Subject: Thermodynamics / Efficiencies / Practical ease
From: ACRE NL
Date: 5/8/2002, 6:46 AM

Paul Randall wrote:


Dear Paul
    I've been reading your stuff on the rotaries web page, and would like to make a few comments.
Many engine people just look at getting more power from their engines, with no idea of efficiency and not  much need for low weight or reliability. For aircraft you need it all, and it's a lot more challenging.

BSFC
    To know where we can make improvements in an engine's efficiency, we need some knowledge of its energy balance, or where the heat released from the fuel ends up. Some will heat up the chamber walls and has to be removed by the coolant and oil, and some will be just thrown away in the hot exhaust. The rest will be converted into mechanical energy, but some of this is lost again, turned back into heat by friction and pumping losses (air, oil and coolant.)  And then some more is consumed by the alternator and other accessories.     Only what's left can be applied to propulsion, and used to get meaningful BSFC figures.

    On a typical rotary, unblown, you say we may have a BSFC of 0.52, and an energy balance of  :-
A)    Exhaust heat              48%
B)    Coolant and oil          24%    (oil is 1/3 of this so coolant only is about 16%)
C)    Shaft output                28%
    The difference between this and most piston engines is probably a lower total cooling-system load but a lot higher exhaust heat, so this already gives some clues as to what we might do for improvements.

    In any case, better BSFC can only come through reducing losses, and there are very few options in this respect. For a start let's look at options inside the engine (any engine, that is)

(A) Change valve timing to give more-complete-expansion before exhaust opening.      Rather difficult for us on a rotary, so really a job for Mazda as on their latest 20B

(B) Use thermal barriers on the combustion chamber walls to try to keep the gas temperatures up so more power is available for expansion of the gas.       Only applicable to the rotor faces.

(C) Use much higher coolant temperatures.      This is interesting, but as it will need higher coolant flow-rates to avoid development of hot-spots through local boiling, it will require greater pumping power. The larger tube diameters and higher pressures in the cooling system will also increase system weight.

(D) Revise piston, seal and bearing designs to reduce friction losses.      Another job for Mazda.   Low-friction seal materials may become available, but till then are not really an issue for the private modifier, and rigid ceramics may not work well for side seals anyway.

(E) Use anti-friction coatings and/or additives, etc.      This is pretty normal practice now, and improved apex-seal lubrication is a good step in this direction too.


    Now let's look outside the basic engine. The greatest source of otherwise wasted energy we can tap is the exhaust heat, and we seem to have more of this available from a rotary than most piston engines.


 
Turbocharging
    Nowadays turbochargers are the prime example of more-complete-expansion, using heat energy to run the supercharger instead of stealing hard-won power from the crankshaft as was done previously. It's so much simpler too, no gearing or hydraulic drives, no inertia problems upon engine speed change, etc.


    Of course the higher charge mass ingested allows the engine to produce a proportionately greater output, but without any of this having to be used to turn the compressor. Therefore, all the power that can be produced within mechanical limits is available for propulsion, giving a better power to weight ratio.
    Turbocharged engines achieve a better BSFC because cylinder filling requires less work due to the positive boost pressure (there may even be a net power production during the inlet stroke), and because the engine does less of the work required to compress the same charge weight to the same pressure.


    Better installation aerodynamics, like getting a bit of thrust from the cooling system and from the exhaust were interesting steps 60 years ago and still very necessary on faster aircraft, but are of limited effect.
Rolls-Royce could have gained a lot more from turbocharging, including reducing the power required by the engine-driven blower, but did not want to even look at it so as not to lose their beloved exhaust thrust.


    Two-stage turbocharging has been done for many years by tractor-pullers and by Cummins in their NTTA -series engines, so you can get useful power from a second turbine, and probably even from a third ...



Compounding
    Adding another stage to the expansion is sort of like having a longer power stroke.There were compound steam engines in the 1800's, so why are people so leery of it? Possibly they think it's far too complicated, and the way Wright and Napier and others did it 60 years ago was sort of complicated.

   Wright added exhaust turbines to their R3350 of 2800HP and got an extra 550HP from them. They also beefed up the crank, put in a 2-speed drive to the compressor and added more cooling fin area, etc., getting 1500 HP more, all for the same fuel consumption. The new maximum was 3500HP, an increase of 25%. They also got 20% more range, indicating that cruise power was available at 16.7% less throttle setting due to the power recovered by the turbines.
    It must be remembered that all major aircraft engines of that era were mechanically supercharged, so the Wright Turbo-Compound was in effect just fitted with an extremely complicated turbocharger, give or take a few net horsepower going into the crankshaft. But due to the original compressor layout being retained they couldn't apply intercooling, which really is a pity.



Practicalities.
    We can definitely do better than that, and we must not repeat errors from the past. Some things are vital, but there's no point in complicating things that can be done in a simple manner. We want as few complex and inefficient power transfers as possible. Turbine-wheel inertia used to be a problem, requiring fluid couplings, etc. but this is reduced if radial inflow (rather than axial) turbines are used.


    Logically, we should first place a small high-speed turbine coupled directly to the compressor without any gearing requirement (a turbocharger), and then a separate lower speed turbine to extract more power and feed it back into the engine shaft, as gearing will be easier at a lower turbine speeds. The Scania layout you show is certainly logical.


 
    Variable compressor speed function is easily achieved using of a smaller A/R turbine housing plus a waste-gate, and energy spilled off here won't be lost, it's still available to the second stage.
    If any control is required on this second stage it could be through variable-geometry guide-vanes, which would certainly be lighter than any variable ratio drive, especially anything with Vee-belts. We may require at most a torque limiter to protect gearing. (We may be looking at something around 100 to 150 HP for this drive, if applied to the 900HP Racing-Beat engine.)
    With the rotary we have some pretty high gas temperatures, particularly on blown engines. The first stage needs to be inconel but fortunately the larger second stage will operate at a lower temperature so may be a Nickel-iron housing would suffice.


 
Other options
    The only other option would be a change of basic operating cycle. The Diesel cycle is more efficient than the Otto cycle due to the higher compression ratios, and so will give better economy and range without in any way undermining any external improvements we've looked at above. Unfortunately it is generally heavy due to the higher pressures, especially if one tries to work with 4-strokes. Of course gas-turbines go the other way, they're nice and light but thirsty due to generally very low compression ratios.


    One of the criticisms leveled at the Wankel was that it has too high a surface-to-volume ratio for use as a Diesel, and RR even made a two-stage Wankel diesel to get around this problem, a large rotor feeding compressed air through peripheral tranfer ports into a smaller chamber and then receiving back the first-stage exhaust for further expansion. It was really a sort of mechanical "turbocharger" set-up which happened to work at very low speeds where a turbo won't, and much more efficient than a Roots blower at high pressure ratios. The problem was simply loss of compression-heat, so should we not be talking rather about surface-to-charge-weight ratio? If so, a turbo can fix the problem, as can higher speed, higher temperatures, thermal barriers, etc.


    There are now all sorts of electronic aids not available 30 years ago, like common-rail electronic diesel injection, so it's no real problem to start on gas and switch to Jet-fuel once temperature and power are up. The use of catalyst surfaces (platinum, etc.) on rotor may be very useful in a diesel, but for gas would probably require direct injection rather than port injection to, avoid premature reaction.


    This avenue is very interesting, but probably beyond any private individual, unfortunately. I think that for the moment, for diesels it may be easier to go the Piston way.  Wonder what happened to the Merlyn diesel aero-engine made by Machen Engineering of Spokane, WA. (since taken over by INTECH or something)  It was a lightweight 3-cylinder uniflow 2-stroke, with turbo and Roots blower, turning out 650HP for only about 380 pounds.  ( ref. Aviation Week, October 1984 )  Also, the Russians did a lot of work on compounding and diesels in the late 40's and 50's that we hardly ever hear of, to power long-range bombers, but I doubt that it would be of help to us due to different size and temperature conditions.



    By the way, so far as centrifugal superchargers are concerned, there seems to be a good range available from  <<  procharger.com  >>  and perhaps their gearing systems could also be adapted for exhaust turbines.

With regards,
                Paul Randall
                    (New Zealand.)


The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org