Big snips>
Prior to installing the 2.5 liter(165hp) Subaru engine into my
cozy, ...
Paul wrote>
Yes but how many people cruise at 40% power? The fuel burn has a lot to
do with the
HP the engine is actually generating.
Things just don't add up. We just went through all this
with Herb's airplane. It is the 165 HP claim I question mostly. The
Subaru
makes a pretty good 100 HP engine. After all 2.5 liters is only
152 cubic inches. To get 165 HP out of this piston engine he is going to
have to really scream the piston engine at around the red line of say
6500 RPM with a 2.8:1 or better PSRU. Ask him what RPM he runs on
takeoff and cruise.
Mark wrote:
It is probably less damaging to the reputation of auto conversions that he
gets lousy performance from a "165hp" engine reliably, than if he has a
major engine failure and buries himself and three friends while proving that
the Subaru can outperfom the O-360.
Mark Wrathall
Good point. Mark I have always said we should divorce ourselves from the
automotive piston engine. There are lots of Subaru engine failures in
the NTSB accident reports way out of proportion to the total
number of aircraft engines out there. Sometimes it is hard to find them as the NTSB
frequently does not mention the word "Subaru" for some strange reason. Many are
caused by the installation detail errors just like what we are constantly harping
on around here.
Frequently the NTSB allows the engine supplier to examine
the engine for the cause of failure which is like allowing the cat
to baby sit the canary. Not a good idea IMHO. The engine supplier's
very economic survival depends on his and Subaru's reputation as a reliable
aircraft engine source.
Other crashes are caused by out and out mechanical failures.
See the first report below. Stratus Inc. themselves lost their demo C150
when the Subaru engine dropped a valve.
Most people give up when the auto piston engine HP starts to deteriorate
at the several hundred hour point from leaking valves, low oil pressure
and leaking piston rings which is a good thing. The engines usually don't last long
enough for something major like a rod or crankshaft to fatigue.
Paul Lamar
SEA00LA116
On June 27, 2000, approximately 1106 Pacific daylight time, a Davis/Crouch Avid Mark IV experimental-category amateur-built airplane, N518DC, was
substantially damaged in a forced landing following a loss of engine power approximately 3 nautical miles north of Concrete, Washington. The commercial
pilot-in-command, listed on the FAA aircraft registry as a co-builder and co-owner of the aircraft, and a passenger were seriously injured in the crash.
Visual meteorological conditions prevailed and no flight plan had been filed for the local 14 CFR 91 personal flight from Concrete.
The pilot reported that he departed the Concrete, Washington, airport (WA13) about 1030 with 15 gallons of automotive fuel on board. He stated that he
flew north over Baker Lake and Shannon Lake. He reported that during the return flight to the Concrete airport, while over Shannon Lake, the engine
sputtered and quit, and would not restart. The pilot reported he then attempted an emergency landing in a rugged logging area west of Lake Shannon and
north of Lake Tyee. He stated he was unable to make it to a logging road, and crashed into trees and bushes along the side of the road. The occupants
facilitated their own rescue by dialing 911 on a cellular telephone and reporting the accident.
An FAA inspector who responded to the accident scene reported that witnesses stated they heard a loud noise and saw a puff of smoke from the aircraft as
it was flying, and that the aircraft then began to lose altitude before they lost sight of it. The FAA inspector reported that in a post-accident examination
of the aircraft, he observed a hole in the engine crankcase, and that the #1 connecting rod had gone through the crankcase at the location of this hole. The
engine was a Subaru automotive engine modified for use in experimental aircraft by Stratus, Inc.
Stratus, Inc.'s owner reported to the NTSB that he and another individual with Stratus examined the aircraft wreckage with the FAA's permission
following the accident. He reported that during their examination, the overheat sensors mounted on the cylinder heads were observed to be melted,
indicative of the engine having experienced an overheat condition. Stratus, Inc.'s owner also reported that other indications of engine overheat within the
engine were observed, such as oil baked onto the oil filler cap and the inside of a valve cover. The Stratus owner stated that his company has told customers
that if an engine is overheated, it needs to be taken apart to check for damage.
The FAA aircraft registry indicated that the airplane received an experimental-category airworthiness certificate on May 3, 1996. According to the
aircraft owner, the airplane and engine had 309.3 hours total time and 5.1 flight hours since the aircraft's last condition inspection, which the pilot/owner
signed off one week prior to the accident.
NTSB Identification: NYC01LA226. The docket is stored in the (offline) NTSB Imaging System.
Accident occurred Sunday, September 09, 2001 at Morrisdale, PA
Aircraft:Murray JN4-D, registration: N176TP
Injuries: 1 Serious, 1 Minor.
This is preliminary information, subject to change, and may contain errors. Any errors in this report will be corrected when the final report has been
completed.
On September 9, 2001, about 1400 eastern daylight time, a homebuilt JN4-D, a Jenny replica, N176TP, was substantially damaged during a forced landing
near Morrisdale, Pennsylvania. The certificated private pilot received serious injuries, and the passenger received minor injuries. Visual meteorological
conditions prevailed for the local flight that departed the Albert Airport (1NS), Philipsburg, Pennsylvania. No flight plan was filed, and the flight was
conducted under 14 CFR Part 91.
According to the pilot, he kept the airplane at a private airstrip near Kylertown, Pennsylvania. He arrived at the airstrip about 1330 on the day of the
accident. He preflighted the airplane, and added approximately 3 gallons of fuel, bringing the total to approximately 8 gallons. The engine started on the
first attempt, and the pilot taxied the airplane to the west runway for departure. Once on the runway, the pilot advanced the throttle, the engine responded,
and after a ground-roll of approximately 300 feet, the airplane was airborne. The airplane climbed to approximately 800 feet agl, for the short trip to the
Albert Airport.
The pilot executed left traffic for the east runway. While on final, he did not feel the airplane was in a position to land because of a crosswind from the
south, so he preformed a go-around, and then left traffic for a second attempt, which was successful. The airplane touched down and the pilot taxied to the
far end of the airport to pickup a passenger. The pilot exited the airplane with the engine running. He then briefed and loaded his passenger. The pilot
taxied the airplane for an east departure. Once on the runway he advanced the throttle. The engine responded, and within 300 feet the airplane was
airborne. After tracking the runway heading for about 1/2 mile, the pilot turned the airplane into the wind to improve climb performance. "Shortly" after
completing the turn, and while approximately 400 feet agl, the engine suddenly loss power. The pilot lowered the nose to maintain airspeed, and executed a
180-degree turn because the only forced landing area was a cornfield behind the airplane.
While proceeding towards the cornfield, the pilot was concerned that the airplane might not clear some power lines bordering the field, so he elected to
proceed directly towards the field, and land with a tailwind. Once past the power lines, the pilot momentarily thought about trying to maneuver the airplane
a little to reduce the tailwind component, but decided against it. The pilot flew the airplane just above the cornfield, trading airspeed to maintain altitude.
When the airplane started to stall, the pilot let it settle into the cornfield. The left wing contacted the corn first, which was approximately 10 feet tall. The
nose dropped and the airplane impacted the ground nose low, and left wing down. The airplane then spun 180 degrees to the left and came to a stop upright.
The total distance from when the airplane first contacted the corn until it came to rest was approximately 60 feet.
The engine was from a 1986 Subaru that was involved in an automobile accident. The engine had approximately 9,000 miles on it at the time of the
automobile accident, and 93.6 flight hours in the accident airplane. The pilot suspected that the timing belt might have failed.
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org