Subject: Turbo compound 20% less fuel burn.
From: ACRE
Date: 3/17/2003, 9:01 PM

Vince Orton wrote:

ACRE wrote:
<major snips throughout>

It would be far far better, with no real weight penalty, to apply a turbo
compound system to our existing internal combustion engines and recover
an additional 6% better efficiency from the engine improving the energy recovery
from 30% to 36% from our gallon of gas. ...

Agreed, Turbo Compounding will help ... incrementally.

Hybrid cars take advantage of the electric car myth. Many people
rationalize them as "electric cars." I got news for you.
Chances are there probably is some combustion engine of some kind somewhere
generating the electricity for that "electric car". In some
cases, horror of all horrors, it is an atomic power plant.

Or a hydroelectric dam.

Often overlooked is where ELECTRICITY comes from to charge ELECTRIC CAR
BATTERIES ... with associated efficiency losses in the 1) generation, 2)
transportation, and 3) charging of car batteries.  THEN we get to
discharge them with yet another pair of efficiency losses: 4) battery
discharge and the 5) electric motor.  It's really dismal.

When debating electric cars once with a neighbor who worked for the
Calif. Air Resource Board, he smiled and said "Yeah, it's inefficient,
but the generation-related pollutants are moved out of the cities."
Hmmm.  He had me.  This is true.

So ... not all smog is bad.  Just the smog in Calif. cities.  Even if we
have to produce MORE energy overall (therefore smog) to move the
"generation-related pollution" out of the cities.

Just remember: Calif. city smog bad ... other smog OK.  (Sorry Arizona,
Nevada, etc.)

We will see the hybrids also disappear as soon as the economic reality of
replacing the batteries sets in.

I agree.  On another note: a substantial recycling infrastructure will
need to be built for these waste batteries.  And soon.  I can't wait to
hear the green arguments on THAT one!  :)

Paul Lamar

Now, Paul, let me counter your rant(s) with one FOR hybrid cars
(forgetting for the moment the feel-good politics of hybrid car
subsidies - I don't like subsidies any more than the next guy).

Two words: FUEL CELLS.  Fuel Cells produce electricity from Oxygen and
Hydrogen (i.e. air and your favorite hydrocarbon fuel).

What possible redemption can hybrid cars have with all of their faults?
Simple.  They jump-start development and production of high-power
electric components for the automotive industry.  Components like
controllers and motors.  They help out with chicken-and-egg problems
related to turning around an entire automotive industry.

Here's the kicker:  Fuel cells are EFFICIENT.  Like 60% efficient.  That
smokes the 30% efficiency of Internal Combustion Engines (ICE).

Turbocompounding?  Sure you can scratch out another 6% (20% improvement)
by turbocompounding an ICE, but that's nothing like the 30% gain (100%
improvement) of a fuel cell!  AND, you can still do turbocompounding
with a Fuel Cell stack - it's called co-generation though.  Generating
electricity by 1) the fuel cell stack, and 2) an exhaust turbine.

You think Fuel Cells are just for weenie cars?  Well, keep in mind some
of the world's largest earthmovers are electric.  Those gigantic
machines have electric wheels driven by a diesel generator.  (Saw that
on Discovery Channel - I fell out of my chair!)  So, once the components
are developed for mass production, automotive power limits won't be a
problem.  You'll have your choice of 1) double the power, 2) double the
efficiency, or 3) a blend of the two.

Paul - I love your turbocompounding plans/discussions.  Where do I sign
up?  Let's do it!  But I'll address my ideas on turbocompounding in
another email.

Hybrid cars are all evil?  Naaaa.  Just a distraction while the
automotive industry turns around to fuel cells and the hydrogen
economy.  I prefer to think that those who purchase hybrids are actually
HELPING to get us there faster.  BUY THOSE ELECTRIC HYBRID CARS!

Oh, and when we have fuel cells CARS, we will have fuel cell
EXPERIMENTAL AIRCRAFT.  More efficient, less vibration, etc.

Let the flames begin ... (er, continue)

Fuel Cell Links (have fun!):
http://science.howstuffworks.com/fuel-cell.htm
http://www.fuelcells.org
http://www.hfcletter.com
http://www.fuelcelltoday.com

--
Vince Orton

I need some help researching gears. I am looking for a small planetary
with the pitch line velocity of the sun gear moving not over 10,000 feet per minute.
That will be the input stage from the turbo with a max RPM of 120,000 RPM.
That makes the max diameter .333 inches.
When I get the gears finalized I can start designing the pattern for the
gear box. I have and old Boston Gear catalog but there must be something
else out there.
 
Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.