Snip
It is Sad to hear about anyone going down, but its especially hard
to take
after meeting and talking with those fine fellows and then having
the judges
refuse to award an "Auto Conversion" award they had just instituted
and
announced. Tracy's somewhat more descriptive comment adequately
describes
how we all felt. While our rotary conversions may have been
considered
"Cosmetically Challenged" by the judges, this V-6 installation was
really
nice and clean and surely would have qualified as a "Show Quality"
aircraft
anywhere else regardless of engine.
I was so Pi__ed, I send an e mail to the EAA Judging Head Honcho and
outlined what I believe is the core cause of this miscarriage of
judging. I
examined the EAA Judging handbook (which most chapters use as a
basic for
judging), while it is quite thorough, it basically boils down to 1.
Is it
safe and airworthy and if it is, 2. How pretty is it? Since most
judges
would not have the background to adequately judge an auto conversion
on
their own, I think a basic auto conversion standard added to the EAA
judging
handbook would help those fine folks who devote their time to
judging. I
suggested that auto conversions deserved a more meaningful standard,
as
those who spend time on making an auto conversion safe and reliable
are
still flying the "Experimental" banner for the EAA and are no less
deserving
that those who spend that time making their airframes prettier. I
doubt
anything will come of it, but should they throw the gauntlet back, I
will be
asking for suggestions from folks on the list.
Calmed down somewhat, but still Pi__ed.
Ed Anderson
Hey Ed, I understand your concerns, but often times more then not, an
uneducated group of
individuals can be appointed to judge airplanes. Just like I saw as OSH,
there were judges talking
about color of aircraft rather then technical merit. It is a shame that
they have such a view as
maybe your installation does not appeal to a color blind judge BUT in
all honesty when my aircraft
makes it to a show in the future, I hope that you or anybody else on
this list will judge my
airplane and come up to me and say that I got a Grand Champion because
it would mean more to me
from someone that has sweated and toyeled over their projects and really
knows what went in to
making an experimental aircraft. I dont need a color blind judge to tell
me how pretty it is. I
can live with out those people. Education is the key. I will do my part
and educate one person at
a time. Hopefully before I die, there will be enough educated people
that can reflect back to what
the EAA is really about and not a couple of liberal arts majors picking
out colors!
Doug Mueller
RX-6 13BT
N900DM
Henderson,Nevada
Thanks, Doug
I agree with your assessment and I think many of us do. Not to take
away from those who have the talent and dedication to produce a "Show
Plane", I for one admire what it takes. With so many kit built planes now a
days, cosmetic differentiation is about all you can expect in many cases.
However, I believe most of us on the list feel that auto conversions simply
needs a different criteria about what is important. I certainly don't hold
it against the judges who volunteer their time and have to go by the
criteria in the EAA Judging Handbook (for the most part).
I almost immediately received a somewhat irate e mail from the SERFI
(apparently the EAA immediately sent it to them and I probably should have
done the same) and we continue to disagree on some points (including the
cosmetic aspect of judging and whether experimentation is still a focus of
the EAA). However, the good news appears to be that the SERFI has appointed
an Auto Conversion board with Dick Simpson as its head to work out a
meaningful criteria. While much remains to be done on establishing a
criteria, it appears that the point has been make that the focus should be
on the FWF aspects. A couple of their initial thoughts on criteria was not
that bad and if they maintain that focus, just might come up with a
meaningful set.
For example, the judging would be limited to auto conversions done by
individuals and no factory FWF kits would qualify . One the other hand you
won't have to build your own PSRU as that - and certain other components
(not defined as yet) could be purchased. However, if you did build your won
PSRU you would probably garner more points. Aircraft appearance would not
be completely done away with, but would probably be used more as a "tie
breaker" between auto conversions.
In any case, I have offered to pull together some criteria for input to this
committee. You know how it goes, if you complain then your' asked to put up
or shut up {:>). I would appreciate any suggestions as to approach and
criteria input. I personally think that perhaps a FWF should be first
broken into areas such as: Engine Mount. PSRU. Engine. Ignition. Fuel
System, etc. Then perhaps a set of common criteria for each section such as
1. Soundness of Design 2. Reliability 3. Fail safe/graceful considerations
or what ever makes sense and can be judged. Perhaps there should also be an
"Innovation factor" for extra points? No doubt subjective will still be
there in the judging, but this would help. So send me any suggestions and
I'll try to organize and pull it all together and then present it to the
list for comments.
One thing of interest, they indicated that they are considering requiring
"Technical Data" and perhaps "Drawings". While I think this could be good,
it could turn into a paper mill, so any thoughts in this area would be
appreciated.
Ed (Stir up the Pot) Anderson
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.