-Mr dan ruggirello wrote:
Can't help piping in about whether it was a shear
or
moment failure. After looking at the solid of the
bolt deformation that Paul supplied, looks to me
like
it was failure from shear and a moment.
For one, you can't get that bolt to deflect like
that
without having both shear and a moment. Just draw
a
free body diagram. Assuming it's a ductile
material,
looks like it failed because it was outside the
vonMises ellipse. Which contibuted more? You
would
probably have to solve the indeterminant structure
using a finite element model to find out.
My two cents worth.
Dan-
My definition of a bolt in shear consist of two or
more plates side
by side tending to move in opposite direction with
the bolt passing through
them. If the plates are not side by side and
separated by a finite
distance I think Roark would call that a beam with
both ends supported
with an opposite couple on both ends. I could be
wrong. Unfortunately Roark
does not have a formula for it as far as I can find.
You would still need to find the moment and shear
force to calculate the stress and/or margin.
The parts introducing
the couples into the end of the beam (bolt) also
must be analyzed as they could
be weaker than the bolt and fail before the bolt.
I agree. Whenever there is a moment on a bolt, there
is a high potential that you will have a fitting
bearing stress failure leading to a failure of the
fitting. But the bolt is also susceptable to failure.
Not good design practice to have a bolt moment,
alright to have a bolt carrying shear if you can avoid
the moment (tight tolerance assembly) and best to have
bolt only carry tension. Pretty much what you said
about good mount design, Paul.
Be
very interesting
to do an FEA on the configuration.
Well, Ed offered the AN tubing, so what the hell, I'll
offer the FEA, static and maybe dynamic to boot! Our
kit doesn't get here for another two weeks and I've
been wanting to try out the non-MSC version of NASTRAN
for awhile anyhow.
Dan
Thanks a bunch Dan. REALLY glad to have you onboard.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.