I would like to try to answer this as I understand it. The wankel has high exhaust
PIPE temps because the charge does not burn completely in the combustion
chamber and completes the burn in the exhaust pipe, which cause very high
exhaust gas temps. I have never heard that the combustion chamber temps are
excessively high. What about this Paul? It seems that the combustion chamber
temps would be lower due to the larger wetted area of the rotor and the rotor
housing and that this is one of the reasons that the wankel has problems obtaining
low bsfc (but boy, Tracy is sure proving this to be an 'ole wives tale').
I am a little more confident dealing with the 2-stroke - lots of experience here.
Remember that a 2-stroke fires every time the piston cycles - this gives the piston,
rings, and spark plug less TIME to disipate the heat from combustion. If the 2-
stroke were to obtain the hot combustion chamber temps that a 4-stroke sees, the
piston crown would (and will) melt in short order. Ask me how I know this! Since
the 2-stroke has less time to disipate the heat, cooler combustion temps are
required to keep the temps of the piston lower. Thus, a 2-stroke sees a bsfc as rich
as .65 to keep the temps in check and should never see an egt higher than 1200
degrees. A typical cruise egt is 1050 degrees with a max of 1150 if you want long
engine life. If you lean a 2-stroke to far while under load you will either seize or hole
the piston.
Ken Powell
Yes, I think Ken has summed it up well. The rotary has relatively low combustion temperatures because of the high surface to volume ratio (relative to a modern piston engine -- anything with overhead valves). There may also be some effect from the relatively slower flame travel in the rotary (caused by the long combustion chamber shape), and the bad quench region in the trailing end of the chamber. It is these precise issues that make stratified charge work so elegantly in a rotary -- direct fuel injection controls to a large extent the combustion rate, stratification renders the surface to volume and chamber shape issues less relevant, and the trailing squish helps with turbulence.
Jon Lauter
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org