Subject: Lincoln vs. Miller welder
From: ACRE NL
Date: 8/8/2002, 10:21 PM


 > > Dean Head wrote:
 > >
 > > Group,
 > > Thought I would pick your collective brains. I want to purchase a TIG
 > > outfit. I was looking at the Lincoln Sq wave TIG 175 at S'n'F.
But now I see
 > > Miller has the Syncrowave 180SD. Any experience with either of
these units?
 > > I only have 60 amps avail in my shop without during some
rewiring. Also have
 > > access to a larger machine if necessary at work so the 175-180
amp will do
 > > most of what I want to do at home. My TIG experience to date does not
 > > include working with these more sophisticated welders. Tried
the Lincoln at
 > > S'n'F and it was quite nice on the scraps of aluminum. Thoughts?
 > > Thanks
 > > Dean Head


 > I have the Lincoln and it works well.
 >
 > Paul Lamar


 Dean, I have the Miller. It works extremely well on 53 amps (that
is the current it uses) I like
 it a lot. I tried the Lincoln and I am partial to the Miller
because of feel. It is a matter of
 preference though I am sure. Dealers that carry both will tell you
that the Miller provides better
 welds but in all honesty a welder is only as good as the person
welding. 1/4 inch aluminum is
 possible with the Miller. I havent tried the max with the Lincoln.
Please dont get suckered into
 the multi roll version welder. Make sure the welder you look at is
AC/DC no matter what your
 choice is. If it is only DC you will only be able to do steel and
such. You will need AC for
 aluminum if you choose.


   I just sold my 160 amp miller and got a Lincoln 275 amp square wave
and it is absolutely amazing how easy it is to weld with it, most of
all the clean cycle makes the cleaning of the metal nearly a thing of
the past. I have run a 175 amp Lincoln some and it seemed good but I
did not run it enough to draw a good opinion but for the most part I
am sold on Lincoln's.
  Ken Welter

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org