Weight is an advantage in a locomotive. Allows them to pull more.
Don't hold your breath on hydrogen distribution.
Paul Lamar
<snip>
Newbie here - My biggest concern with hydrogen is containment. Practical
quantities require liquification, which means cryogenics or high pressure.
(What is the pressure of liquid H at room temperature? I can't remember.)
Cryogenics calls for a huge thermos bottle. Not something I want to be
within a hundred feet of in an accident.
Shannon
Paul -
1) Fuel Cell / Electric Motor combinations will be comparable to gas
engines in weight. Fuel Cells have the advantage because you can move
components around to play with CG. Only the electric motor needs to be
in front (or in back for pushers). They will provide more power and
more efficiency. Once there are thousands in the wrecking yards, there
will be dozens in aircraft. :)
2) No one should hold their breath for hydrogen distribution - but it
will happen in one form or another. (Bet?) Keep in mind that I am on
the ACRE list, and I am pursuing a wankel-powered aircraft. I am not
pitching fuel cells instead of wankels - I don't think they'll be ready
in the next few years when I'll be ready to fly. But fuel cells are
coming, and they will be better when they arrive (and are debugged, mass
produced, etc.)
I stand by my original statement: BUY ELECTRIC HYBRID CARS NOW! Not me,
of course. :) I'm waiting for the fuel cell electrics to come out, but
everyone else can feel free to help fund the transition. I'm waiting
for now. Sounds like you are too, Paul.
Shannon -
Check out those links in the original email, and there's lots more if
you Google "Fuel Cells".
There are several ways to resolve the hydrogen storage problem:
1) Store it as a stable liquid fuel (gas, diesel, methanol, etc.), and
REFORM it as the fuel cell requires hydrogen. (Most probable technology
for the next 5-10 years)
2) New technology is being developed that stores hydrogen in special
materials. These materials "soak up" hydrogen and release it upon
demand. The kicker? It's possible to store hydrogen at several times
the density of its liquid state at a fraction of the pressure. The
materials suspend the hydrogen molecules in a matrix. Of course there
are "gotchas", like cost, etc. (That's DEVELOPMENT for ya')
There are other potential solutions, but this demonstrates that
traditional methods and hazards aren't the ONLY way to solve traditional
problems. Heck, this ACRE list is ALL ABOUT thinking out of the box.
*****
Back to wankels - we shouldn't give up just because Fuel Cells are
coming and they will be better. That will be some time off in the
future. The wankel is still a superior aircraft engine. Now let's
continue developing, flying, and proving the wankel.
--
Vince Orton
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.