Subject: A fresh look at cooling
From: ACRE
Date: 3/13/2003, 11:32 AM


Jerry Hey wrote:

The factors that effect cooling are surface area of the rad, the
capacity of the rad and the air flow through it. It would seem that for
any given capacity, the larger the surface area the better. Perhaps not.
In talking with C & R, it is clear that experience has taught them that
air flow is the major issue. The Winston Cup rads that they build are 4
to 5.5 inches thick and are very efficient because they have figured out
how to get air through them. Quote from C & R today, " bigger is not
necessarily better".)

Perhaps we have given core thinness too much importance. Air moving
through the rad is the BIG STICK as Paul has pointed this out at least a
couple of hundred times and C & R concurs. Just about every Sunday you
can watch WC cars making lap after lap with their inlets mostly covered
with duct tape which testifies to the efficiency they can get out of
thick radiators.

ACCORDING TO C & R THICK RADIATORS GAIN EFFICIENCY AS THE SPEED OF THE
AIR STREAM INCREASES BUT THIN RADIATORS ACTUALLY LOSE EFFICIENCY AT
HIGHER SPEEDS. I find this hard to understand but if a given mass of air
has the ability to remove a certain amount of heat, it still requires
contact time with the cooling fins to do so. Maybe that is part of the
story. Big area thin rads for slow moving vehicles and small area thick
rads for fast moving vehicles. Is this a formula we can believe?
Probably. Since it is proven every Sunday on the race track.

At Daytona the WC cars use 4 inch thick rads and that is what one tech
person at C & R recommends for aircraft running above 150 mph. While they
could not easily produce the data for me today, they derived it through
extensive wind tunnel testing and seem confident of the rock on which
they stand. Of course, every other sentence was a warning that it all
depended on the "installation."

A 4" x 12" x 12" is roughly equivalent in capacity to my 13" x 18" x
2.5" but a whole lot easier to find a place for. A little
4" x 14" x 14" would handle a turbo!!!

what do you all think? Jerry

"It is good to make things simple, but not too simple." Albert Einstein


The pressure available to force air through the rad at 150 MPH is twice as
high as it is at 100 MPH. We need to cool at 100 MPH climb. If it cools at
climb (full power slow speed) it will cool at cruise (moderate power
medium speed).

Daytona speeds are 200 MPH or above where the pressure is four times
higher than it is at 100 MPH. Not a whole lot of people are making 4 inch
thick rads. Perhaps they are trying to sell expensive rads into a
exclusive market
of their own making :)

The NASCAR race car rad ducts I have seen are really bad news. No bell
shapes in sight. The air must exit into the high pressure engine compartment
as no exit ducts are allowed. Furthermore the engine is right behind
the vertical rad. All and all a really terrible example of proper cooling
design.

One reason they use tape to block off the air to the rad is to lower
the pressure under the hood which causes lift on the front of the car.

BTW the RX8 has a laid down rad at about a 45 degree angle. Perfect
for a top of the hood exit duct. I am thinking of going in to business
making carbon fiber hoods with a proper rad air exit duct for RX8s :)

Paul Lamar


Jerry,

  I'm surprised that the guys at C&R would tell you that. I'm with Paul on
this. From an engineering perspective and also intuitively the thick
radiator doesnt make sense. The thicker radiator definitely creates more
drag. And as air flows through the radiator front to back the air picks up
heat so the back of the core loses efficiency. The only place that the
thick rad makes sense is if you are so space limited that there is no way
to pick up core volume by increasing frontal area. If you are already maxed
out in frontal area with no more room to grow and the engine still wont
cool then adding thickness may be your only option. Seems like a sledge
hammer approach to me.

  I've mentioned this in the past, probably so any times that many of the
long time guys on list are tired of hearing it. A number of years ago we
had a guy on list by the name of Fred Moreno who did cooling system designs
for a living. I asked him to look at an analysis for my RV4. He provided 3
different examples with differing frontal areas for radiator cores. All 3
cases theoretically would provide suitable cooling, but the small frontal
area rads required excessively large air inlets and exits to cool
sufficiently. This caused an enormous increase in cooling system drag.

  To me the lesson learned is to keep the thickness down and frontal area
up which allows you to reduce air inlets and exits and thus minimize
cooling drag.

  BTW my radiator came from C&R. The core is 20" x 14" x 2.25" and its a
dual pass unit. If I could have fit a core with more frontal area I would
have done so.

Mike Wills


 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.