Subject: sanity check - tension bolt issue resonent freq.
From: ACRE NL
Date: 10/30/2002, 8:16 AM


Mr dan ruggirello wrote:

I posted earlier (@ flyrotary) that I was skeptical
that the tension bolt issue was vibration since my gut
feel was the bolt was much stiffer than 110hz (6500
rpm).  Well, I just estimated the 1st mode natural
frequency and low and behold, I calculated a frequency
of 150hz.  Too close for comfort!!!

Specifics:
fixed at one end, pinned at the other
diameter: 10mm
length: 273mm-10mm ~263mm (10mm thread enguagement)
E: 30 msi
I: 1.18E-3 in^4
density: .30 lbs/in^3

Yup, very likely it's vibration/fatigue.  Now my
question is if the RTV or shrink wrap is effective and
reliable......

I will probably calculate a fatigue life on the stock
bolt, use the RTV and replace the bolts every so often
based on fatigue life or go to a higher strength bolt
(given it meets the fatigue life) for added margin of
safety.  (I think I saw a higher strength after market
bolt).  This seems like a case where the bolts were
engineered for an average automobile environment where
continuous/frequent high rpms are not a design
consideration.

I am not that familar with the bolt, anyone know what
the stock bolt material is?  Is the bolt diameter
equal to or less than the minor thread diameter?

Dan

Thanks Dan. Funny you should mention that as Richard and
I were talking about it on Monday at his place. Some are cut down
and some are full diameter 10 mm (new ones). I have no idea what
the material is but I am sure it is some sort of high strength
steel.

BTW Richard is thinking of offering a service to check used
bolts for cracks by measuring the resonant frequency.
New bolts are $17 each from Mazda.

Paul Lamar

Don't forget that resonant components can respond to harmonics as well.  My
cruise rpm is in the range of 4500 to 5200 rpm.  This equates to a frequency
range of 75 - 86Hz.  The second harmonic would be 150 - 173 Hz.  This isn't
close, it's dead on!

Having said that, I am fairly confident that damping the bolt near the
center will eliminate the problem.  Tune in again in a few years when I
again hit the hour mark where my tension bolt failed.

Interestingly, my old engine had the early bolts which had a shank necked
down to a smaller diameter than the threads.  These bolts had almost twice
as many hours (not even counting the hours in the car) as the brand new full
diameter shank bolts in my current engine.  The old engine never had a bolt
failure in 856 hours of flight.

Tracy Crook
tcrook@rotaryaviation.com
www.rotaryaviation.com

Perry Mick's failed tension bolt was the necked down version.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.