Subject: Pineapple Racing Q&A- Coolant
From: ACRE
Date: 3/10/2003, 10:21 PM


Mike McGee wrote:

 Continuation of topics from a tech Q&A session at Pineapple Racing in
 ...
 EG if you're switching over.  At over a hundred bucks, an expensive
 installation.

 Everything is a sales pitch until you have tried it or seen it work.  The
 guys at Pineapple Racing have enough credibility with me that I will
 ... be studying this some more.
 http://www.evanscooling.com/

 Comments?
 Mike McGee, RV-4 N996RV, O320-E2G, Hillsboro, OR

Without having a thermal couple located within 2 mm of the combustion
chamber adjacent to the lower spark plug (cyl head temp gage) I can not
say if NPG (propylene glycol) works or not. There are some theoretical
heat transfer problems with it as I recall.

We had a long discussion about it on here a few years ago. It may not
boil over but that does not necessarily mean it is cooling the metal
like it should.

Paul Lamar

  I have run Evans coolant for about 300 hrs but I am not sure if I am
going to stick with it as I am about to fill it up in a few days.
  Cost is one down side and the other is the availability when out on
the victor air ways if you need to top it off as you cant mix water
with it.
  The other brew I used was 60-Sierra 40-water mix that also worked fine.

  Ken Welter

Interesting thread.  Cooling is our biggest Boogie Man right now.

I think we all share the opinion that the Wankel can make plenty of
power - we just need to pick our personal margin of safety and work
within that range.  Mine is currently 100 HP/rotor.  BUT, we still need
to dump that waste heat.

The ACRE list has educated us that the temperature DIFFERENCE (delta-T)
determines cooling efficiency.  400 degree air-cooled engine fins
transfer heat better than 220 degree radiator fins.

1) If we run hotter cooling systems, won't that increase the cooling
efficiency?  How critical is engine heat within the rotor housings and
intermediate housings?  I've read the stories of engines that were
overheated, and continued to fly.  Damage seems to occur only with
extreme overheating.

2) With larger delta-T's, won't flying on hot days be less of an issue?

3) I'd really like operational data from Ken Welter.  How hot does he
run under various conditions?  Is it or is it not cooling adequately?
Does he have to "baby" the system?

4) I certainly expect to find some "gotchas".  If it was so simple,
every automobile on the road would be using this stuff.  How do those
"gotchas" apply to aviation use?  Are they worse than the cooling Boogie
Man we're dealing with now?

5) If cost is the only applicable "gotcha" ... hell, count me in!  I'd
gladly take the extra margin of safety for $200-300 more.

6) I'd like to keep my coolant from puking overboard ... then I'd have
NO cooling.  (Well, OK, less cooling.)

7) Does this stuff attack any of the "improved" seals we are using?

8) It sounds like this was discussed before I came onto the list.
Conclusions?

I'd be willing to personally invest in the testing of this by helping to
cover the costs of this expensive coolant, and maybe even help with
instrumenting a test engine with Paul's heat sensors/thermocouples.
Maybe this testing can be arranged to take place at the same time as the
LAEV prop tests.  Let me know.

--
Vince Orton

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.