Subject: Please put a safety cable on your engine.
From: ACRE NL
Date: 8/13/2002, 2:54 PM


--> > NTSB Identification: LAX02LA220

                            Accident occurred Friday, July 05, 2002 at
Pahrump, NV
                          Aircraft:Bushby Aircraft Mustang M-11,
registration: N30430
                                        Injuries: 2 Uninjured.

 This is preliminary information, subject to change, and may contain
errors. Any errors in this
report will be corrected when the final report
                                        has been completed.

On July 5, 2002, about 1200 hours Pacific daylight time, an
experimental
Lazaro/Bushby Mustang M-11,
N30430, experienced a propeller
blade failure during cruise flight, resulting in a forced landing on a
dry
lake bed near Pahrump,
Nevada. The personal flight was operated
under 14 CFR Part 91. Neither the private pilot nor his passenger were
injured. The airplane
sustained substantial damage. Visual
meteorological conditions prevailed, and no flight plan was filed. The
flight originated at Pahrump
at an undetermined time.

The pilot contacted a Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) inspector
at
Las Vegas, Nevada, and
reported that he had experienced a
propeller blade failure while en route to Pahrump. He stated that post
accident examination of the
airplane revealed that 21 inches of a
propeller blade had separated. The propeller is an aluminum two bladed
McCauley fixed pitch.

According to the pilot, the resultant imbalance resulted in
substantial
damage to the airframe,
leaving the engine hanging by one 3/8-inch
bolt.


I have been trying to decide where to hook up a safety cable on my tube
and
fabric Sportsman. Right now
I am thinking that a tab on each upper 3/8" bolt that holds the mount to
the
airframe is the stongest place to
attach. This guy said there was only one 3/8 bolt left. Would this be at
the
rubber isolation mount?
Is the weak point out at the rubber mounts or where the mount bolts to
the
airframe?
Also if I use 2 cables is 1/8" heavy enough?
Lonnie

Got a picture of the fuselage frame Lonnie?
Here is an old  picture of your motor mount.

I would drill a couple of small holes in the firewall and run a 1/4 inch
cable
in one hole, around one or more major steel tubes and back out the other
hole and
around
the engine some place. Safety wire the cable where it comes out of
the firewall and apply a little red RTV to seal the holes.

Here is a scan of the Sportsman fuse.
Run the cable behind all four of these tubes just behind the firewall.

BTW You must be getting close to first flight. How is it coming?

Paul Lamar


That drawing is the same as my airframe at the engine mount area.
It looks like to me the strongest place to attach a cable is where the
5 tubes come together at the upper bolt locations. Therefore it
seems like attaching cables to the 3/8 bolts would be the stongest
way of tying into that cluster. If you simply wrap a cable around
a couple of  .035 wall tubes I would think the tubes could be ripped
easily.
Why a 1/4 inch cable? 1/8 cable is rated at about 2000 lbs. If I use
2 that would be 4000 lbs.  If the cables do not have much slack then
there would be little shock loading. I read one account of a biplane
with a radial engine where the engine was just hanging by the throttle
cable.

I just sent the computer back to Tracy yesterday. It ran once on #1 computer
for about a minute. When I tried to start again #1 primary injector stayed
open.
Did not stay open on #2 computer. Ran for about 15 seconds on #2 but badly.
Checking the timeing while cranking found the timing marks jumping all
around.
Hope Tracy can tell me if there was a problem with the computer or something
with my wiring.
Still have painting and covering to do, but wanted to get initial engine
runs first.

BTW Paul, I modified the mounts as shown in that picture to 3 tubes per
point as you suggested. I feel better about them now.
Lonnie

It is up to you. Steel has the ability to absorb energy by yielding.
The engine could flail all over the place if a prop blade came
off. If the tubes can bend they might absorb more energy than if the cable
was attached to a ridged place. Also the sheet metal firewall adds to the
material that must be ripped apart and that too will absorb energy.

Why not use a 1/4 inch cable to be on the safe side? There is little
difference in the cost or weight.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.              Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            http://www.linux.org