Subject: Starter solenoid (fwd)
From: ACRE NL
Date: 3/5/2003, 11:05 PM


Al,
Bob Nuckols wrote an article about why you should have an external
starter
solenoid.
You can read his article at:
http://www.aeroelectric.com/articles/strtctr.pdf

Mark S.

What s the steady-state current draw of the starter solenoid?

Why, in all of Bob Nuckol s wiring diagrams, is there a starter
contactor
switching the heavy current to the starter?  There is already a
contactor
in the solenoid.  What am I missing here?



Al Gietzen

        Paul,

          I think this info should be added to the Rotary Best
Practices site.

        Kelly Troyer

Except I think that Bob misses it on this one.  But right or wrong;
here's another point of view:
Posted for "Al Gietzen" <alventures@email.msn.com>:

My further thoughts regarding using a starter contactor:

First of all, reading the Bob Nuckoll's article makes me wonder.  I have
not seen a car in the last 30 years that has not used a relay between
the switch on the dash and the starter solenoid circuit.  So the issue
of the high initial current to the solenoid burning up the starter
switch is ancient history.  The point is that the relay handles the
current to the solenoid; not the starter motor current.  I planned the
same for the plane; an automotive relay rated at maybe 40 amps;
activated by the push button switch on the panel - which powers the
starter solenoid, which closes it's heavy duty contactor to switch the
motor current; which can be very high.

He doesn't mention another real issue; that is the collapse of the
solenoid coil field upon disconnect produces a pretty good arc at the
contacts; so a diode to ground to bleed off the back current is
important to the longevity of the relay.  He doesn't give any reason for
switching the starter motor current with a starter contactor; other than
B&C suggests doing it that way.

I did learn that the steady state current draw while the solenoid is
engaged is about 10 amps; so my initial question answered.  That I
appreciate.

I think in aircraft use it is primarily for safety reason.  If the
solenoid
should fail closed then the starter would remain engaged with the engine
running and cause damage.  With a switch activate contactor you remove
all power to the starter thereby precluding that type of mishap.<  Ed

Bob's approach is to tie the solenoid activation terminal to the starter
motor terminal.  Power to the starter activates the solenoid, engaging
the starter gear, and closes the motor contacts allowing the starter to
operate. Then place another contactor in series with this that switches
the combined load of the solenoid and motor.  This doubles the
probability of a stuck contactor causing the starter to fail to
disengage.  It may more than double the failure probability because the
return spring in the starter solenoid is much more robust than the one
in the contactor; so which is more likely to fail closed?  Maybe the
concern is that the additional mechanical mechanism in the solenoid may
cause a failure to open?

I believe that the purpose of the starter contactor in
Bob Nuckol's drawings is to isolate the starter cable
from the battery.
If the starter cable were connected directly to the
battery and it shorted to ground there would be no way
to disconnect it.<  Jim

This may have some validity, depending on the configuration.  There is
still the battery contactor to disconnect it; and is it any more likely
that the short would occur between the battery contactor and the starter
contactor, than on the starter side.  Nuckoll's also recommends placing
the starter contactor at the engine; and using the heavy starter lead
for the alternator charging circuit.  For me; with an engine in back and
the batteries up front; it's the only logical way to go.  So for me a
short in the starter circuit can only be broken by the master switch
(battery contactor).  Since I have an 'engine critical' buss on the
battery of the contactor I can still fly the plane.

Unless I'm still missing something, my conclusion is use the contactor
in the starter solenoid, to switch the starter motor current, switch the
solenoid circuit with a 40 amp automotive relay in the engine
compartment, and have some nice little #22 wires running to my starter
push button switch.  I noticed this morning that Paul Messinger came to
the same conclusion in his article in Contact!

Sorry to go on about this.  The good thing is - I did get my question
answered! Thanks for your comments.

Best,

Al


The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.