Subject: Please put a safety cable on your engine.
From: ACRE NL
Date: 8/13/2002, 4:40 AM


NTSB Identification: LAX02LA220

                            Accident occurred Friday, July 05, 2002 at
Pahrump, NV
                          Aircraft:Bushby Aircraft Mustang M-11,
registration: N30430
                                        Injuries: 2 Uninjured.

 This is preliminary information, subject to change, and may contain
errors. Any errors in this
report will be corrected when the final report
                                        has been completed.

On July 5, 2002, about 1200 hours Pacific daylight time, an experimental
Lazaro/Bushby Mustang M-11,
N30430, experienced a propeller
blade failure during cruise flight, resulting in a forced landing on a dry
lake bed near Pahrump,
Nevada. The personal flight was operated
under 14 CFR Part 91. Neither the private pilot nor his passenger were
injured. The airplane
sustained substantial damage. Visual
meteorological conditions prevailed, and no flight plan was filed. The
flight originated at Pahrump
at an undetermined time.

The pilot contacted a Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) inspector at
Las Vegas, Nevada, and
reported that he had experienced a
propeller blade failure while en route to Pahrump. He stated that post
accident examination of the
airplane revealed that 21 inches of a
propeller blade had separated. The propeller is an aluminum two bladed
McCauley fixed pitch.

According to the pilot, the resultant imbalance resulted in substantial
damage to the airframe,
leaving the engine hanging by one 3/8-inch
bolt.

This sort of scene has been played in my mind too many times.  I guess it's
my physics and engineering background that puts the respect into this kind
of out of balance situation.  That being said I've got some kind of
solution that may be what the safety cable is about.  I don't know, I've
never seen one.

When a prop sheds a blade or part of one, the prop flange end of the engine
will want to orbit about the new center of mass of that end of the
engine.  This can be calculated if you have an approximate idea where the
prop is going to break.  The (in our case) water pump end would only see a
sort of gimbal like motion.

If the safety cable were wrapped around the prop flange end at about the
motor mount station and had enough slack such that the prop flange end of
the engine, after throwing a blade, would "orbit" inside the loop of safety
cable.  Then the safety cable would effectively cage the engine in the loop
but isolate the shake from the airframe.  This of course after the engine
broke loose from the front mounts (yeah I know, this is a stretch if MY
imagination).  The engine would still be restrained fore and aft by the
rear mounts provided they had the range of motion both up/down and sideways
so that the prop flange could do its orbit without pulling the rear mounts
loose.

All this would maybe give you enough time to shut down the engine before it
made the airplane unrecoverable.

The engineering questions arising (assuming a bed mount) are:
1. Is the "tear loose" force of the out of balance prop going to be higher
than the negative-G design load of the front mount?  On a metal prop it
could be, on a composite or wood maybe not.  It would need to be.

2. The safety cable loop diameter would be a function of prop weight,
engine nose weight, and where you thought the prop would break.  I seem to
recall that the amount of prop lost in the above event is common?

Well, this turned into a bit of a read.  Am I on the right path with this
safety cable?

Mike McGee, RV-4 N996RV, O320-E2G, Hillsboro, OR
13B in gestation mode

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org