Subject: Failure modes- - - detonation
From: ACRE NL
Date: 2/22/2003, 10:41 AM


   >wmd wrote:
   >>
   >> I spoke to a friend the other day who does a fair amount of road racing and
   >> he rruns an engine shop. He likes the rotary for its power and size but is
   >> critical of it in that it is susceptible to detonation, which if it occurs
   >> damages the seals and ruins the engine---not to the point of catastrophic
   >> failure but  a reduction in power immediately and further over time.
   >> What steps can be taken to prevent this in an aircraft engine application ?
   >> Has anyone experienced this problem.
   >>
   >> Comments ?
   >>
   >> bill


   >Only the turbo is affected by this problem. The NA engine rarely detonates.
   >With the turbo use 3 mm Hurley Engineering  two piece steel apex seals.
   >The 2 mm  three piece cast iron seals were developed by Mazda to improve
   >the low RPM/low HP fuel consumption and emission problem. They have no
   >benefits at high RPM and high power in a turbo engine. The two piece
   >steel apex seals are much more rugged and less prone to fracture
   >under detonation.
   >
   >Paul Lamar

 The detonation you mention only really occurs because the 13B is strong enough to withstand more boost than other engines can tolerate, and only becomes a big problem when using enough boost to produce more than 400-500h.p.  I don't think anyone would try to get more than 300 h.p. out of a 13B in aircraft use.  It doesn't mean you can't detonate at the lower power, but it is no more likely to detonate than other engines.  Some of the racers are getting more than 600hp out of the 13B.  The fact that they do that on largely stock components is what really sold me on the rotary.

If you want to set the time-2-climb record you should change out the apex seals like Paul mentions, but it is really not necessary for most aircraft applications.  In fact, even 3mm apex seals will not protect the engine from damage if -it does detonate. They just hold up better to the very high pressures involved with running high h.P.

Dave Leonard


 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.