Subject: For sale milling machine
From: ACRE
Date: 6/19/2003, 7:43 AM


In a message dated 6/12/03 9:07:28 PM, rotaryeng@earthlink.net
writes:
<<I am thinking of buying a new mill. Airgas has a Chinese knee
mill
on sale with table drive and digital read out for $5000
I will sell my current cheap Chinese mill for $500 FOB Santa
Paula.
You pick it up. Good shape. Works fine. 3 HP at 110 volts single
phase
but can be wired for 220 single phase. No cuts or gouges in
table.
R8 taper. Same as Bridgeport tooling.
Paul Lamar >>

===========================================================
For the $5000 your going to spend, you could buy a good used CNC
Bridgeport
with a bad controller($1000-$2000), add a cheap IBM
computer(Pentium
166MHz+)
for $250, and a after market new controller($800-$1500). CNC
cad/cam
software
>from free-$800. Just my two cents.
Rich Gillen

Most of the CNC Bridgeport's I have seen for sale are $8000 and
up.

Are they on Ebay?

Paul Lamar
=================================================

Yes, ebay is a very good place to find used CNC machines, parts,
etc.
Also do a Google search for
used CNC machines.
Rich


Paul,


Rich is telling the truth. Here is my machine that I did just that very
thing with. Although I upgraded to a little more expensive control. If
you
are willing to trade some speed and power you could use Gecko drives to
control the servos and do it for cheap.(
http://www.geckodrive.com/ )There
is an article in this months Home Shop Machinist on how. I have seen
perfectly good boss mills go for less than $800 dollars. They are too
slow
for modern production. The original controls suck and most of them blew
before the machine had much wear on it. Machine tool industry is in a
major
slump so these things are CHEAP!! Add a servo and a rotary table and you
have a full 4 axis machine. The machine envelope is only 18x12x6 on the
series one machines like mine. Knee travel can handle much larger parts
but
you have to do things in stages. The series 2 machines have a 24x18x6
envelope but they weigh about 4000 lbs. They usually come with a
standard
cat 30 quick change.

Also see:

http://www.yeagerautomation.com/shop/

Monty


Couple of questions. Does it have servos or stepper motors.


Stepper motors. Thru boss 7 or 8 (not sure which, but you can tell by
looking at the motors. The steppers have big fins on them and are short and
fat. The servos are longer with no fins). After that they were servo
machines. Servo's are much more expensive and difficult to retrofit. Unless
you are doing production, you don't need the speed that servo's offer.
Stepper's work just fine. These  machines already have ball screws and
central lube systems. That was a typo in my original post, it should have
said steppers not servos.


R8 taper?


No, they come with a standard Cat 30 quick change tool holder. There are two
types, I can't remember the manufacturers off hand, but one has ears and one
has slots. They are very common. I see them on Ebay all the time. I have
been to auctions and seen literally bins full of these tool holders. They
hold standard sizes of end mills etc. They are also inexpensive and much
less of a pain than R8 stuff. Production shops have moved to Cat 40 tool
holders so the Cat 30 stuff is laying around.


Do all stepper motor amp systems work with all stepper motor mills?


Pretty much yes. If you stick with the Bridgeport's, definitely. Otherwise
you may have to play with step times, ramp up and down etc. Boss machines
had two types of servo motors, Sigma, and Superior. There are some slight
wiring differences but no big deal.


Same question for servo systems.

Stay away from servos. More expensive.


In other words what kind of can
of worms would I be getting into if I had to retrofit
the electronics?


You WILL have to retrofit the electronics. Unless of course you want to
learn how to use the old tape reader and replace the difficult to find
boards in the obsolete piece of crap when it breaks every other week. The
boss machines originally came with tape readers. One of the common failure
modes was a transformer blowing. You can look in the back cabinet at the 3
transformers used to drive the steppers. If one or more of them looks like
it was smoked (signs of arcing, and melted insulation. Transformer will
smell bad and the conformal coating will look like it has melted) stay away.

It usually will fry the stepper on that axis. The machine will run, but the
stepper will be weak. Of course if you find one of these for really cheap,
like $500 or free. Get it. I see the steppers on Ebay often. A lot of people
retrofit these machines with more modern steppers to speed them up and then
sell the old ones.  If you like you can just take the old cabinets off and
throw them away. OR, I used the back cabinet and placed all of my
electronics in it. If you are using Gecko drives you can use a smaller
enclosure. Basically the way it works is you have a dedicated DOS machine to
run the CNC software. The PC tells the stepper drivers what to do and they
drive the steppers. The Boss machine has a mechanical digital readout built
into the machine that you can use to double check operation. I used the
AH-HA control for my machine, which is basically plug and play. It has a 12
amp capability. I think that the Gecko drives are 4 amps. They will run the
machine just fine. You just can't hog on a chunk of steel at a high rate of
speed and expect it not to loose steps. You can do most things though and
the price is much lower. I don't think it is a can of worms at all. I had no
trouble with it. Based on what I have seen of your electronics knowledge on
here, I think you will find it a breeze.

Monty

Thanks Monty for the education. I was not sure what I would be getting into.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.