Subject: NTSB Organization (was Coot Crash)
From: ACRE NL
Date: 6/23/2002, 6:16 PM


Perry Mick wrote:


Along with what I said in my previous post, I think somehow
we need to get the NTSB/FAA to contact Mr. Paul Lamar as
an aviation rotary engine expert should these events occur
in the future.  The local FSDO is usually the investigating
body, so each one would have to be made aware of this.
Not sure how the NTSB is organized.


As luck would have it, I was just reading an article on NTSB organization &
investigations in Flying magazine.  Apparently, the NTSB has several field
offices (Miami, Chicago, Atlanta, Washington DC, California, etc.) that do
all the "routine" GA crash investigations.  The people in these offices are
"generalists"; i.e. not experts on ANYTHING.  No college degree required, no
formal technical training, etc.  Usually a mix of experience and background;
everything from newly minted college grads to more experienced people with a
few thousand hours of GA air time.  The most senior/experienced usually have
some high performance and twin experience, instrument rating and perhaps a
commercial rating, but that's it.  No A&Ps, no engineers, etc.  I guess this
sort of makes sense since so many of the crashes are due to pilot error and
not mechanical or structural failure.

The real experts work out of the Washington DC office and focus only on the
big time crashes.  Probably because their human factors are so much better
and mechanical / structural failure is a much bigger factor.

Anyhow, the wonks looking into the Coot engine seizure are definitely on the
wrong track.  Perhaps we could also point out to them that there are a
ga-zillion miles on racing rotary engines with very high horsepower without
apex seal oil injection... and they don't seize.  I don't suppose Mazda-trix
or racing beat could weigh in on the issue?

Tom Kendall


 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org