I have seen an interesting study on oil filters. The comparison
of all commercially available filters were used with interesting results.
The high end
of oil filters was those available from Amsoil.They were superior in
filtration ability
but they came at a price. Of all the available filters on the market, FRAM
and Wicks
tested the worst with poor materials and common failure of parts, like
bypass
valves. Interesting enough I got the data from a rotary enthusiast off of
his web site.
It showed for the money that AC-Delco rated highest in materials and quality
for the
money of most available filters. Mazda uses superior filters as well but
that is
usually a dealer item and will generally pay as much as an Amsoil filter. The
remote set ups that we use lend themselves to easy Amsoil adaptability. I am
partial to the lubricants that they produce but I was not involved in the
study. I am
just the messenger.
> > > > > Doug Mueller
> > > > > RX-6 13BT
> > > > > Henderson,NV
I think a real comparison would have to include efficiency at a specific
micron rating. Burst strength would be another important requirement. I once
blew a Fram PH8A off of a double element housing with a stock Fiat pump at 80
PSI.
I don't see in the results that Wix is one of the bad boys. Fram is the
real goat of the bunch. It should be noted that all of the manufacturers fill
in their catalogs with elements from their competition. So if Wix has no
element for the Fairthorp Electron Minor, they will sell a Champion for that
application. In a Wix box at the NAPA store, but it is a Champion. So you
might buy a Fram that was made by Champion and you might buy A Pruolater that
was made by Wix.
I use a pair of K&N filters on a dual mount. They flow 16 GPMs each and
have a burst of 450 PSI. This is a cross for the APH8A/ Lee FL1 etc. Two
would be too heavy for aircraft use but one would be just fine. I am looking
for 85-95 PSI at speed
(9,500) RPM, so one filter for 6,500 RPM should be more than enough.
Lynn E. Hanover
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.