Subject: Cooling System Restrictor - Good or Bad?
From: ACRE
Date: 6/25/2003, 12:03 AM


Mark Steitle wrote:
 >
 > Paul,
 >
 > From past statements I have been convinced of the benefits of removing
the
thermostat and controlling temps with cowl flaps.
 > What I'm wondering is if I should replace the thermostat with a
restrictor
plate, or leave it "wide open".
 >
 > Over the years I have heard & read differing opinions on whether or not
a
cooling system restrictor (such as a thermostat) is
 > beneficial or not to cooling of an engine.  Lynn Hanover recently stated
that he runs a 5/8" restrictor in his 13B race engines
 > and doesn't have a problem with overheating.  This makes some sense as
the
typical thermostat has a fairly small passage-way for
 > coolant to pass through.
 >
 > I got to questioning this again yesterday after reading an article on
cooling systems at (don't laugh)
 > http://www.grapeaperacing.com/GrapeApeRacing/tech/coolingmods.cfm that
explains that having a restrictor in the cooling system
 > actually raises the boiling point of the coolant to close to 300 degrees
F
by creating 40-45 lbs of pressure between the pump
 > and the restrictor.  If this is true, it seems like this would be highly
desirable.
 >
 > Here's what they say about system pressures, "The pressure in the block
is
higher than the radiator pressure, this is because
 > the pump is building pressure due to the thermostat being a restriction.
This pressure raises the boiling point of the coolant
 > and reduces the chance of steam pockets, so never run with out a
thermostat (or some form of restriction). The radiator cap will
 > usually hold 15-18 PSI, if the radiator holds the system at 15 PSI, the
boiling point of plain water will be raised to 250° F.
 > The water pump can then make an additional 40-45 PSI in the engine and
bring that boiling point close to 300° F. So as you can
 > see, pressure is important."
 >
 > They also state, "Most people seem to think that all a cooling system
needs to do is keep the engine from overheating. But what
 > is not realized is if the engine runs too cool, thermal efficiency is
lost
and power is reduced."
 >
 > So, I'm wondering... do I want high pressures, or high flow.  It doesn't
seem like I can have both at the same time.
 >
 > Mark S.


The restrictor, it turns out is actually less than 5/8". All of the coolant
leaves the engine through this restriction. The side benefit of the restrictor
is that the radiator and hoses are not exposed to high pressure.

And there is considerable pressure. I have not measured a Mazda, but for
reasons unknown to me at the time, a friend was using my dyno to dial in his MGB
engine. You can collect quite a few friends if you have a 300 HP Stuska dyno.

 Anyway, think 1939 tractor engine. He was slowing the water pump by juggling
a collection of pulleys. Because it costs HP to turn up unneeded revs on the
water pump. So he had a pressure gauge in the block. The first thing we
noticed was that there was a bunch of pressure in the block. Then at high revs the
pressure was all over the place. The suction side of the pump was boiling the
water. Just replacing the thermostat fixed that.

 By the time he was done, with the slowest pump speed we could come up with,
we had 40 PSI at 7,800 RPM. (don't try that with stock rods). So if you are
among those people who fear a thermostat failure, that leaves you with a
restrictor. You can add the pressure cap number to the block pressure number. So the
cap has to be in a location where block pressure can see it. Like on a remote
recovery bottle. Otherwise the block pressure will overpower the cap and dump
coolant when you rev the engine.

 So there are a couple of horses going down the drain, if you need them. Just
slow the pump. Keep in mind that it will be that much slower at idle also.

Not as big a problem at 6,000 or 6,500 RPM but real easy to avoid. You could
loose a lot of coolant and loose system pressure but still not loose pressure
inside the block where you need it. At least until coolant loss uncovers the
pump.

The suction side hose should have a wire support in it or be aluminum tubing
if possible. On the dyno, if you are foolish enough to get close during a
pull, you will notice that without a restrictor in the outlet, that the top
radiator hose is as hard as a diamond. It is rather firm even with a restrictor.
Think about that hose getting a little leak or blowing off at 30 or 40 PSI.

Lynn E. Hanover

That is why we have wiggins couplings and aluminum tube water pump plumbing.
This engine uses a 50 psi pressure cap, aluminum tubing plumbing and wiggins
couplings.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.