Michael McGee wrote:
The exhaust tuning discussion. This applies primarily to the NA
folks
We have been going round about what is the best configuration for our
application. Two pipes into the muffler or one? Collector at 16" or
32". How long the collector? Personally I am looking to be one of
the
quietest airplanes in the air with what I'm building without
sacrificing a
lot of power.
In the Q&A session several people were interested in this since
racers in
general now have noise restrictions. Apparently in Canada they are
even
stricter than the US. Rob Golden stressed that having a dyno to help
dial
in a muffler and exhaust system really helps. He likes to emphasize
that
you can theorize all day but a test will show the proof. One test is
worth
a thousand expert opinions and harder to get. I'll be able to do
exhaust
tests with the engine test stand I'm building. At least to the
static rpm
I'll be able to get with fixed pitch props. Paul and the gang might
be
able to add it to the test regime they will be doing with the LAEV
Prop.
The exhaust system needs to be tuned all the way to the end. It's
important to keep the pulse trains working together without fighting
each
other. Primaries need to be matching lengths in exhaust pulse
wavelengths. Once the primaries are collected your wave length is
1/2 of
what it is in the primaries because the two are 180 out of phase. So
your
collector length is dependent on half the primary wave length.
Primaries at one wavelength produce best power but make it peaky.
Two wave
lengths help flatten the power band. For you 2.17 guys that sounds
like
about 31-32", us 2.85 folks a little shorter. I wouldn't go any
shorter
than 16" on the collector (two collected wavelengths).
Pipe diameter--this was interesting.
According to Rob Golden, if you are putting out 275 hp (on a 13B)
then a 2"
primary pipe is the about the right size. It keeps the flow
velocities in
check and still keeps the pulse trains well defined. For less than
275 hp
scale the area of the pipe down accordingly. This puts my 200hp
target
with pipes that are:
200/275 = (pri dia)^2/(2")^2 ...(I've already canceled the pi's and
dia/2)
pri dia = ~1.7"
Loosen up a bit and call it 1.75" ID
Collector diameter = sqrt[2*(1.7^2)] = 2.4" ID,
using 1.75" pri, you get a 2.5"ID collector
Comments on these numbers anyone? It all sounds plausible to me.
MGM
Mike McGee, RV-4 N996RV, O320-E2G, Hillsboro, OR
13B in gestation mode
Mike, first thanks for collecting and disseminating this information.
I can't comment on the proper exhaust pipe diameter ( I only know
what I am told) but it would be sooo much easier to route the smaller
pipes. If it is true, I will definitely rebuild my finished exhaust.
Jerry
This all jibes with what I have found and agrees with the engine tuning
articles read in various books & magazines. I used 1.75" tubing on the RV-4
and will do the same on my 20B RV-8. It certainly does make routing the
exhaust easier than with 2".
Tracy
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.