Subject: Jim West fatal Coot crash.
From: ACRE NL
Date: 4/24/2002, 7:04 AM


Ken Welter wrote:

  Yes and as you remember I told you at Arlington last year that Jim
was a accident waiting for a place to happen as the engine
installation was a compleat abortion and in addition to that he had a
aft CG problem and he would not listen to me about it and I told him
that it would be prone to stalling and spinning in the event of a
engine failure, then a couple months ago on a taxi test when he
lifted the nose wheel off the ground the nose came up and with full
stick forward he could not get the nose down and it stalled at about
ten feet off the ground braking the nose gear and one main gear and
damaging the hull. He repaired the damage but I do not know if he did
anything about the weight and balance but you would think he would of
at that point.
  Ken Welter

Its always particularly sad to learn of an accident that likely could have
been prevented.  You can fool yourself and perhaps others, but you can not
fool the laws of physics and aerodynamics - at least, not for long. I did
not know Jim, but my condolences go out  to his family and those who did
know him.

Ed Anderson


What doesn't make sense here is how he got an airworthiness cert if his W&B was
off. FAA (and presumably DARs) are pretty strict about W&B calcs; at least my
FAA inspector was.

Finn


Yes but do they actually check it or do they check just the paper work?
There is a saying in the professional A&P world. "I pencil whipped it."
Meaning I signed it off without actually doing the work. In my experience

the FAA rarely checks anything other than the paper work.


 The coot and any pylon pusher plane has a very narrow CG range. The wing has a wider margin that it can be operated in but with this type of plane in the event of a engine failure the prop drag will pull the nose up. With the engine mounted high it will shift the weight aft when the nose comes up. For this reason you need to operate on the forward edge of the CG window of the wings specs. To complicate this the passenger weight is forward and changes the CG drastically and for this I have a 2.5 gallon fuel tank in the nose and a one gallon tank in the tail cone to shift the weight and keep the CG dead on 25 percent of the cord. Jim did not build his coot he just installed the rotary on a coot that he bought and there was two seven gallon tanks in the forward floor boards that I told him needed to be full to fly solo to keep it in CG and he did not believe me but I don't know if they were full at the time. The lake also has this problem and they have weights that they slide in and out of compartments in the front and rear.
 Ken Welter

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org