As I am slowly learning some of the powerful free software tools
at my disposal I have come up with this single graphic
that illustrates the importance of the exhaust pipe length
and a way of implementing it with a simple compact muffler
design that will fit under the cowl of most side by side
airplanes.
The chart is from Mazda SAE paper 841017.
BMEP is more or less the same as torque which at a given RPM
translates to HP. The higher the BMEP at any RPM the greater
the HP.
From this chart you can see that 31 inches is about right
and that is the length of the square pipe wrapped around the
muffler can. If somebody wants to build one of these I will
test it on our new dyno in about couple of months or so.
Paul Lamar
Yes I think it does to a certain extent but I am not entirely
sure to what extent. That data was taken with a p-port and a
relatively short intake pipe but I know not what diameter.
Diameter of the pipe also has an effect on tuning surprisingly.
Mazda did that because they were looking for good power
over a wide RPM range. Very important for a road racing car.
Here is a chart of P-port intake length verses BMEP from the same
SAE paper. I suspect we are running pipes a bit too long
for 6000 to 7000 RPM. I think Chuck Dunlap may be having this problem.
I removed my oil filler neck and will
be looking into a way of shortening the intake pipes just
a bit and still get oil in the engine. I will move the intake
plenum up over the rotor housing a bit.
The time has come for a little dyno tuning to nail some of this stuff
down for aircraft use.
Paul Lamar
A peak bmep of 144 psi sure does not look like any 120 percent volumetric
efficiency, when a garden variety Cont IO-360 pulls more than 170
Vance
That was for this particular test. As I said I have no idea what
the port size was. For all I know it was a one inch diameter
P-port. Mazda is not always totally fourth coming in their SAE papers.
The Leman engine was designed after these tests and the pipe size
chosen was huge. The Leman engine obviously has a volumetric efficiency
well over 100% over a very wide range of 6000 RPM to over 9000 RPM.
It is just plain common sense that a hole almost the size of the bore,
with no poppet valve getting in the way, is going to breath well.
If it were a complete study there would be a zillion curves
as one would have to vary pipe size AND length. 5 sizes and 5 lengths
would be twenty five curves. Not five curves or ten curves. Here is
a similar study on a piston engine and it too is far from complete.
Note the volumetric efficiency also exceeds 100%
This study provides evidence of why Chuck Dunlap's engine is down on power.
As the pipe is made smaller the optimum RPM is reduced and the
power falls off faster at higher RPMs. Chuck is using long pipes of
relatively small diameter so he is probably losing power around
6000 RPM and above. It took me a long time to figure out the
Mazda dynamic chamber but that is another story for another time.
Paul Lamar
I'm ready to hear the "another story" anytime Paul.
Royce
Keep reading :-)
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org