Al Gietzen wrote:
I was considering getting my manifold coated on the inside in an effort
to reduce wall temps and
heating in the cowl. Before committing to the cost I want to know how
much it will really help;
seemed suspicious to me that the very thin coatings (.005-.010") would
provide anywhere near the
temp reductions claimed by Jet-Hot.
I estimated the heat flux from a 1600F wall by conduction, natural
convection, and radiation to
total about about 5 watts/sq-cm. Most of this is by radiation. If you
have air blowing over the
surface it might go up by a few W/sq cm.
I called Jet-Hot to get the thermal conductivity of the coating. They
refuse to provide any
engineering data of any kind. They did tell me that the coating on the
inside would only be about
0.001"; and about .005" on the outside.
It is hard to imagine that the thermal conductivity could be less than a
ceramic, so using that, a
.001" coating gives a temp drop of a whopping 6 C, or about 10 F drop in
wall temp. Adding
another .005-.010" on the outside may drop the temp a total of about
100F.
So unless you're doing it to make your manifold and pipes look nice (or
I've made an error in my
calcs - entirely possible) these coatings are a waste of money;
especially a .001" coat on the
inside. No wonder they don't give out any engineering info.
Al Gietzen
Except for one thing Al and I am not saying this because I necessarily
think its true.
I am just saying it is a possibility. Steel and SS tends to oxidize at
high temp.
If you can keep the oxygen away from the surface they might not corrode so
badly
and perhaps last longer. Mild steel flakes off in large chunks when used
for
rotary engine exhaust.
Paul Lamar
Mark Wrathall wrote:
Paul may be right about the reduced corrosion, but I'd tend to agree with Al
on this concerning heat reduction. The TBC (Thermal Barrier Coating) which
GE uses on all the flow path components of the GE90 between the combustion
chamber and the stage 2 HPT nozzles is certainly much thicker than 1-5 thou.
I have no data on how thick, but when it flakes off, mostly due impact, it
would appear to be over 10 thou thick.
Mark.
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.