Subject: There has to be a better way!!!
From: ACRE
Date: 6/8/2003, 3:41 PM


Tom Smythe wrote:

Read that as less expensive.

I just got off the phone with an aircraft structural engineering
firm
and they're asking for $150,000! to do the design work on the plane
I've
already done the configuration work on (that part they quoted $3,500
for
if I hadn't done it yet).

Anyone know of a way a non-engineer but, technically knowledgable
guy
can put together an airplane and survive in it?

Thanks,

tom


Vance might be able to help you out for a lot less money. He has
designed
several very successful composite experimental airplanes

Paul Lamar


That number does indeed seem high, but one would have to have a feel
for just how detailed a design you requested.\Drawing up every rivet
hole
or every ply on a composite can burn up a lot of expensive manhours if
you have a professional staff and high overhead. If you got this quote
over
the phone, you must be aware that less than one percent of such calls
are serious enough to even consider. I have worked in conjuction
with Rich Trickel on quotes where we generally consider the completion
of one airframe set of parts and some tooling for composite construction
and quotes for a relatively simple 2 place are typically about 200 to
300K
and that is with low overhead and slim profit margines.

Non-engineers have designed some very fine airplanes using experience,
borrowed state of the art, good practice, and patience and only farming
out some of the major structural calculations (if at all)
The market is full of good airplane designs and kits, but I fully
understand
the desire to exercise the creative juices - but do not plan on making a
bunch
of money, nor expecting a professional firm being so interested in your
design to absorb any of the costs.
Vance J

Walter Williams wrote:

just remember Tom, Orville and Wilbur were not aircraft engineers and we can
do better only because of the shoulders we are standing on.  walt

I might add there are several good books on the subject. If it is aluminum
Analysis & Design of Flight Vehicle Structures by Bruhn is the bible. I am willing to bet
Richard Van Gruesven has a copy. On the overall design A Practical Guide to Airplane 
Performance by Donald Crawford comes to mind. In Composites it is Composite Basics by 
Andrew C. Marshall and Advanced Aircraft Design by Martin Hollmann. In fact Martin
might be interested in doing the design. The last three books are available from
Aircraft Spruce.

If you know all this and you just want drawings hire a person that knows
Rhino or some other 3D cad program and have him/her knock out the drawings.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.