Subject: Engine for Murphy was: Supercharger?
From: ACRE NL
Date: 3/4/2002, 7:18 PM


Tom Smythe wrote:

Hi,
?).

My current plane of choice (not purchased yet) is the Murphy
Beaver
with
a 20B attached instead of the Russian radial. At present, we're
getting
ready to move out to the country from our suburban home, but
sometime in
the next year or so... ;-)

I've been reading and learning for a long time from the folks on
this
list - thank you all very much for your efforts and ideas.

Tom Smythe

I am a bit curious as to why you would opt for the 20B for the big
Murphy
instead
of the Russian radial. The M14 is a natural for that plane. It is
cheap
and
reliable
the match up is already worked out, the props for it are great for
that
application,
The power to weight ratio is hard to beat, and the sfc is not too
bad.
The
20B
is more of a racer choice. The Murphy is a truck , and a pretty darn
good
one
particularly with the M14 - Vance Jaqua


Vance I am surprised at you. Piston engines are grenades waiting to
happen.
The three rotor would last twice as long and be much cheaper to
overhaul.
Forget piston engines. They are dinosaurs.

Paul Lamar


Yeah your right Paul! Them M14 s are not very durable - when you run
them
on generator sets you have to ovehaul them after only 20,000 hours.
Vance Jaqua


Somebody got the units wrong in the translation from Russian to English.
That is 20,000 minutes :-)> Come on Vance I am really surprised at you.
You
have been on here for three years or more. Surely by now you understand
the structural and wear advantages of a rotary over any piston engine.

Do you still think the rotor reciprocates or what?

Paul Lamar


When I got my SR2500 and before it I was looking at the MP14 as the plan A
engine.  I only got about 600 hrs behind radials, Pratts and Jakes,  really
like them, love the noise they make,  and things only got interesting twice,
but the other one always hung in there.  When 3 of us couldn't make it fit
without being way out there, (pre Murphy Moose SR3500) decided to go the 20b
route.  The 3500 and the 2500 are a fill and fly aircraft (keeping in mind
CG), and  there are alot of places in the US to fix the 20b if you can't do
it yourself.  There are no dealers in the US to wrench on the MP14 if you
can't work on it yourself, plan on a 1000hrs before it needs serious
wrenching, if you pay attention to the oil in the bottom jugs. From the
people I've talked to, you better have a place to work on gaskets and and
other things.  I like flying into small dirt, grass strips ,skis and floats.
The 20b will give me alot more visibility over the front than the MP14.
Fuel burn will be about the same, however there won't be a five gallon oil
tank on it tho.  The only bad thing that I can see is that there isn't a
good PRSU to put 350 hp of turboed 20b on.  When MGDQ is flying, it will
probably weigh in at about 1650 lbs with 300 hp turboed.  Will probably
perform the same  as a 3500 with a MP 14.

Barny

Have you looked into prices on the Bell 47 gear box? Actually I think
Tracy is being conservative on the 300 HP rating of the six pinion Ford
based box. Ford uses that with some real high torque turbo diesel pick
up trucks. Also research the Allison auto transmission used in the really
big GM trucks. I think Don Dunbar is also on to something with that
Borg Warner Velvet boat drive box. 

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org