 240 HP for a two
rotor at 6000 RPM is a worlds record so far for NA rotary engines.
Nobody else comes close. The VE is well above 100% over a wide RPM
range. Peak torque or max Ve occurs at 6500 RPM with a very flat
but slightly decreasing VE and torque above that up to 9000 RPM.

Almost a straight line between 620 Nm at 6500 to 580 Nm at 9000
RPM. The slight decrease in VE and torque I believe is caused by
the increased pipe skin friction due to increased air velocity
(~V^2) out weighing the decreasing length of the tuned pipe.

If it were not for keeping the apex seals in the rotor slots I
believe the rotary would generate even more HP per rotor at the
same RPM as the Lemans engine with even larger pipes and wider
intake ports.

SAE Mazda paper 920309.

Paul Lamar

Paul,

The Lemans engine is indeed a work of art. The Port is large by our
standards. This does not mean that it is gargantuan. It is simply
sized for high rpm operation.

Wait a minute! It has the worlds HP record for 6000 RPM. That is not
high RPM for a rotary. Nobody but nobody has got more power at 6000
RPM!!!! At 9000 RPM the Lemans engine has more power per rotor (172)
than even the 290 HP RX8 prototype which had 145 HP per rotor at 9500
RPM. Why? Lower air velocities in the runners!


One of the things you tend to shoot for in runner sizing
is not having an area smaller than the port or valve aperture. This
is complicated in valved conventional engines by the fact that there
is a valve stem and several turns and transitions in the runner.
This is where airflow Voodoo comes into play. On the Lemans engine
It is fairly straight forward. It looks to me like the runners are
the same area as the port, as it should be. They are also the most
efficient shape, a circle.

The port it self is rectangular.


People looking for
some type of secret magical shape for a runner should just look at a
circle. A tube has the least amount of wall area per flow area of
any shape, therefore less frictional loss. This is true when the
airflow is straight. When you are accelerating the flow (ie changing
its direction) then you can get non uniform flow fields and
different port shapes can work better, like the D port etc. The
Lemans engine also has variable length runners to take advantage of
sonic tuning. They also have a nice bell shaped inlet, best for flow
losses, and sonic tuning. The runners are straight. They did
everything right. You will note that they did NOT make the runners
much larger than the port.

I agree with this. But the port is limited in width to keep the apex
seals in the slots. It is limited in height for valve timing purposes.
I suspect it is probably possible to get even better breathing if both
side ports and a peripheral ports are used together with one large
runner for each rotor and with even lower main runner air velocities
than the Lemans engine.

It looks kind of like they did in the cross section view, but the
port is more oval shaped and I bet the cross sectional areas are not
far from equal. They did make a larger port than the typical rotary,
which flows better and makes better peak HP numbers. With fuel
injection, you don't have to worry about the fuel suspension problem
like you do with a carb, so this works well. However, I bet the
throttle response below 3000 rpm sucks!

As I said before we don't care about that. It has that has no
consequences for an aircraft engine. I will not argue that point. For
all I know or care there is an optimum air velocity for good throttle
response over a wide RPM range. In fact Ken Powell is trying to solve
that problem as we speak. I even fabricated some parts to help him in
his quest.


The
thing probably idles at a ridiculously high rpm, and not all that
well. It is a high strung race engine. In a fast, slick airplane
with a fixed pitch prop, a peaky high strung engine that idles at a
high rpm is not the best thing. Now if you put a variable pitch prop
on the thing and control thrust that way, while keeping the revs up,
you may have something.

It idles fine. Albeit at 2000 RPM.  They had it here in So Cal at the
Seven Stock meeting a few moths ago and I heard it run. Heck I have a
street motorcycle that idles at 2000 RPM. Ken's engine with variable
port timing will idle even better and show near the same HP per rotor
at the same RPMs.

I still say your chart of VE vs Mach number makes Tracy's argument
and mine as well. There is a definite optimum value. It is worse
both above and below that point. But strictly speaking, all of those
engines were carbureted. So you would have to do the same test with
a fuel injected engine. I bet you would see the same thing, maybe
shifted towards the lower mach numbers somewhat.

I strongly disagree with your interpretation of that chart. So does
Taylor. Here is a modern chart from Heinz Heisler's book  that also
shows a drop off in VE as runner air velocities increase. Note that
despite more skin friction drag in the pipes as the RPM and air flow
are increasing (in the left most chart) VE is remaining near constant
as pipe sizes are also increasing. HP of course is rapidly rising with
the RPM and additional air flow.

In the right had chart; note also that as air velocities
increase, despite the shorter pipes with less skin area, VE is
rapidly decreasing with increased runner air velocities.
If both pipe diameter and pipe length where  both increased
the VE would not drop off or drop off at a far lower rate.
More like the rate of the VE drop off in the Lemans rotary engine.
Whomever made this chart did not complete the experiment. Many more
charts should have been made with larger and larger runners over a
range of pipe lengths. For some strange reason he limited himself to
the 40 mm pipe dia. case when the 50 mm pipe dia. case resulted in
more power at higher RPMs. Probably looking for low down HP and
torque.

The bottom line message is: Make the runner dia. and port area
as large as possible and tune the length for max  take off HP at the
peak prop RPM. The engine RPM at this point will vary according to the
PSRU ratio used. For a rotary something around 3:1 PSRU ratio looks
about right.

More evidence. Runner sizes are increasing in all types of piston
engines as more manufactures go to two intake valves per cylinder
which gives more port area.


I have to go tear down a chimney now {8-0

Monty

So far you guys have shown me no data to support your contentions. I
guess I am going to have to scan yet many more graphs from Taylor to
convince you guys. It would be better if Tracy took some of that $500
he has and bought the two volume set of Taylor's bible of engine
design books. Would save me a lot of work :-)> When I would go up to
see Everett Hatch years ago he would carry his Taylor around with him
where ever he went. We would go out to lunch and he would quote
various passages. I miss the guy.

Paul Lamar


   OK, I'm not sure how I feel about this.  It is hard to look at this objectively when I
have spent my entire adult life considering intake flow velocity and how to keep it
UP due to the demads of carburation.  I THINK that I interprete Taylor to mean
bigger is better, but only up to a certain point. AH, the devil is in the details and the
only way I see to solve this is to experiment - on my list of things to do when I get
the airplane flying.
   However, no one has addressed exhaust gas dilution and how the large ports
affect low speed/rpm operation - do not underestimate the importance of this if you
are running a fixed pitch prop.  The engine has got to idle in order for the landing
task to be performed safely.
   At low rpm the exhaust still contains enough high pressure to backflow into the
intake since both the inake and the exhaust are open at the same time (overlap).
This causes all kinds of problems such as lack of oxygen in the intake charge, high
levels of CO(??) which tend to put the fire out, decreases the low pressure of the
intake, and increases intake temp.  I've probably forgotten something important
here, but you can see the problem.
   As stated above, large intake pipes means low velocity at these low RPM's.
Small intake pipes mean higher intake pipe velocities and pressures - these higher
velocites create inertia in the intake charge which blow past the exhaust leakage
and maintain the low pressure of the intake port - these actions help to decrease the
negative affects of exhaust dilution.

Ken Powell

Come in high. Slip it in and land. Who cares if the engine quits :-)>

That is a big issue with a PP. Keeping the throttle right next to the 
rotor as you are doing will help greatly. 

BTW The new RX8 however has no overlap at all.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org