Royce Wise wrote:
This is a snipped reply to a letter from the cozy list for those of you not on that
list.
Royce
Royce Wise wrote:
"Hicks, Wayne" wrote:
Okay, here's my report:
(In no particular order.....)
1. snip, snip
4. The canard flight lines had more Velocities than V, L, and C's.
Overall, not as many canards this year.
We were expecting more than was there as well.
5. snip
6. snip
7. snip
8. snip
9. snip
10. snip
11. Learned that the same strobe and lighting systems displayed in the main
vendor barns could be bought for almost half that in the Ultralight vendor
areas. The ultralights have a lot of goodies that would be nice to have on
the Cozy. It's amazing what you can find there...
The ultralight community is definately on the ball.
We plan to build one just to have to tool around in.
12. snip
13. snip
14. snip
15. The diesel engines were not well-represented this year. (Gee, wonder
why?) I did see a burn-anything turbine engine that put out 350 horsepower
(?) while burning only 12 gal/hr. I have to admit that those rotary guys
may be on to something. Saw a few Mazdas with the Cook planetary PRSU's
that looked sano.
Wayne I will add a little to your comments concerning the rotary.
I am a long time Turboprop/Turboshaft/Jet/FreeTurbine engine technician.
I am also a long time certified recriprocating engine technician.
The rotary is as close to a turbine as you can come and not yet be a turbine in
smoothness.
Fuel burn is compatable with a recip.
Power can exceed most recips on a Hp per Lb basis, coming close to a turbine if
done right
Rotary size is as close to a turbine as you can come short of being a turbine.
Rotary longevity is as close to a turbine as you can get short of a turbine.
Catastropic failures in a rotary are less often and more improbable than even in
a turbine.
If done right automotive EFI is very compatable with the fuel controls on a
turbine.
Turbines have a couple of problems for the homebuilder--- Hotsection/compressor
inspections. ( not a big issue if you know what you are doing)
Initial cost. (although this is becoming less of an issue when comparing a
certified recip price to a turbine price)
Replacement parts costs. (again like the initial cost of the engine compared to
a certified recip)
Availability. ( This is easing up somewhat especially for the older engines)
High fuel burn per flight hr, as you noted.
A turbines good points are --
Continuous combustion engine, so no power pulses.
No recip/oscillating parts so very smooth, very little noticeable vibration.
At flight idle power is always there.
Can burn most combustable fuels. Not flammable fuels though.
Very small/lightweight per HP.
Very reliable. High TBO's.
A rotaty fits most of the turbines good characterists except of course the fuel
type.
It is an intermittent combustion engine, so some degree of power pulses.
No recip/oscillating parts, so very smooth.
The rotary is easily available. Prices are comparable to most auto recips.
Cost of parts is also comparable to most auto recips.
So to a lot of us the rotary is the best of both worlds.
Just my thoughts opinions etc on the issue.
Royce
16. snip
17. snip
18. Got 20 pounds of catalogs and documentation to sift through. It'll
keep me busy until next year's SNF. :-)
Me to.
Royce
=======================
L. Wayne Hicks
Senior Engineer
Zel Technologies, LLC
757-865-0900 phone
757-865-8960 fax
wayne.hicks@zeltech.com
http://www.zeltech.com
Good work Royce. Shows an excellent understanding of the issues.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org