Subject: Cooling System Restrictor - Good or Bad?
From: ACRE
Date: 6/25/2003, 2:53 PM

Mark Steitle wrote:

Paul,

From past statements I have been convinced of the benefits of removing the thermostat and controlling temps with cowl flaps.
What I'm wondering is if I should replace the thermostat with a restrictor plate, or leave it "wide open".

Over the years I have heard & read differing opinions on whether or not a cooling system restrictor (such as a thermostat) is
beneficial or not to cooling of an engine.  Lynn Hannover recently stated that he runs a 5/8" restrictor in his 13B race engines
and doesn't have a problem with overheating.  This makes some sense as the typical thermostat has a fairly small passage-way for
coolant to pass through.

I got to questioning this again yesterday after reading an article on cooling systems at (don't laugh)
http://www.grapeaperacing.com/GrapeApeRacing/tech/coolingmods.cfm that explains that having a restrictor in the cooling system
actually raises the boiling point of the coolant to close to 300 degrees F by creating 40-45 lbs of pressure between the pump
and the restrictor.  If this is true, it seems like this would be highly desirable.

Here's what they say about system pressures, "The pressure in the block is higher than the radiator pressure, this is because
the pump is building pressure due to the thermostat being a restriction. This pressure raises the boiling point of the coolant
and reduces the chance of steam pockets, so never run with out a thermostat (or some form of restriction). The radiator cap will
usually hold 15-18 psi, if the radiator holds the system at 15 psi, the boiling point of plain water will be raised to 250° F.
The water pump can then make an additional 40-45 psi in the engine and bring that boiling point close to 300° F. So as you can
see, pressure is important."

They also state, "Most people seem to think that all a cooling system needs to do is keep the engine from overheating. But what
is not realized is if the engine runs too cool, thermal efficiency is lost and power is reduced."

So, I'm wondering... do I want high pressures, or high flow.  It doesn't seem like I can have both at the same time.

Mark S.


Mark here is what H. Heisler says about the subject in his book Advanced Engine Tech.

***********************************************************************
Radiator thermostat performance
When the conventional cooling system thermostat
closes, it stops nearly all coolant circulation
through the radiator. Thus, coolant already in the
radiator (approximately 60% of the total coolant
in the system) quickly cools, and this may reduce
its temperature in cold weather to something like
30 deg C to 40 deg C colder than the coolant in the
engine. This stop and go thermostatic control
creates an endless surge of cold quenching
coolant through to the hot cylinder-block. This is
capable of producing a temperature differential.
from the bottom to the top of the engine, of as
much as 40 deg C. Consequently, high thermo-cyclic
stresses are created which distort the cylinder-
block and head and will eventually cause damage
to critical areas in the engine's cooling passage-
ways.
        The great benefit of the automatic radiator
shutter system is that once the engine reaches its
operating temperature, the main-flow radiator
thermostat remains permanently open so that
coolant circulation is continuous.
 
       Coolant temperature control is now achieved
entirely by the shutters regulating the quantity of
air flowing to the radiator matrix.


Radiator shutter performance
Thermostatic fan-drives only control overheating
situations, whereas the thermo-automatic
radiator shutters prevent overcooling occurring.
The automatic shutters transform the radiator
into a variable-rate heat-exchanger by controlling
and changing the air flow across the radiator core
(cooling capacity) corresponding to the constantly
changing load and speed of the engine.

Temperature variation reduces the degree of ther-
mal stressing and keeps the engine working at its
most efficient temperature under most driving
conditions. Shutters work well in conjunction
with fan-blade drive controls as the latter are still
required to reduce power consumption and noise.

*************************************

End of quote.

Here is what he has to say about radiators.

*****************************************************
14.3    Fundamentals of
radiator design

Factors which influence the size and effectiveness
of a radiator to be installed in an engine cooling
system are as follows.

I       Increasing the coolant flow-rate reduces the
temperature drop between the entry and exit
passageways.
2       Increasing the mean temperature difference
between the coolant and the air entering the
matrix core raises the heat dissipation capacity
of the radiator.
3       Increasing the coolant flow-rate, proportion-
ally raises the power required to drive the
water-pump and therefore offsets the improve-
ment in radiator efficiency at high flow-rates.
4       A suitable liquid coolant temperature drop
through the radiator matrix ranges from 5 deg C to
10 deg C at full throttle over the normal working
speed range of a typical engine.
5       Coolant containing up to 50% ethylene glycol
reduces the heat dissipation capacity by some-
thing like 15% . owing to the lower specific heat
capacity compared with that of water.
6       Increasing the cooling system's operating
pressure raises the boiling point of the coolant.
A 0.1 bar increase in coolant pressure raises
the coolant temperature by approximately
2.5C. The raised coolant temperature entering
the radiator increases the temperature differ-
ence between the liquid coolant input to .the
core tubes and the air-flow temperature enter-
ing the frontal area of the radiator matrix. The
thermal capacity of the radiator is increased by
something like 1.8% for each 1 deg C increase of
temperature difference between the coolant
input temperature and the input air tempera-
ture.
7       The most economical radiator is the one with
the narrowest matrix depth and the widest air
cell spacing that will provide the required heat
dissipation within the frontal area available.
8       Increasing the matrix core depth increases the
heat dissipation capacity but this capacity in-
crease becomes much smaller beyond some
critical depth. For example. a 50% increase in
core depth improves the heat dissipation
capacity by 15%, whereas a 100% increase in
depth raises its capacity by only 20%.

****************************************
End of second quote. Nowhere in the 50 page chapter on cooling
does he mention the use of a restrictor anywhere in the cooling 
system for any reason.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.