Subject: Bad news
From: ACRE
Date: 4/23/2003, 9:13 PM


snip
I'm lost... :) What's wrong with using fuel cells? Except for the
current price and performance, I'd love to have a fuel cell car
that got it on like a 60's slot car.

Phil

It takes more energy to make the hydrogen than you get back by using
it. Except for the limited supply using hydro, wind and photo.
Assuming of course you can solve the distribution problems. Things
never discussed or addressed in the glowing press releases.

Paul Lamar


Here is an interesting article on the fuel cell and it's financing
difficulties after three years of little progress.
http://www.autonet.ca/AutonetStories/Stories.cfm?StoryID=8223
Rolf Pfeiffer


It's not like you can pump hydrogen out of the ground at a cost of $2 a
barrel. Also there is a nation wide zillion dollar gasoline  pipeline
transportation and
distribution system in place that took 100 years to install.

Paul Lamar


Paul,

  I know you're not a fan of this technology, and I'm not going to try
to convince you out of your beliefs.  Maybe this will help you
understand the 'other side'.

  The hydrogen economy is coming and it's long, long overdue.  While it
took 100 years to get the petroleum distro system in place, it won't
take near as long for the H2 system - things are moving faster today
than 100 years ago.  Many people have used the energy balance as 'proof
positive' that Eeyore was right:  'it won't work'.  What the most vocal
critics aren't looking at is that it isn't about energy balance.  It's
the most abundant element in the universe, can be easily made (and is
being made by people in their back yards around the world right now!)
from the planet's most abundant resource, using our most abundant source
of energy - the sun.  Without pollution, without an Exxon Valdez -
ever!, without green house gasses, without CO or N0x or sulphur
compounds or acid rain or smog.

  What would a drive around San Bernadino be like of you could see the
mountains?  How would SoCal smell if you took out the brown crud you're
breathing now?

  That's why the momentum will continue in spite of politics or intertia
or Big Oil or lobbyists.

   Have a good evening,
    Andy

PS...  I worked with a couple named Sammis while stationed in Germany.
They considered naming their daugher 'Mary Christine'.  Mary Chris
Sammis.


Sun? What sun? What about those people that live in Seattle and the 
great North Wet? :)

Long before the car the LA basin was known as the smoky valley or some
such by the natives. It mostly has to do with the prevailing winds off 
the ocean stacking whatever is in the air behind the ring of mountains.
San Bernadino happens to be at the end of the huge box canyon.

The fact of the matter a lot of the smog left in LA is not caused by
burning hydrocarbons. The contribution of the car is probably 1/100 of what
it was 35 years ago. I can remember LA in those days and it was much much worse.
The car is 98% as good as it will ever get.

The car just happens to be an easy mark for the wackos as car owners are not
politically organized. No lobbies in the state or federal government.
Car owners are now paying a huge disproportionate cost in many subtle ways. 

Take diesel trucks and buses for an example. I still see trucks & school 
buses spewing black carcinogenic smoke all over LA. Truckers have a very effective 
lobby as they can scream cost. School buses authorized by the same politician 
that are attacking the car and advocating hydrogen. By the time those and other 
smog problems are fixed hydrogen, if it ever happens, will make little or no difference. 
Politicians are all about BS. They get elected on their ability to BS. Very few are 
technically capable of changing a set of spark plugs let alone making 
engineering decisions.

I suspect a lot of the improvement in LA air in the last 35 years  has to do 
with a subtle climatic change brought about by housing development, new water 
reservoirs and individuals watering their lawns and gardens on what was formerly 
a desert. One rain clears the air like magic. When I fly over LA in my plane 
over the years I never cease to be amazed at the new housing developments. It is 
now wall to wall houses from Venturi to the Mexican border 200 miles away and 
100 miles East to the mountains.

It is just plain stupid and idiotic to expend more energy than you
get back by creating an artificial energy source. This is one of the reason
we don't have fusion as an energy source. Fusion was touted as the 
energy supply of the future decades ago. They soon found out that it took more 
energy to create fusion than you got back other than what happens in 
a hydrogen bomb.

Hydrogen will never happen. It is another fad issue dreamed up by the wackos that 
will go the way of the electric car and the current hybrid car.

Paul Lamar


The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.