The potential of some of the marine outboards is
awesome, mainly for their power to weight ratios.
Take a look at the cruise fuel burn of a two stroke vs. a rotary,
calculate the extra fuel load (and operating cost), and see if the two
stroke still makes sense.
Jon Lauter
Rotary Power Marine Corporation
Gentlemen, at the risk of speaking lightly of something massively
undeserving of trivialization, I would like to inject some opinion on the 2
stroke outboard conversion topic. Please understand that I don't mean to
evangelize the outboard powerhead conversion. I believe the rotary
conversion is superior for reasons already mentioned, but also because it
is more highly developed at this time.
Two stroke outboards have come a long, long way in fuel efficiency in the
last few years. So much so that they are comparable to 4 stroke stern
drives, in terms of fuel efficiency. Mercury's "behind the liner" porting
techniques have helped efficiency considerably. The Mercury 2.5 liter
powerhead was a major step forward in both power and fuel economy. The
Mercury 3.0 liter powerhead is another step forward, although it is not yet
as developed as the 2.5 liter platform.
I would contend that the best powerhead available for conversion and use in
a small aircraft is the Mercury 2.5 liter horn motor. These units can
easily put out 300 hp at 6000 RPM, normally aspirated, no nitrous, and do
so reliably and with longevity. 400 hp is doable but expensive. Your 800
horse example of a rotary firebreather is quite doable too, although the
engine would have to spin so fast that it would be irrelevant as an
aircraft motor.
Depends on the gear box ratio. The Bell 47 helicopter gear box used by
Dave Garber is 3:1 and will easily handle 1000 HP in a time to climb
scenario. That would be only 3,000 prop RPM at 9,000 engine RPM.
Other ratios higher than 3:1 are possible.
The guys who run these levels of power go down the lake
0.25 miles at a time with longevity beyond this distance being irrelevant.
These engines are often spun to 11-12k RPM and they simply don't hold
together for long at these speeds.
I would contend that new powerheads can be had for less than the $10 000
figure you've cited. Mercury has already done some conversions for use on
jet pumps but I have no idea what those powerheads would go for. An
excellent contact on this subject would be John Marles. He is an authority
on the subject and has massive experience in converting powerheads for
interesting uses including converting engines for use in sand rail desert
vehicles. I can assist anyone interested in contacting John.
While I wouldn't want to guess at the weight of a full conversion, I'm
confident that a well done conversion would have an extremely competitive
power to weight ratio.
I would worry about two issues with the outboard conversion. First, in the
case of the Mercury, the top bearing is adequate for lake use. It's
marginal for high performance use. In order to get reliability out of the
top bearing, a lightened and balanced flywheel would need to be fitted.
Second, I would be concerned about the ability of the stator to source high
quantities of current for long periods of time. Even if you were to use
the 40 amp stator, I would be concerned about it's longevity.
I would like to thank everyone on this list for providing excellent
reading. It has been very interesting and informative.
Best regards,
Tom Brown
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org