Subject: Ducted fans and turbofans
From: ACRE NL
Date: 3/22/2002, 12:48 AM


(big snip)

I was struck by the performance comparison between the direct drive
Subaru
in this month's  Sport Av, and Perry's experience. It would seem to
fortify
the conclusions that ducts are not particularly viable for sport
aircraft in
our design range. It strongly suggests that; while the duct can
improve
static thrust,
probably reduce noise, and provide improved safety for adjacent
personell on
the ground; they lose at cruise and above. (boy! my old English
teacher
would kill me for that sentence structure) - Vance

Me too. Notice that Charlie Airsmen also has takeoff performance
problems.

His break through is the long prop shaft and gentle slope to the
rear of the cowling. Notice also he traded top speed for a three blade
climb
prop. Klause told me Charlie overheats the oil at top speed and must
back
off.

Paul Lamar


Paul,

I have been busy on the house lately, but in the evenings I have been
looking at the high speed ducted rotary concept. Qualitatively, I have
to
tell you that I am a bit pessimistic about the efficiencies attainable
with
such an arrangement. Most modern turbofans operating at M .8 or so have
very
high pressure ratios, like 30. Even using a turbocharger you will not be
able to do that with a rotary because of detonation problems. They have
Thrust specific fuel consumption around .5. Rotaries are far more
competitive with turboshaft engines. Especially in the low power range
below
400 hp. Above 1000 hp, the rotary is going to have a difficult time
competing. For instance, the PT6 has 1600 hp and the equivalent specific
fuel consumption is .505 lb/hr/eshp (eshp takes exhaust gas thrust into
account), even neglecting the exh gas and just using shp gives .53
lb/hr/shp. Derivatives of the GE T700 turboshaft produce 1700 shp with a
specific fuel consumption of .46 lb/hr/shp. and weigh just 430 lb. Hard
numbers to beat. BTHW I have been in a test cell when one of these
things
was being put through its paces. If you have ever stood 6 feet from
something producing 1700 hp, you know what an uncomfortable experience
it is
8-0.

Looking at the drag numbers and power required to attain high subsonic
speeds shows that it is going to take at least 1000 hp even with a small
very efficient airframe to get to M .6. (Power required is a cubed
function
of speed) A "cold" jet is much harder to design. There is no heat
injected
into the air stream to expand it. Plus you have the additional
complication
of cooling systems. I think that for M .6 and above, we will have to let
the
jets do their thing.

Charlie Airesman's takeoff problems are the result of a fixed pitch
prop. If
you had a small direct drive prop that was variable pitch it could out
perform a larger fixed pitch speed prop in takeoff and climb, while
besting
it nicely at top speed. (small dia props work better at high speed). The
props become so small for a rotary at 6000 rpm (32 in!!) that they are
only
viable for a high speed single person extreme design. These small props
are
effectively a UDF optimized for M .5 and below. Unless you are going at
least M .4 (aprox 300 mph) there is no reason to use a NASA type UDF.
The
NASA UDF is designed for M .8 cruise, somewhere that we just don't have
the
hp to go. Probably below M .5 you would be better off using a small high
rpm
variable pitch prop.One could argue that it would be much cheaper to buy
a
Jet engine than to try to build a 1000 hp 3 rotor ducted fan that will
last.
If you want to build a world record single seat type of plane you might
use
a turbocharged 3 or preferably 4 rotor with the UDF concept to get
between M
.5-.6. Perhaps a 4 person twin as in Vance's sketch using pylon mounted
direct drive variable pitch props would be feasible for flying in the
400
mph range (M .5). (however, would you want to sit next to that prop?)

As far as the auxiliary, turbine driven fan, I think you would be better
off
using a conventional turbo-compound setup feeding power to the main fan.
It
would be much smaller and lighter. The flow area becomes so small to get
good velocity through the turbine at such large diameters that you are
going
to have high losses through the necessary clearances around the blades.

Most of the numbers I have thrown about can be found in Mechanics and
Thermodynamics of Propulsion, Second Edition, by Hill and Peterson. The
UDF
stuff comes from personal conversations I have had with Mike Murray and
if
you are really interested check out NASA CR174790 lots of references in
this
doc.

If you could give me the rpm and the airflow ingested for the 900 hp 3
rotor, I will put some (fuzzy) hard numbers to it (too many unknowns to
get
exact numbers, but I can get a best case scenario).

The moral of the story, unfortunately, is that for our speed range and
budget size, it is damn hard to beat the conventional variable pitch
prop.
The good news is, in this speed and Hp range, the rotary reigns supreme.
Turbo compound the engine, and nothing can touch it.

Paul, got any pics of the fluid coupling on the blowdown turbine from
the CW
R3350?

Monty


I'll work on those numbers for the 900 HP 3 rotor.

That is real interesting on the small diameter variable pitch prop.

As fate would have it Butch is working hard on a variable pitch prop
design as we speak. Hopefully he will have the prototype done by Sun & Fun
and will be able to display it there.
The parts in this picture are from a earlier, now obsolete prototype.
(too heavy)

This is all I have on the R3350TC fluid coupling.
You can just barely see the fluid coupling.

Paul Lamar


The small diameter controllible pitch prop  would still suffer from
the high disk loading but would let you make full HP at static.
interesting thought - I will model the case (180 hp at 6000)
and put some rough numbers on it - Vance


 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org