"Del Johnson, North Point Solutions, Inc" wrote:
>
> I contacted a company (Shapiro Supply Co, St. Louis, MO) that I have
ordered
> small quantities of aluminum tubing and asked if they could supply
Inconel
> 625 tubing and whether they would handle a group purchase (i.e. receive
> orders, credit card numbers from each person in the group, get the
material
> from their supplier and cut it up, package and ship to each person in the
> group the quantity that they requested).
>
> For purposes of pricing I told him to assume that we could get a group
order
> for 100' of 2" - 0.035 wall thickness 625 Inconel. He came back with the
> following quotes
>
> If he purchased 100' of tubing in 20 foot lengths he could sell it to us
at
> $55/foot. However, he would have to cut up the Inconel into pieces such
> that there would be no waste. This goes for all the other quotes which
> follow. It would take his supplier about 6 weeks to deliver since they
do
> not have the 20 foot lengths in stock.
>
> He could get his hands on 10' lengths of the same material within a week.
> However the price per foot for a 100 foot order is 78.50. In other
words
he
> can get the 20' length tubing quite a bit cheaper than the 10' length
> tubing.
>
> He also quoted a price of $92.25 for a 40 foot quantity order, assuming
we
> only can mobilize a small group purchase. This material at this rate
would
> come in 10 foot sections which he would cut up to whatever size each
> individual in the group needs.
>
> Again, he cannot realize cost of any wastes.
>
> To compare these prices to straight 2" Stainless Steel (321) I pulled the
> following prices from Burns Stainless site:
>
> 0.065 gage $30.10 1.34 lbs./ft
> 0.049 gage $22.64 1.02 lbs./ft
> 0.035 gage $20.55 0.73 lbs./ft
>
> I don't have the weight for 0.035 gage Inconel 625 but it would probably
> slightly more than SS of the same size. From what users have said, you
> probably need 0.049 or 0.065 gage SS for exhaust stacks whereas you can
> probably get by with 0.035 Inconel. The Inconel is about twice as
expensive
> (assuming we buy at $55/ft), lighter and more durable.
>
> I assumed that 2" diameter tubing was the correct size but for the Mazda
but
> if I'm wrong we can get revised prices for 1-3/4". There might be an
> additional price break at a high quantity and we might be able to get
even
> better prices if we went out for bid on the stuff. However, I like the
> friendly arrangement that I have worked out with Shapiro (assembling
> individual orders, billing and shipping individually for each member in
the
> group purchase).
>
> Here is the route that I propose that we take:
>
> 1. Paul, before this note gets distributed would you make your
> recommendations on the tube diameter/gage for the Inconel purchase.
> 2. All others that are interested please respond back with the quantity
of
> tubing (at the diameter/gage that Paul recommends) that you would be
> interested in.
> 3. I will then get back with Shapiro for final pricing, payment methods,
> expected delivery time.
> 4. I will then notify everyone via ACRE the final price quote and ask
place
> your order with Shapiro wants and arrange payment directly with them.
>
> When I tried to get interest in a group purchase on Inconel bends I only
got
> 4 or 5 responses. I think the problem is that a lot of people don't have
> their exhaust design started and have no idea the bend size and quantity
> needed. We might look for a company that would bend our tubing after we
> have purchased the straight pieces on a piece by piece basis.
>
> There is almost always some Inconel material being sold on E-bay. I
picked
> up some 1-1/2 tubing at about $6/foot. I also picked up some Inconel
filler
> rod. A friend of mine who is a master welder is practicing tig welding
this
> material. You might want to get some of the surplus Inconel and have
your
> welder (or yourself) do some sample welds before committing to the $55
> material.
-Lehanover@aol.com wrote:
The CART cars use Inconel headers, but replace them at very short intervals
because they crack quite often. They only support their own weight which is
not much at all, and still they crack. In the case of CART the tubes are very
thin walled. True, they will stand up to ridicules temperatures but so will
stainless. The thin wall Inconel cannot be stressed while it is hot. Some
sort of slip joint would have to be included so that the weight of the pipe
is not hanging on the flange. The bends are formed from sheet stock in
multiple pieces and welded up, instead of being bent up from tubes. So, the
outside of a bend is the same wall thickness as the inside. This should be
the case in any design and since thick wall stainless bends are so cheap and
available, why Inconel? It is impossible to get both headers to take on the
same shape as the outside of the bends heat up like crazy while the insides
run cooler and the pipes curve away from the hot side. They squirm around
like snakes. If they are rigid from the flange to the collector without a
slip joint, one or the other of them will eventually fail near a fixed end. A
picture of such a failure was posted on this site.
A thoughtfully designed stainless system can nearly match Inconel in weight
and is half the cost.
Lynn E. Hanover
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.