Subject: fat=lower drag, was The miraculous Subaru???
From: ACRE NL
Date: 1/29/2002, 5:15 PM


"Byrd, Ray" wrote:

Lower drag with more frontal area?  YES!  With a family of very clean
shapes, drag continues to reduce as max thickness moves aft. (NACA
laminar-flow airfoils are a notable example)

For the ultimate in fuselage drag reduction see AIAA-87-2935, Fabio
Goldschmied,  "Fuselage Self-Propulsion by Static-Pressure Thrust: Wind
Tunnel Verification". Boundary layer is ingested near the aft end, and blown
aft thru a nozzle.  Drag coefficient can be zero, and propulsive efficiency
100%. A real mind bender.

Ray Byrd

Since a canard develops lift there will be two vortices trailing aft at
the juncture of the canard and the fuselage. Kind of destroys most of the
benefit of a lower fuselage length  to frontal area ratio.

The other factor is sort of an area rule effect that modifies the
cusp of a true laminar flow object with a aft located max frontal
area and that is the location of the strakes. Extensive wind tunnel
test should be done to explore these factors before any judgments
can be made that a larger frontal area fuselage such as the Cozy
or Velocity is lower drag than a tandem seat fuselage with half the
frontal area such as a Long EZ. Frankly I doubt it.

Paul Lamar

The Taylorcraft (side-by-side) is faster than the J3 Cub (tandem)
on the same engine.  The Aeronca Chief (SBS) has the same
perf as the Aeronca Champ (Tandem) with the same engine.  The
Cozy has about the same perf as the Long EZ with the same
engine.  The wing moslty controls the cruise in most aircraft unless the
fuselage or something else is hideously wrong.

Bill Freeman

What do you mean by "mostly". We need some "real" numbers here. The numbers
I have for these old airplanes is fuselage 25%, wings 35% tail 10%
landing gear 15% and the rest is engine and engine cooling.
That does not exactly make the wings "mostly".

When I see a Cozy race a Long EZ side by side I will believe it.

Paul Lamar

Paul, I have flown several xc trips wing to wing with Vance Atkinson's Cozy 3 place
and you never have to wait on Vance. My Long EZ flat out would go a little faster
than the Cozy with the same engine, but not every 0320 Long could keep up with Vance.

I don't remember if it was written or verbal, but Burt did an analysis of the Cozy
drag and stated the Long had a 3mph advantage in max speed with the same hp.

Herb

3 MPH can be close to a 10% drag reduction.

A lot depends on details. Klause is going 252 MPH with an O-200 Varieze
and it is not all engine. Mostly aero details and a bit of better prop. 
I would like to see both airplanes.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org

crawford-performance3.gif