There seems to be a general lack of understanding of how hybrid cars work.
Hybrid cars are attempts to exploit the inability of the internal combustion
engine to be economical when operating at the low continuos power requirements
of the typical auto engine. Internal combustion engines get the most
HP out of a gallon of gas at the best torque point. Generally
that is about the 65 to 75% HP level. A car requires only about
30 to 40 HP to go down the road. The remaining HP is there for
acceleration and to climb the occasional hill.
Just like an airplane the difference of the amount of HP between
what is required to maintain a constant speed and what is available from the
engine determines the acceleration and climbing ability. F = M x A
or A = F / M which is the same as the power to weight ratio.
The idea of a hybrid is to use a lower power engine operating
near its torque peak to charge a battery while the car is going down the
road at moderate speed or if necessary while the car is sitting at
a stop light. The theory being you are getting more energy out of a gallon
of gas. The battery power is then used to accelerate the car OCCASIONALLY.
If your hybrid does 95 MPH it will only do that for a brief period
as some of the HP required is coming from the charged battery. When the
battery is depleted the car MUST slow down.
The same thing will happen if you climb a long hill. At first everything
goes along pretty good while there is still charge in the battery.
As you get to the top of the hill say in a valley and you now want
to pass somebody there is no battery charge left to accelerate the car.
The same thing happens if you are on a two lane road and cruising at
say 65. At that speed there is not much HP left from the small low power
engine to charge the battery. If you deplete the battery by making several
high speed passes in a row or climb a hill there will be nothing left
to help you on that last pass.
All this would not be too bad if electric motors and batteries weighed nothing.
Unfortunately reality sets in and the weight added to the structure of the
car to carry the heavy electric motor and battery soon add up to an enormous
weight penalty. In this case 765 pounds.
Further more every time you convert mechanical energy
into electrical energy there is an efficiency penalty. Conversely every time
you convert electrical energy back into mechanical energy there is also an efficiency
penalty. These penalties are accumulative. 80% times 80% is 64%.
Further more all gasoline internal combustion engines with out turbo compounding
only extract about 30% of the energy in a gallon of gas at best. Diesels
slightly higher. Most of the waste energy, about 50%, goes out the tail pipe.
So of that gallon of gas used to charge the battery and then supply mechanical
power to the wheels we are only getting 65% times 30% or about 20%
of our moneys worth. Off setting this slightly is the generator
can be connected to the wheels to slow the car and recover some of the stored
kinetic energy in the car. This process too is highly inefficient and it takes
a very complicated and expensive controller to achieve even a moderate
energy recovery. If you need to stop real fast it is probably useless. Overall
at best hybrid cars are only slightly more efficient in a mostly city driving
cycle than the same size car with 1/3 less weight.
It would be far far better, with no real weight penalty, to apply a turbo
compound system to our existing internal combustion engines and recover
an additional 6% better efficiency from the engine improving the energy recovery
from 30% to 36% from our gallon of gas. If the power to weight ratio of the
engine is a constant, and indeed it is in most modern cars, we can reduce the size
and weight of the engine by about 20% because the turbo compound engine also
produce 20% more power. This then will reduce the structural
weight of the car yielding even more efficiency when it comes time to
accelerate or climb hills.
Hybrid cars take advantage of the electric car myth. Many people
rationalize them as "electric cars." I got news for you.
Chances are there probably is some combustion engine of some kind somewhere
generating the electricity for that "electric car". In some
cases, horror of all horrors, it is an atomic power plant.
In the short span of four or five years pure "electric cars" have
disappeared from the face of the earth for the second time in 100 years
as I predicted when I helped test the GM electric car for Popular Science
magazine four or five years ago. BTW I did not just fall off the
car testing turnip truck. One of my businesses for the years between
about 1971 through 1995 was supplying performance testing equipment
to the world's car and motorcycle manufacturers as well as most
car magazines. Our test equipment was the industry standard and
was also used to calibrate inertial navigation equipment for
boomer submarines among other military uses.
The Prius uses 228 1.2 volt expensive Nickel Metal Hydride batteries.
Just like your notebook computer or any other electric car when the
batteries wear out in several years you are in for an enormous expense.
In effect at that point the Pirus will take a huge depreciation hit.
Rumor has it these batteries are worth as much as $30,000. I cannot say
what Toyota will charge to replace them. Basically they are giving them
away now at the real expense of all those that buy Toyota products.
We will see the hybrids also disappear as soon as the economic reality of
replacing the batteries sets in.
As an interesting aside. Cars are more or less banned on Catalina
island. At first the day visitor would rent an electric golf cart
to get around Avalon. That was then. Now all the golf carts are powered
by two cycle gasoline engines that start up and shut down as needed.
When you use the electric golf cart for an hour or so it then takes 6 hours or
so to recharge the battery. This meant you needed four to five times
the number electric golf carts to supply the transportation demand.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.