Subject: rotary vs turbine
From: ACRE NL
Date: 9/13/2002, 2:30 PM


Jon Potter wrote:

I am not a pilot or an engineer, but couldn't resist your site (I have at
least driven an RX-7)

Why not devote all this energy to perfecting small turbine engines?  That
seems to be the direction of these rotary innovations. See Eclipse 500
aircraft, etc.

Thanks in advance.

The laws of geometric scaling are against small turbofans.
IMHO the Eclipse 500 is a stock scam and $100 million tax fraud.

Each year I ask Williams at OSH what the ratio of
the weight of fuel burned to pound of thrust developed by the
Williams small turbofan engine installed in the Eclipse 500.
They refuse to answer.

If you never build anything or build something
and don't put it in the hands of an objective observer to test
it...  it becomes just more vapor wear. Don't hold your breath
and don't invest until (or if) it becomes a proven product.

Paul Lamar

They just had their first flight and don't sell stock...  Of course that
doesn't mean that it is going to perform like they say it will.  I too have
my doubts about that engine, but eclipse appears pretty solid.

Hans

http://www.eclipseaviation.com/

Perhaps not.
But they do take deposits. As I understand it the deposits are
non-refundable after the first flight. They can now go bankrupt
at any moment with no financial obligations.

The other thing about small jets is range. The storage volume of
a fuel tank goes up with the cube of the linear dimensions.

Let us say a Cessna Citation tank is equivalent to a tank
of 10' by 1' by 5' or 50 cubic feet.  Fuel volume would be  378
gallons. Lets say the Eclipse is half scale.

Lets say the Eclipse tank is equivalent to a tank 5' by .5' by
2.5' or 6.25 cubic feet or 47 gallons. Lets give it the benefit
of the doubt and say they somehow squeezed in 100 gallons. Typical
for larger four place airplanes like the 182. How far do
you think you are going to get in a twin jet with 100 gallons?

Can we really believe the Williams engine fuel burn is going
to be 100/375 or 26% of what a Citation burns for the same range?
The smaller Citations already have limited range.
Long range is a safety issue. I have had to turn back after
flying for several hours in SE Alaska due to bad weather. All the
way back!

As I said.... a scam pure and simple.

Paul Lamar

I should have checked the web site. Eclipse is claiming 
1330 pounds of fuel or at 6 pounds per gallon 221 gallons.
Good trick considering the main gear is stored in the thin jet wings.
Wing span is 36 feet and the 182 is 37 feet so I kind
of doubt they have 221 gallons in the wings. There must
be a 130 gallon fuselage tanks somewhere near the CG.
130 times 232 cubic inches per gallon is  30,160 cubic inches.
That would take a fuse tank 60 inches by 60 
inches by 8.4 inches. Well perhaps.

Endurance claimed is 3.66 hours or 60 gallons an hour for both engines.
That right there is out of my price range at $2 bucks a gallon.

Anybody have the specs for a Cessna Citation? The Cessna
site is not talking. All fluff and no claims.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.