kevin lane wrote:
kevin lane wrote:
i plan to install a belly scoop on my -8. i think i can route the
plumbing
under the cabin floor. what do people think about running simply
radiator
hose vs some type of aluminum? i planned to use 1" inside dia. hose or
pipe. does flex aluminum come in 1", maybe for A/C uses perhaps? that
would eliminate fittings and potential leaks although i would have to
insulate it i would guess. any ideas? kevin 3 rotor turbo'd
Not recommended Kevin. The water pump might not be up to it and it is hard
to duct air in and out of the heat exchanger. You will not be able to get
a suitably shaped (thin, large area) rad in a pod under the engine. If
the rad is too thick sufficient air will not flow through it. Cutting
large holes
in the RV8 fuse and putting the rad in the aft fuse would be a bad idea.
Running the pipes through the cockpit with hose or other joints is
also a bad idea as a leak can cause scalding water in the cockpit. No fun.
Also you will have the additional drag of the belly scoop. There is plenty
of room in an RV8 cowl for one horizontal rad and an oil cooler under the
engine.
Simple and short plumbing. Direct air in an out of the rad. Optimum
minimum
drag solution for cooling the rotary. Our biggest problem.
Paul Lamar
I have read much that states that the air behind the prop is disturbed and
not the best for cooling purposes. I like the looks of a belly scoop and
thought I could use a pair of radiators that actually reached up as high as
the elevator pushrod assembly. Two ducts would be needed and the rads would
be mounted at an angle to allow greater area. I guess I was hoping for a
cleaner engine compartment with the engine rads in the rear, and the oil
cooler up front. With a turbo and three rotors I thought that an engine
compartment based rad would be pretty tight. Perhaps your reasons are why I
have not seen this done yet. I'm currently building the fuse and haven't
chopped any holes yet, but the decision time quickly approaches. tell me
more, i readily admit to not being an expert. kevin
Well we have been through a lot of configurations over the past five years
and I can honestly say no installation that I know of has been entirely
satisfactory. There is nothing more frustrating than an aircraft engine
that won't cool. Many people have given up over the past 50 years on
liquid cooled aircraft engines. You must give it every chance to succeed.
My best guess on what will work well is an intake in a high pressure
area with a totally unobstructed back side of the rad. All other considerations
are secondary. The highest pressure, free from boundary layer effects, is
found on the front side of the cowl. If the rad is placed next
to the skin of the airplane the back side will be completely
unobstructed. Modern heat exchanger practice is to use as thin a heat
exchanger as possible. This reduces the resistance to air flow and the
first half does three quarters of the work as the air heats up as it passes
through the rad. Check out the modern car and your house air conditioner.
The rate of heat transfer is directly proportional to
the difference in temp between the rad and the air. Liquid cooling starts
out with a handicap as the coolant boils at 220 F while out side air can
be as high as 110 F.
Rather than go through all this again I will attach my article
from the web site. After you read that I will answer any further
questions.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.
HOW TO COOL YOUR WANKEL copyright by Paul Lamar
Can an aircraft engine be improved by liquid cooling? Cooling an aircraft
engine with liquid under all ambient temperatures is not an easy thing to
do. Many designers have failed. All aspects of the cooling system design
must be near perfect. There is no cooling but air cooling. Ultimately all
waste heat must be dissipated to the air surrounding the aircraft.
Back Ground on Air Cooled Aircraft Piston Engines,
The current air cooled aircraft piston engine's power to weight ratio will
be very very difficult to improve upon based on its hundred year detail
development. No helpful material breakthroughs have occurred in the last 70
years. However strict attention must be paid to the cylinder head and
exhaust gas temperature of an aircraft engine or failure will occur. The
engine is finicky and the fuel air mixture must be set just right at all
power levels or the exhaust valves and cylinder heads will fail due to over
heating.
Temperature gradients in the metal are very important. A temperature
gradient is defined here as a large change in temperature from one part of a
solid to another. The air cooled engine by its very nature incorporates high
temperature gradients. High temperature gradients lead to cracking as part
of the metal wants to expand and this expansion is resisted by the cooler
parts. Cracked cylinder heads are a common problem with air cooled engines.
Pistons, of necessity, are almost always made of light weight aluminum by
the fact that they are starting up and stopping twice per engine revolution.
The modern light weight high HP piston engine would not be possible without
light weight aluminum pistons. Consequently they must be cooled by oil or
they too will soften, fail from over stress and may melt. Heavy duty
aluminum pistons sometimes have steel or cast iron inserts in the high
stress, high temperature ring land area.
Review of basic principals and history.
HP is a force times a velocity, Or put another way, force times a distance
traveled per second. Watts (heat per unit time) and HP are interchangeable
(746 watts equals one HP). It takes HP at the power plant to generate the
electricity that is used to light your 100 watt light bulbs.
Therefore the critical thing when designing a cooling system is the amount
of continuous HP the engine is called on to develop. A cooling system that
works for a light duty car application might not work for the same 200 HP
engine when used as an aircraft engine. Cars generally average around 40 HP
continuously and are occasional required to climb a long steep hill where
the HP required might climb to as high as 100 HP. The same engine used in an
aircraft might be expected to generate 200 HP or max power for as long as it
takes to climb to cruising altitude. Then it may be called on to generate
150 HP continuously. The design of the aircraft engine cooling system is far
more demanding. You cannot merely pull over to the side of the road if the
cooling system fails.
Heat balance
All engines have a heat balance. Heat balance is a list of the portions of
the total energy in the fuel that is distributed to various purposes. The
intrinsic efficiency of the engine determines what fraction of the heat must
be rejected. The heat rejected is the sum of what goes out the exhaust pipe
and what goes out the cooling surfaces.
A Rolls Royce Merlin used in the P51 has a heat balance of:
Mechanical HP out 29.6%
Waste cooling heat 18.9%
Waste exhaust heat 51.6%
One of the most efficient aircraft engines ever designed was the liquid
cooled O-200 Continental aircraft engine as used in Dick Rutan and Jeana
Yeager's around the world non stop and un-refueled Rutan Voyager.
Continental claimed this engine had a heat balance of:
Mechanical HP out 35%
Waste cooling heat 21%
Waste exhaust heat 44%
For the early 1981 Mazda 12A rotary engine it was
about:
Mechanical HP out 28%
Waste cooling heat 24%
Waste exhaust heat 48%
This differs little from any other typical intermittent internal combustion
engine but small efficiency improvements continue to be made in the Mazda
wankel rotary. The most recent Mazda RX8 engine is far better than this.
However I have no heat balance numbers yet.
The large amount of energy 'thrown away' as waste heat is an inescapable
result of the laws of thermodynamics. Engineers try to keep a high
combustion temperature for maximum overall efficiency and a high coolant
temperature (by minimizing the heat rejected to the cooling system), while
not melting or softening the metal the engine is made of!
There are three main ways of transferring heat. Conduction, convection and
radiation. Conduction takes place between solids or within the same solid
while convection happens between a solid and a fluid such as air or water.
Radiation takes place by one object "seeing" another hotter object. No not
nuclear radiation. You can be warmed by the sun no matter how cold it is
out side. You will not be warmed if you are in the shade. This is a classic
example of heat transfer by radiation. We are mainly concerned with
conduction and convection when cooling an engine.
This is a bit subtle and concentrated so it will take some cogitation and
re-reading for this to sink in.
The continuous HP per cubic inch of displacement and the geometry of the
combustion chamber combine to determine how much heat must be rejected per
unit time through the walls of the combustion chamber. The higher the HP per
cubic inch the more severe the cooling problem. If your engine has 20 square
inches of combustion chamber surface to transmit 100 HP worth of waste heat
that is easier to do than transferring 200 HP worth of waste heat with the
same 20 square inches. This is the very crux of the situation in getting the
heat out of the metal and into the coolant when dealing with high continuous
HP per cubic inch engines.
Aluminum combustion chambers melt at a lower temperature than cast iron but
they conduct heat better than cast iron. Most really heavy duty piston
engines use cast iron and or steel combustion chambers, heads and cylinders.
As you can imagine there is a severe compromise in the power to weight ratio
of any heavy duty piston ICE. It is also one of the developmental
differences between a heavy duty truck engine, an aircraft engine and a
light duty car engine. A heavy duty, over the road, tractor trailer turbo
diesel engine can weigh 2000 pounds while generating only 350 HP. The life
is expected to be up to or over 500,000 miles. A 350 HP air cooled aircraft
engine has a similar duty cycle and expected life but it weighs only about
500 pounds. This is a remarkable power to weight ratio for a heavy duty
engine. This is the result of 100 years of detail refinement and
development. Only the finest materials are used. That is also one reason why
aircraft engines are so expensive.
Air cooled aircraft engines have relatively low HP per cubic inch partly for
the durability reason. They are high displacement low RPM engines. This is
opposite to what we have been told for many years. Most automotive
journalist tout the high power to weight ratio of high RPM low displacement
piston engines. The key to this misconception is automotive piston engines
are very light duty engines.
A Mazda wankel rotary engine is indeed a small displacement engine as it
displace only about 75 cubic inches while generating 200 HP therefore its
cooling requirements appear to be severe. Unlike a piston engine however the
aluminum combustion chamber or rotor housing of a Mazda wankel engine is
lined with steel. The steel is chrome plated which of course is shiny and
reduces heat transfer by radiation from the white hot combustion gases. The
other very important difference is the combustion chamber moves as the rotor
turns. This means the area the combustion heat is applied too is much larger
than a piston engine. This is not good from an efficiency point of view but
excellent from a HP per cubic inch of displacement point of view. Mazda
rotary engines have generated as much as 400 HP per rotor without melting
the rotor housings. To my knowledge nobody has ever melted a rotor housing
which happens to be a rather common problem with piston engine aluminum
combustions chambers. Metal temperature measured near this surface are much
the same as temperatures in piston engine combustion chambers. About 500
degrees F. The rotor is cast iron and nearly impossible to melt. (See the
side bar the Rotor Verses the Piston.)
In a Mazda wankel rotary engine one third of the cooling requirement is oil
and two thirds is water or glycol/water mix. This differs from most piston
engines. The piston must be cooled by the oil of course but the piston makes
up a smaller portion of the total metal surface exposed to the hot
combustion gases at any one time. The rotor face makes up roughly half of
the surface area in contact with the hot combustion gases during the entire
expansion cycle. A piston top is a decreasing proportion of the total area
exposed to the hot gases as the piston moves down the bore. Oil cooling in a
wankel rotary is therefore very very important.
Pistons, of necessity are almost always made of light weight aluminum for
reasons mentioned above. The wankel rotary engine on the other hand can and
does use a heavy cast iron, impossible to melt rotor as the rotor never
stops and starts up in the opposite direction. It moves in a perfect circle
at all times. Never the less the rotor must also be cooled with oil.
In an air-cooled engine waste heat is transferred by the fins on heads and
cylinders directly to the air. This is done first by conduction and then by
convection. The rate of heat transfer is proportional to the difference in
temperature between the fins and the surrounding air. This difference,
initially, is about 400 degrees. The metal surface surrounding the
combustion chamber is 500 degrees and the ambient air temperature
surrounding the fins is about 100 degrees F. If the engine gets hotter the
rate of heat transfer increases. In a sense this is a stable cooling system.
Higher temperature, faster heat transfer, more cooling. The fin density or
number of fins per inch of head or cylinder surface must be such that the
rate of heat transfer to the air keeps the hottest part of the combustion
chamber below the melting or softening temperature of the metal. Usually
aluminum and usually about 500 degrees F.
In a water cooled engine waste heat is first transferred to the surface of
the coolant jacket by conduction and then to a coolant by convection. It is
stored in the coolant and moved to a heat exchanger where it is then
transferred to the air by convection. The water temperature is limited to
about 250 degrees due to boiling. The metal temperature can be 500 degrees
so the difference is only about 250 degrees initially and the rate of heat
transfer is lower. If the engine metal gets hotter the rate of heat transfer
will at first be increased by a process called nucleate boiling. Nucleate
boiling is a benign form of small scale boiling with enhanced heat transfer
characteristics. Tiny bubbles of vapor are formed and they work their way
to a vapor pocket at the very top of the cooling system by buoyancy. Bubbles
rise. If they cannot make their way to the top of the cooling system steam
pockets may occur which are very bad as the heat transfer from metal to
coolant in that local area is greatly reduced.
The internal shape of the water jacket around the combustion chamber must be
such that no local severe boiling takes place at the maximum continuous
power the engine is likely to generate. This is regardless of the bulk
temperature of the coolant. If this rule is violated parts of the
combustion chamber may melt or crack. This is the limiting factor in how
much continuous HP you can get out of any liquid cooled ICE.
If the temperature of the bulk coolant goes beyond the boiling temperature
overall boiling occurs of course. All hell breaks loose and the coolant is
forced out of the water jacket through the pressure cap overflow valve by
massive amounts of hot vapor or steam. Once boiling of the coolant starts it
is all over in an instant. Less coolant, hotter metal, more steam, less
cooling. One might say the cooling system pops like a pop corn. Thus the
cooling system becomes very unstable indeed. Something we all have probably
experienced in our cars. This is a major difference between the air cooled
engine and the liquid cooled engine. Needless to say this cannot be allowed
to happen in an aircraft engine.
A few bad experiences like this during climb out can be very discouraging
indeed. Forget all you have learned about dealing with car overheating. You
cannot just quickly reduce power and pull over to the side of the road and
stop. Given this situation it is best to test your new water cooled airplane
at low use uncontrolled airports so you can get it back on the ground right
now! Otherwise you may damage your engine. There have been some recent
improvements in materials used for sealing the rotary, both oil and water,
that have made it more tolerant to temporary over heating. Unlike a two
cycle piston engine the rotary will not seize. The rotor, being made from
cast iron, expands less then the rotor housing made from aluminum.
Most aircraft liquid cooling systems have a pressure gage. As the engine
warms up the pressure in the cooling system increases. If there is a slow
leak it will not necessarily be initially noticed by a reduction in
pressure. The leak might be such that the normal expansion of the coolant
will maintain the pressure despite the leak.
Consequently we have found that the best way to test for leaks is pressurize
the coolant system to about 30 psi while the engine is still cold before
flight. This can be done by installing an ordinary tire valve, called a
schrader valve, and using any convenient source of pressurized air.
Many people have given up on water cooled aircraft engines at this point. It
takes an extra amount of perseverance and determination to continue.
Having said all that and you are going forward anyway it is best to suppress
your creative urges and copy a system that someone else has used and that
you know works. Later on, after you have flown your airplane for awhile, you
can do a little experimenting.
Don't be tempted to use an oil to water heat exchanger for oil cooling. This
adds to the water cooling problem and reduces the margins of safety between
normal operation and unstable operation. (Bulk coolant boiling). Several
people have tried this and failed miserably. An OIL TO AIR heat exchanger
oil cooling system on the other hand is a stable system as oil boils at a
temperature well above normal oil operating temperatures. (Nothing worse in
the middle ages than being boiled in oil.) It is also a parallel independent
cooling system and will continue to function when the liquid cooling system
fails. This is not the case when an oil to water heat exchanger is used. In
that case all your eggs are in one basket.
In a typical water cooled automotive type engine the water jacket inside the
cylinder head is inaccessible. You can not open up the head and make
modifications and improvements to the water jacket. Fortunately this is not
the case with a Mazda wankel engine. The rotor housing is a separate part
and when the engine is un-assembled the interior part of the rotor housing
water jacket is readily accessible for modifications. The development of the
exact shape of the internal water jacket around the wankel combustion
chamber is still in a state of change after 40 years of development. Some
turbo charged Mazda rotary engines used in drag racing cars burning alcohol
and nitrous oxide are generating up to 400 HP per rotor or 800 HP for a two
rotor engine.
The four rotor Mazda engine that won the 1991 Le Man 24 hour road race out
right generated about 172 HP per rotor for a total of 690 HP. The engine was
in excellent to new condition after the race. Racing Beat in Anaheim CA has
about 200 hours on the dyno with a turbo three rotor Mazda engine generating
900 HP on 100LL aviation fuel. That of course is 300 HP per rotor. This
engine is intended for use in an aircraft. I mention these particular rotary
engines to illustrate the importance of cooling system development to these
very high HP per cubic inch engines.
Several modifications have been tried such as grooving the walls of the
water jacket to improve the heat transfer from the metal to the liquid
coolant. We have discovered that this is unnecessary if you limit your
engine to around 200 HP for take off and cruise at 175 HP. However this
feature may come in handy in the future when we get more experience with
higher HP turbo charged Mazda two and three rotor engines in aircraft use.
We do know the two rotor Mazda engine will currently generate about 200 HP
continuously with out melting or cracking for a bare engine weight of 235
pounds with PSRU for an excellent power to weight ratio. Tracy Crook near
Bell Florida has well over 1300 hours in his Mazda rotary powered RV4 with
no metal cracking or housing warping. Ken Welter near Portland Oregon has
run hundreds of pounds of nitrous oxide through his normally aspirated Mazda
wankel engine increasing the power from 200 HP to 300 HP and helping him get
his 2900 pound modified Coot amphibian on the step and off the water.
Once the heat is in the coolant it must be transferred to the air by the
heat exchanger (unfortunately called a radiator) by convection. In this case
the heat exchanger is 250 degrees F and the air is 100 degrees F or a
difference of only 150 degrees so the rate of heat transfer is also
unfortunately still lower. Small differences in ambient air temperature make
relatively large differences in the cooling of liquid cooled aircraft
engines. This is much more pronounced and noticeable than it would be with
air cooled aircraft engines. Air cooled engines historically work better in
the desert as a ten or twenty degree F increase in ambient temperature is a
smaller percentage difference in an air cooled engine compared to a liquid
cooled engine.
Air Flow Measuring Tools.
An essential tool for troubling shooting a cooling system design is a water
manometer. Air flow cannot be seen. Particularly from inside the cockpit
when you are flying. Some way of determining what the air is doing in the
cowl is extremely important. A low cost water manometer can do it all. It
can measure static pressures and air velocity. The idea is to achieve as
high a static pressure in front of the rad as possible and as low a static
pressure as possible on the rear of the radiator. Water manometer are easily
fabricated from clear plastic tubing and low cost drip irrigation plastic
Tees and elbows. Drip irrigation vinyl tubing is about $4 for 50 feet and is
ideal for plumbing the measuring points in the cowl to the manometer. A
small piece of porous kitchen foam hot glued to the end of the vinyl tubing
insures you are measuring static pressure and not stray local air currents.
If you point the end of an open tube in the direction the air flow is coming
from you can measure the air velocity. At sea level the formula is MPH = the
square root of (pounds per square foot /.0026). This is called dynamic
pressure. One inch of water is equal to .037 psi so you can see that a water
manometer is extremely sensitive device for measuring low pressures.
The Hard Part. Getting The Air To Go Through The Heat Exchanger.
Here is where most builders have difficulty. It is not easy to design a low
aerodynamic drag aircraft liquid cooling system. The cooling drag can be as
much as 30% of the overall drag on the airplane. The scoops and ducts must
be designed properly. The job of the duct is to slow the air velocity and to
raise the pressure to the point that it optimise's radiator performance.
Many lessons were learned in world War I & II on this subject. Some
important improvements did not have time to be applied during the war so
some of the best lessons can not be learned by studying WW II aircraft. The
P51 seems to be the ultimate liquid cooled aircraft of WW II yet its duct
system has been improved upon by some work published after the war. There
is an out of print book written by Kuchemann and Weber published in 1953
called The Aerodynamics of Propulsion wherein much of this has been
presented. Used copies are still available on the Internet.
Prior to this work most duct designers thought it necessary to design the
duct so there was a gradual transition from scoop opening to heat exchanger.
See figure x. This is not the case and a more bell shaped transition is
called for such as figure y. The coordinates of such as duct are given in
table a.
The other half or more of the equation is getting the air out on the back
side of the heat exchanger. According to our test of off the shelf car
radiators using a duct mounted on top of a Dodge Caravan (see picture on the
web site) and a water manometer it is very important to have a clear space
behind the heat exchanger. The air flow coming out of the rad can be as high
as 40% of the forward speed of the airplane. If there is an object within
ten inches behind the typical radiator this air velocity will convert to
static pressure on the face of the object. This in turn will impede the air
flow through the rad in the vicinity of the object. It is best to mount the
heat exchanger on the inside surface of the cowl and have a totally
unobstructed back side by exiting the air directly to the air stream.
In recent years improvements have been made in heat exchangers themselves.
It has been found that the thinner the heat exchanger is the better it works
given a constant volume. In other words a heat exchanger that is twenty
inches by twenty inches by one inch thick works better than a heat exchanger
that is ten inches by ten inches by four inches thick. Both heat exchangers
have the same four hundred cubic inches of volume. The rule of thumb is the
first half of the exchanger does three quarters of the work. This is because
as the cooling air passes through the heat exchanger it warms up and the all
important difference between the air temperature and the metal at the back
of the heat exchanger is reduced and so too is the the rate of heat
transfer.
Another advantage of the thin heat exchanger is the air pressure required to
push air through the exchangers is lower as the exchanger gets thinner and
thinner. This pressure is an out growth of the dynamic pressure caused by
the aircraft moving through the air at high speed. All modern cars and
trucks use thin, large area heat exchangers mounted perpendicular to the air
flowing through the grill. They need to cool while climbing hills when the
HP requirements are highest at only sixty or so MPH where the dynamic
pressure is only 0.065 PSI. A good scoop and duct or grill will give up to
about 80% of this or only 0.052 PSI. Not much!!! This is also the reason
large cooling fans are used in trucks and cars. At 100 MPH which is a
typical climb speed for a lot of airplanes the dynamic pressure is only 0.18
PSI. Again a properly designed scoop and duct will give about 80% of this or
0.14 PSI.
Unfortunately a large area thin heat exchanger is difficult to install
perpendicular to the air stream in an aircraft as it increases the
aircraft's frontal area. Let me define the term frontal area so there is no
mis-understanding. Technically frontal area is the maximum cross sectional
area of the aircraft perpendicular to the air stream regardless of where
along its fuselage length this occurs. It could occur half way back. Some
people mis construe this term to mean the shape of the front of the
airplane. Not true.
Thick heat exchangers were successfully used in fast airplanes during WW II
as the dynamic pressure available is proportional to the square of the air
speed. At two hundred MPH the dynamic pressure is four times what it is at
one hundred miles per hour. Most home built airplanes climb out at about
one hundred MPH so a thin heat exchanger is called for. A P51's heat
exchangers were a total of eleven inches thick and at four hundred MPH the
dynamic pressure was sixteen times higher than it is at one hundred MPH.
Never the less P51 and other liquid cooled WW II airplanes had problems
cooling while taxing for takeoff. Obviously a thin heat exchanger is called
for in home built aircraft. The problem is how do we fit them in? The
solution was mentioned in Kuchemann & Weber book Aerodynamics of Propulsion
and another book still in print published after WW II by Kays & London
simply called Compact Heat Exchangers.
The heat exchanger is installed at an oblique angle to the center line of
the aircraft as shown in figure z. This was referred to by K & M as an
oblique cooling block. Unfortunately it is difficult to apply the bell
shaped duct principle to such an arrangement so a modified shape was
developed by K & M and Kays & London shown in figure r. An approximation to
this shape that works fairly well is a simple wedge shaped duct as shown in
figure s. The distribution of the air flow through the heat exchanger can be
checked with a test rig. This consist of a blower, a heat exchanger and a
prototype duct. The air velocity distribution coming out of the back side of
the heat exchanger can be measured by a hand held digital wind speed meter.
Why not place the thin rad in the back of the fuselage perpendicular to the
air stream similar to the P51 arrangement? This will work of course but the
frontal area of the the aircraft will be increased by the P51 type scoop
required. A flush duct such as a NACA duct was not recommended by NACA for
feeding air to a flow restriction such as found in a heat exchanger. Recent
tests have verified this as fact. The NACA duct will fail to work under those
circumstances. Furthermore the long plumbing lines required might tax the
capabilities of the water pump. Not to mention the extra weight of coolant
required to fill the necessary long and large diameter coolant lines.
It is better to fit obliquely mounted heat exchangers under the cowl. This
is facilitated by the small size of the Mazda wankel engine compared to a
air cooled aircraft piston engine. The two rotor engine is twelve inches
wide by 14 inches high by eighteen inches long not including the PSRU. This
is much smaller than any piston engine of comparable HP. There is usually
plenty of room under the engine for an oblique mounted radiator with the air
exiting straight down through Venetian blind style cowl flaps. In airplanes
with retractable nose landing gear two obliquely mounted radiators, one on
either side of the engine, work well exiting straight out into the air stream
also with Venetian blind or gill type cowl flaps. Louvers could be used if
high speed drag is not an important factor.
It is also very important to make sure the air going through the exchanger
is as cool as possible so it is is unwise to pass the air over the hot
engine and then through the heat exchanger. It is better to duct the cool
air directly to the heat exchanger and then let it flow over the engine or,
better yet, directly to the outside of the cowl.
When the air arrives at the heat exchanger it should be slowed considerably
and the pressure should be about 80% of dynamic pressure if the duct and
scoop were designed properly. As the air passes through the heat exchanger
the pressure will be reduced still further and so too the air velocity. The
air temperature will increase up to about 40 degrees F above ambient air if
the heat exchanger is designed properly. The air will then go on to cool
parts of the engine before exiting through the cowl outlet openings. As the
air passes through these relatively small openings it must speed back up to
near or above the slip stream velocity and be directed to the rear of the
aircraft to recover as much energy from the cooling system as possible. This
energy recovery phase reduces the over all cooling drag.
If an opening is at the bottom or edge of the firewall a large radius must
be used on the firewall just before the opening in the cowl. This minimizes
the energy loss of the high speed cooling air exiting the cowling. This has
been well known for at least 70 years.
Cowl Flaps
Cowl flaps must be used on high speed airplanes as the dynamic pressure
varies widely over the speed range of an airplane. At 100 MPH it is 26
pounds per square foot and at 200 MPH it is over 100 pounds per square foot.
The most severe cooling requirements are during a max angle max HP climb out
at about 100 MPH. At 200 MPH the dynamic pressure is four times higher than
it is at 100 MPH and so too is the potential volume of air available to cool
the engine. Therefore the cowl flaps are nearly closed increasing the
pressure in the entire cooling system and diverting the air flow around the
scoop and reducing the internal air flow to roughly what was needed at 100
MPH. This greatly reduces the cooling system drag. Probably worth about five
or ten MPH additional cruise speed around 200 MPH. More as aircraft cruise
speed increases.
Full power top speed runs such as cross country racing are another matter.
Top speed is proportional to HP cubed while dynamic pressure is proportional
only to the square of speed. Consequently cooling again becomes an issue. It
may then be necessary to partially open the cowl flaps again. There is
nothing like a long cross country race on a hot day to test your cooling
system.
In a car, a thermostat is used to control the engine temperature. This is a
bad idea in an aircraft engine as it is better to use the cowl flaps for a
reduction in cooling drag as stated above.
I hope this clarifies and answers a few questions you may have had about
liquid cooling an an aircraft engine.
Paul Lamar