Subject: Torque diesel automotive engine suitabilty
From: ACRE
Date: 6/12/2003, 5:16 AM


-Ted Boudreaux wrote:

Then again...

I drive an '02 VW Jetta TDI (direct injection turbodiesel).  The curb
weight
of this car is within 100 lbs of the 2.0 gasoline car.

tedb


Thats about right. 25% more engine weight. What is the RPM red line for
this
engine?  HP rating?

Paul Lamar


-Ted Boudreaux wrote:

In US trim, the engine produces 90bhp @ 3750 RPM.  Torque is 155lb.ft @
1900rpm.  Redline is 4700rpm.  approx 50mpg on the highway

In some European models, the same block & head will produce 150hp @
4000rpm
& 236 lbft @ 1900 rpm.  The euro version uses a different turbo &
injection
system (Pumpe Duse-- integral fuel pump & injector assembly).

tedb-

André & Wilana Claassen wrote:

The weight of the complete VW tdi engine is 135 kg [297 pounds] (i'd was investigating
the poss.but the cost is to high)The other thing about diesel wich i like
very much is the fact that it will not ignite easy .At the moment i'm buzy
making fire break's around some timber plantations ,we're using a fire
lighter for this fueled by a gas/diesel mix you dont get the mix to burn if
you dont use at least more than 50% gas , at 50% it burns slowly +- like a
candle .(diesel is a much safer fuel for that reason i believe)
Groetnis
Andre Claassen

An in-flight fire can ruin your whole day, no doubt about it but fortunately it is
rather rare in properly developed installations. One of the reasons the carb is under
the aircraft engine IMHO is any leaks do not tend to drip on the exhaust 
system. It behooves us to think about this when we place our fuel injectors.

This engine might make a fine engine for a low and slow airplane with a rather
poor payload but a  psru would still be required. A low and slow airplane needs 
a large diameter prop for good efficiency during take off and climb.
The durability in aircraft service is yet to be determined but I doubt
it would be as good as a diesel piston engine designed for high continuos
HP service. I am sure the weight of this engine has been reduced and hence
the durability compromised to optimize it for low continuos HP automotive 
service. It would be very expensive to put one on a dyno and run it for
1000 hours at 75 to 80 HP to find out. 

Never the less many people have chosen some
automotive piston engine, installed it in an aircraft and flown it for several
hundred hours. This process has been on going for the last 70 years
or so. Usually any given individual gives up after a few hundred hours
and possibly another person or organization tries. I can name at least five 
different Chevy V8  projects that have failed in just the last five
years. The smaller the automotive engine the longer it seems to last
and the longer it takes to discover that it is not a totally satisfactory
aircraft engine solution.

This correlates well with the nature of automotive service in that
the amount of continuos power required is largely independent of the 
installed peak HP. For an example a Corvette sports car engine is about
the lowest duty cycle automotive engine one can find.

On the other hand a one liter engine in an econo box is working its
butt off cruising down the freeway at 80 MPH. This is the reason
the early low HP Subaru engines got their good reputations for
service in aircraft IMHO. Pump the Subaru up to 200 HP and expect it
to last in 150 HP aircraft engine service is a bit optimistic.
Another example is the original 40 HP VW air cooled engine. In the
old days a VW bug would run flat out at 72 MPH all day long on the 
then new freeway system in the US. People were not happy with that
and VW increased the power. The early VW engines made fine aircraft
engines but the later higher HP versions started to fail in aircraft
service. Some compromise was eventually arrived at in the 60 HP
range as I recall.

This brings us to a very important yet subtle factor in the rotaries 
favor in that literally dozens have been installed in aircraft over the least 
30 years and have proven totally satisfactory in terms of basic engine 
durability.  This is still ongoing but several users have gone well over 
a thousand hours with no sign of structural failure or high wear. I feel 
we must increase the RPM, increase the PSRU reduction ratio and increase 
the HP to find the limits of the rotaries life in aircraft service. Otherwise 
it will take the rest of my life to wear out the first rotary. My goal 
is to see a worn out rotary in normal aircraft service :) In other words 
I think we have been way too conservative so far. 

Ken Welter and his 2900 pound amphibious Coot is an exception. Ken runs almost a
3:1 psru and uses nitrous oxide on a regular basis to increase the HP
by an additional 100  to jump the Coot up on the step and out of the water.
 
Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.