As I am slowly learning some of the powerful free software tools
at my disposal I have come up with this single graphic
that illustrates the importance of the exhaust pipe length
and a way of implementing it with a simple compact muffler
design that will fit under the cowl of most side by side
airplanes.
The chart is from Mazda SAE paper 841017.
BMEP is more or less the same as torque which at a given RPM
translates to HP. The higher the BMEP at any RPM the greater
the HP.
From this chart you can see that 31 inches is about right
and that is the length of the square pipe wrapped around the
muffler can. If somebody wants to build one of these I will
test it on our new dyno in about couple of months or so.
Paul Lamar
Joseph Berki wrote:
How would one build this muffler? Would it use pre-bent stainless pipe
welded together around the can?
No. All flat sheet.
Would the can be made from sheet plate
stainless?
Yes.
How difficult is stainless to cut?
Easy if you have a plasma cutter. Tracy Crook has one and might cut it
for
you if you send him the SS sheet and patterns. Most custom commercial
restaurant
kitchen builders deal with stainless all the time and probably have
a plasma cutter. Some have a computer controlled plasma cutter and you
merely enter the drawing.
If you made the square
stainless out of sheet that would require much welding.
Yes but stainless is very easy to tig weld if you back up the weld
area with inert gas. Any good welder will know how to do that.
Thanks for
converting kg/cm2 to psi
Joe Berki
Paul, I don't think the wrap around exhaust will be that easy to
build. Some welds may be difficult to reach Also, a ten inch
diameter muffler will force the use of a wider cowl. One of the strong
appeals of the rotary is the narrow foot print. Still, I think it
should be tried. My simple CAD abilities cannot deal with the shape of
the ellipse created when the sheet metal goes around the muffler at an
angle. Can you supply that for me? Please include the DXF. I would
like this better if the muffler was 4" diameter. Has nothing to do with
performance, just appearance. But what is the difference in
performance? I would build the prototype out of 604SS because the
muffler tube is available. Also, if the length of the muffler is
toward the firewall with the outlet at the rear, there will be less
conflict with MM tubing........Jerry
I have already given welding it some thought and some of the
welds will have to be done from inside the can. Then the
ends welded on. Or weld the square down pipe on the front
end with a 180 bend. Aft end with a S bend. Either
one will look cool :-) However I suspect that will result in
an increase in back pressure and a reduction in HP.
The rotary is 10 inches wide. Half of that is five.
Five and ten is 15 so in theory it will fit in a 30 inch wide cowl.
Give it another inch or three for clearance and you get a 36 inch
wide cowl. Most side by side airplanes are at least 40 inches wide.
My 182 is 48 inches wide. It will fit in my Kis Cruiser
cowl no problem. A TO4 turbo and HKS manifold sticks
out beyond that.
BTW don't overestimate the importance of making the cowl pointed
in the top view. It will do little if anything to reduce the drag.
It might help the prop efficiency a small amount. Max frontal area
is max frontal area and that usually occurs right where the pilot
sits in a side by side airplane. Old tandem airplanes like
the RV4 and three are another matter. The RV8 and other tandem
airplanes have the wider cowls.
I would be guessing about the difference in performance with a
four inch can. I suspect it would be less.
It will be awhile before I have time to do that ellipse
but it should not be hard. Perhaps some of the other math
types on here can do that for you. You could mock it up
in card board and transfer the pattern to the steel.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/ http://www.linux.org