Subject: Rotary displacement verses piston engine displacement
From: ACRE NL
Date: 6/28/2002, 7:37 AM


VJ - So it might be new, but it does not change any rules of
thermodynamic
nor Physics

True but as you admit the chamber expands over 270 degrees while both
the dyno-cam and a crankshaft piston engine  expand over 180 degrees.


No - the dyna cam expands over 90 degrees, and it could be 180 degrees or
45 degrees  by reshaping the cam, so long as it works in integers of the
four stroke
cycle, and none of those answers would negate the system I stated for
computing true displacement. 

As I recall I thought it was a skewed flat wobble plate last time I looked
at it in Torrance. That would make it 180 degrees. 45 degrees is
possible however but not practical. There is line contact between
the connecting rod rollers and the cam which limits the RPM presently
to about 1800 RPM due to high line contact stresses. This is why it is not 
practical to retrofit the Dynacam in existing airplanes as the 
landing gear is too short for the required  seven foot diameter props.
Are they still in business and still pushing worthless stock paper?

The fact that the Wankel expands over 270 degrees is
actually de facto evidence that you should not use that rotation for
displacement calculations. No one chamber completes the thermodynamic
cycle in one rotation, nor even two rotations. It takes three full turns for
one face to complete the four stroke cycle, and the other three then also
complete their cycles   EXACTLY AS AN EVEN FIRING THREE
CYLINDER FOUR STROKE ENGINE OF ANY OTHER
CONFIGURATION that would have 3:2 stepup of the output shaft).
The common P V diagram for the four stroke cycle makes no mention of
angles, nor even of stroke, but only volume changes that go from minimum
to maximum in four excursions (called "strokes" for convenience) The
integrated area within the curves can be equated to foot pounds of work
per cycle. The angular travel  some output shaft has no direct bearing
on this volume - it could even be a rack and pinion with 100 turns per
stroke and the displacement would be the same.
The rather high output rpm of the output shaft is an artifact of how
the cycle is mechanized, and I am sure that Herr Wankel would
have made it slower if he could.


Vance you are replacing the world wide acceptance of the defacto standard 
definition of piston engine displacement by the over simplified
dictionary definition. The piston engine world assumes 180 degree 
output crankshaft expansion. The over simplified dictionary definition states 
"The volume displaced by the stroke of a piston." You are trying to relate
the Wankel rotor motion to a piston and crankshaft and it is apples and oranges.
It is not a short stroke crankshaft and large rectangular piston. Accept that
fact.

Why would Felix Wankel want to slow it down? The HP generated per pound of
weight  in internal combustion engine is strongly related to the RPM at which 
max HP is generated. You yourself tout the power to weight ratio
of model aircraft engines that run up to 25,000 RPM or so. The only reason
geared large aircraft engines were limited to about 3500 RPM was because of the
inertia loads of the connecting rod and piston jerking up and down and dead 
stopping at top and bottom. Large aircraft piston engines evolved to 
more and more cylinders and high RPM when they were superseded
by gas turbines.  

Face it! Piston engines are obsolete for aircraft. The Wankel engine is
the current engine of choice for light aircraft and possibly for cars if Mazda 
perseveres. You are fighting a losing battle. Particularly on here.
This is the choir. To have owned one and understand it is to love it.

The Wankel is at the beginning of its development. The piston engine 
development is up against a brick wall. Any so-called "warts" the 
Wankel currently has will be designed out or designed around in the coming
years. Right now it is one company (Mazda) but it would not surprise me
if any day now Continental or Lycoming take up the Wankel cause.
It is a natural for light aircraft engines. In the near future we will have
some three rotors flying and more turbo charged 13B versions flying.
That will impress mightily and  open some additional minds to the 
Wankel aircraft engine.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org

dyno-cam.jpg