Subject: Freedom motor announcement?
From: ACRE
Date: 5/5/2003, 11:09 PM


 > > > > > >> Paul
 > > > > >>
 > > > > >> I just checked up on the Moeller site and see where Freedom
 Motors
 > is
 > > > > >> taking orders for their
 > > > > >> engines.
 > > > > >>
 > > > > >> "Beta versions of the RotapowerŪ 650 and 1300 will be available
 > this
 > > > > >> summer and priced at $5,000
 > > > > >> and $7,000, respectively. Volume pricing reductions will be
 > announced
 > > > > >> as production levels
 > > > > >> increase later this year. "
 > > > > >>
 > > > > >> www.freedom-motors.com/
 > > > > >>
 > > > > >> Thought I would pass this along to the group.
 > > > > >>
 > > > > >> Mike Perry

 > > > > > What ever you do don't send them any money.

 > > > > They have had the same message up for 3+ years.  Paul Moller
 recently
 > > > > plead guilty to stock violations.
 > > > >
 > > > > Hans Conser

 > > "Bruce E. Calkins" wrote:
 > > >
 > > > The Rotapower 650 announcement went up a few days ago. If you will
 > notice,
 > > > Freedom Motors had planned to put the 530cc engine into production
 > first,
 > > > but because of the interest received in the larger
 > displacement/horsepower
 > > > output engine the 650cc is being produced first.
 > > >
 > > > Also, Dr. Moller did not "plead guilty" to anything.  Rather than go
 > into a
 > > > long battle with the SEC, he agreed to pay a fine.
 > > >
 > > > -MI

 > > I'll believe after I see it run for 500 hours Bruce. Its going to take
 you
 > > years to overcome your image. Best change your company name and hide
 > > the owner ship of the new company.
 > >
 > > Paul Lamar


 wadebush wrote:
 >
 > Bruce,
 > Instead of being defensive about the engine why not put one of your 650cc
 > engine in an airplane and fly it around to all the shows demonstrating
 that
 > it works. Better yet, one of each.
 > After some real air time hours, people not wanting to "roll their own" can
 > go "drop in" for their aircraft engines through you guys (Moeller /
 Freedom
 > Motors).
 > Until then the only "proven" (real air time rotaries) are the ones that
 > actually fly and are able to make it to the shows.

 > Paul has to be somewhat conservative especially on anything not flown. To
 > tell
 > everyone "yes, go and buy one" would put him at odds with potential
 lawsuits
 > and mad patrons should some unforeseen problem arise in the Freedom motor.
 > The engine is different enough thats its reliability is yet unproven
 > especially without a flying example. Of course people would be interested
 > but there will always be those that choose to pioneer their own way or, as
 > in my case, save tons of money while learning a subject extremely
 > interesting to me.
 > Just my take on this, but I could be wrong.
 >
 > Wade Bush


"Bruce E. Calkins" wrote:

 Dear Wade,

 We have been working with a group which intends to offer the engine to the
 aviation community and they, in turn, have been talking with a aircraft
 builder.  My understanding is that they will be getting one of the first 50
 engines that come out of our partner's facility in Minnesota and that it
 will be modified and used in some sort of aircraft application.  I have not
 been part of that discussion.  We are concentrating on the engine production
 requirements and meeting specifications for a number of non-aviation related
 applications as our top priority.

 Like Mr. Lamar, we do not suggest that one of the first applications of this
 engine be in an aircraft.  We would prefer to establish a performance
 history with a less safety-critical application.  But we have little control
 of the engine once it is sold and, realizing this, when we were approached
 by the group mentioned above, we suggested that they run independent tests
 and do their own evaluation.  Given the outcome is positive and the "first
 articles" coming out of our manufacturing effort are suitable for their use
 > in an aircraft, they will proceed.

 Again, we want our rotary engine to gain acceptance in a wide range of
 applications and have been working steadily (although slowly) towards that
 goal since we acquired the OMC design in the mid-1980's.  I know that many
 people have become frustrated with our apparent lack of progress, but we
 continued to work on both the 530 and 650 designs at our own expense.  Our
 requirements lead us to look first at the 530, but other industries needed
 the additional horsepower of the 650 (50 hp vs. 75 hp, respectively).

 We have slowly acquired all the specialized equipment needed to produce the
 engine in volume and built tooling for both the 530 and 650 engines, with
 custom tooling for the version required for our ducted fan application.
 Furthermore, we've been testing the engine in various configurations in our
 dyno facility nearly continuously for the past three years (two-to-three
 builds a week), and in a ducted fan test stand for about two years.  The
 eight 530 engines in the Skycar have now been in used periodically for about
 2 years and in a more than 20 brief hover flights over the past year.

 I appreciate that it has taken us a long time to bring the Rotapower engine
 to this point but I hope that we can get an unbiased appraisal of the
 engine, regardless of how long it takes.  As rotary engine supporters, I
 continue to think that this could be your goal as well.

 Sincerely,

 Bruce E. Calkins
 General Manager
 Moller International
 (530) 756-5086
 www.moller.com


First let me ask the obvious question. Who are those guys?
"a group which intends to offer the engine to the aviation community"

"talking with a aircraft builder" ???? Does that mean they are going
to attempt to certify the engine?

The rating is now down from 150 HP  to 75 HP is that correct?
If so that puts it in another market segment which is a tough market to
be in. Namely low cost two cycle engines. Is the "group" prepared
to compete on cost alone as that is what they are going to have to
do? Certain improvements have made in the low cost light weight 2 cycle
engine making it much less prone to seize. Namely water cooling,
aluminum bores and EFI.

Paul Lamar


   I cant believe the number of people that will run out and lay out
cold hard cash for something that is unproven.
  Just look at the BD-5 and you would think that people would get wise
but no Jim comes up up with the BD-10 and he took 50 some deposits at
Oshkosh before it even flew and then some idiot bought the whole
company from Jim and killed himself in the peace of crap, you think
he deserves the Darwin award or what ?
  Not to mention even if this Freedom motor is a good engine, where
are you going to get parts for it if or more likely when the company
goes tits up ?

  Ken Welter

 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.