Subject: Aircraft Applications (was: Newbie application questions)
From: ACRE NL
Date: 1/30/2003, 10:27 PM


Vince Orton wrote:

(Reply to MegaSquirt Yahoo List.  FYI for Aircraft Rotary Engine List.)

Steve Rothert -

Well, YES, there ARE people thinking about MegaSquirting their aircraft
(see attached replies below).  The FAA rules are a little more strict,
as you can imagine, but that's what EXPERIMENTAL aircraft are for,
right?  At least we don't have any smog nazis with aircraft - hell,
aviation gas still uses TONS of lead!  (As in Leaded Gas...)

For the rest of you on the list, please pardon me while I go off-topic a
bit ...

With this last Group Buy (GB) I got a MegaSquirt (MS) kit for my '76
Toyota LandCruiser 4x4.  Depending upon your RELATIVE viewpoint, you
could say I get into pretty rough terrain with rock crawling.  Often the
truck operates at extreme angles (say, ~60 degrees up or downhill, or
~30-40 degrees on a side), and carbs don't work well at those angles -
it messes up the float levels, burns rich/lean, etc.  The last thing you
want when climbing a waterfall is to stall out near the top!!  (It's a
long way down ... backwards ... with limited rear view ... and no power
brakes, steering, etc.  Sphincter City, you know.)

Upon getting experience with with the MS, the 4x4, tuning, problem
resolution, reliability testing, etc., I'll put TWO more kits on my
aircraft engine.  Why TWO you ask?  One active, one backup, on separate
electrical busses, and connected to the injectors through selector
switches.  Other redundancy is being considered as well, like separate
injectors, fuel rails, fuel pumps, etc.  I'm just trying to balance
redundancy with reality - I don't want to introduce more failure modes
than I resolve with redundant hardware.

I probably will go through the code and do some tweaking and
simplifying.  I'll see what's already done first, naturally.  Aircraft
applications are quite different from automobile applications.
Examples: 80% full time power is normal; changing altitude is ALWAYS a
factor; pilots usually control mixture themselves for various
conditions, etc.

If I decide NOT to MS my aircraft, I'll go with Tracy Crook's aviation
EFI unit - VERY reasonably priced, and the engineering is sound.
(They're flying right now.)  (See links below.)

I will be using a Mazda Rotary (Wankel) engine.  Why you ask?  It has
far fewer failure modes than a piston engine, and is much, much
stronger, durable, and reliable.  Those of you that know Wankel engines
probably know why they are superior.  For those that don't, here is a
quick list:
- Only 3 moving parts for a two-rotor Wankel
   - vs. -
- MINIMUM of 28 moving parts for a 4-cyl piston engine
  (What do you want in YOUR aircraft?  You can't just pull over!)
- No valves to burn (80% power full time, remember)
- Can run exceptionally lean at power
- Eccentric shaft is HUGE & STRONG compared to crankshaft
- Wankels breathe exceptionally well (did I read ~130% VE?)
- Huge power-to-weight ratio (it's lightweight)
Very important: Aluminum expands at a lower temp than steel.  In an
overheated piston engine the aluminum piston expands and seizes in the
steel cylinder - zero power.  In a Wankel engine the aluminum housing
expands before the steel rotor, losing compression & power - BUT IT
STILL WORKS.  A while back, a Wankel powered aircraft lost coolant
completely.  The pilot reduced power and flew to the nearest airstrip
and made a safe landing - under power.  Once the ignition was switched
off, the engine never started again - BUT pilot and plane made it down
safely!  Again - what do you want in YOUR aircraft?

I could enumerate many more advantages, but others have done it
already.  Check out:

http://www.rotaryengineillustrated.com for great Wankel info - Blake
Qualley, YOU DA MAN!  (Now go post new info to your site, darn it!
Finish your "Rotary Engine 101" and "Advanced Topics" pages!)

http://rotaryaviation.com for Tracy Crook's aviation products - great
stuff!  He's a fountain of practical information and it's application in
the real world.  I'll use his stuff on MY aircraft.  'Nuff said.

http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng for LOTS of Aviation Wankel info.
Wacky Paul Lamar does an excellent job running the newsletter and
guiding brainstormers through to products, kind of like "open-source"
solutions for rotary aviation.  (Like MS!)

There's lots of good reading, graphics, and animations in those links -
save them and check them out when you get the chance.

My choice to investigate the MS for aircraft use is just an extension of
this "simple is good" mentality.  Tracy Crook already has an excellent
EFI/Electronic Ignition product, but I should AT LEAST take the
opportunity to learn more about speed-density EFI on the ground (in my
LandCruiser).  MS is that opportunity.

I have to run now, but let me know if you want more info.

Thanks,
-Vince Orton

Wacky? I have been called a lot of things but that is the first time for "Wacky" :)

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.