> > Hi, Paul.....regarding the use of two thrust bearings on my Ross PSRU, I
> would rather forward Dave Mix's comments rather than possibly
misstating his
> reasoning for doing the mod this way. Here is a copy of the
message he sent
> to me regarding the options. Thanks for your interest and
comments. Hope to
> see you at Sun-N-Fun. Paul Conner
*************************************************************************
> > Hi Paul,
> > I've been inside your psru and have done the necessary measurements.
> >
> > Here's a rundown of what I discovered, and a proposal for the bearing
> > installation.
> > The good news is that your shaft seal is a better design than the
> > early seals that
> > Ross used, but the downside is that it uses the 1.750 diameter of the
> > shaft as its
> > sealing surface, therefore this dia must stay at 1.750. There is a
> > thrust bearing available that will fit that dia but things are never
> > that easy. The shaft seal fully
> > seated in the bellhousing cavity protrudes .006 and needs to be
> > protected
> > from any compression, so in order to provide a path for the thrust load
> > to
> > pass into the housing I will make a "bridge" that will support the
> > thrust bearing
> > on one side and straddle the seal body on the other side. ( All 360
> > degree
> > circular of course ).
> > Mr.Ross did a fine job of space utilization and left me with .127
> > space to
> > put in .180 +/-.004 worth of stuff. I will take a minimal cut into the
> > planet
> > carrier (approx. .053 deep) to accomodate the new parts.
> > Now the dilemma, all this puts one bearing set in place ( bearing
> > plus
> > hardened & ground washer on each side) To put an additional bearing in
> > place will require the planet carrier cut to be .162 deep (vs .053). The
> > carrier in that area is .255 thick HOWEVER the cut would be VERY close
> > to the planet
> > gear pinions (.035 wall more or less, this would be at 4 places).
> > This is totally your call, and I don't want to influence you, but,
> > DON'T DO IT.
> > The thrust bearing is rated at 5600 pound load at 4500 rpm. Within
> > reason
> > ratings run inverse to each other (the lighter the loading the higher
> > the allowable
> > speed). The max pure thrust load you could ever possibly put on the
> > bearing
> > in this application is equal to the max aerodynamic drag of the
> > aircraft.
Nothing to do with the prop thrust.
> > Operating
> > at 6000 rpm at such a minimal load is reasonable. Also remember that the
> > aft
> > thrust bearing is a single race also and has a similar rating and is
> > potentially seeing
> > a greater load due to the gear tooth spiral effect.
> > That was easy enough. The bearings are ordered as are the races and
> > material to make the bridge. Also, please measure the bellhousing/psru
> > gasket thickness for me.
> > Please let me know if you want the second bearing, its do-able, but
> > if it were my
> > gearbox I would opt to maintain the integrity of the planet carrier and
> > forgo the
> > second bearing.
> > Thanks, Dave
> >
This bearing has nothing to do with the prop thrust.
This bearing takes the thrust load from the helical sun gear
and operates at up to 6500 RPM on take off and 5000 RPM continuously.
Here are some drawings of devices that will do the job and that
is not dependent on the distance from the sun gear to the Ross
bell house casting.
Paul Lamar
When you go through these life calculations you will soon discover
that any needle bearing operating in this size and RPM range has a
very limited life indeed. This is why it is necessary to use at least
two or more back to back to reduce the RPM to half or 1/3.
You new guys out there.. check with me on this kind of stuff. We have been
at this for five years so far. People on here have had first hand experience
with thrust bearing failure.
Paul Lamar
Yes I think I have logged more dead stick landings than anyone do
to the Ross gearbox, one of them from 6000 ft with the tops at 5000
and the ceiling at 500ft.
It has been proven that this bearing wont handle the rpm and all you
have done by installing a single bearing is to put it in a spot
easier to maintain and I the first failure at only 80 hrs so that
means that you would have to replace the bearing at 40 hrs or less to
be on the safe side.
As for room to install more bearings, I had an idea to install a
spacer plate between the gearbox and the bell housing to give more
room, it seams like it would be simple to do with the setup you have.
Ken Welter
Thanks Ken. That is a great idea and simple too.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2002 All world wide rights reserved.