Subject: Cooling System Restrictor - Good or Bad?
From: ACRE
Date: 6/25/2003, 10:09 PM


End of second quote. Nowhere in the 50 page chapter on cooling
 does he mention the use of a restrictor anywhere in the cooling
 system for any reason.

 Paul Lamar


This essay suggests that thermal damage is occurring as though a fully warmed
engine is plunged  again and again into icy water. Baloney. Thermostats don't
jump open and snap shut in an endless flamenco dance. The dreaded thermostat
is not killing off millions of engines per year. Not even in North Dakota in
the winter. Those people do put cool looking covers over their grills to
prevent supercooling the coolant.
I had to do that on my Fiat. Between the aluminum head and the heater on full
blast, it would just not heat up. Better than a VW Beetle, but not much.

On the other hand, when cold, an engine equipped with a thermostat will
operate at lower temperatures longer than an engine equipped with a closed loop
system like the stock rotary or the old Fiats.

With a thermostat the entire coolant supply system may not be used at all if
the OAT is too low. I could drive to work in my old Chevy van with the heater
on full blast and the radiator would barely get warm. I could cool the system
so well with the heater core that the thermostat would never open. The
thermostat has a bubble valve that lets air out of a system being filled, so it also
leaks coolant to the radiator, and that gets supercooled. The thermostat does
not prevent flow to the heater core.

The stock rotary thermostat prevents flow to the radiator until the block is
evenly heated by recalculating water. The same with the Fiats. But they used
an external in line thermostat in a silly collection of hoses. The closed
system like the rotary is the obvious winner in the efficiency department. The
engine warms quickly and the temps are uniform throughout the block before the
thermostat begins to open. Of course in the great white North, you can still cool
it with the heater core and never reach operating temperature.

With the radiator shutters only, it will take a long time to warm the engine.
All of the coolant is passing through the engine all of the time. All of the
coolant must be heated before the engine can reach operating temperature. Not
just the coolant inside the block. In a cold area it may never warm up enough
to supply good heat from the heater core. Or reach minimum operating
temperature. Like my truck.

Answer these questions.

Why is the top radiator hose so small and the bottom hose so big?

I don't have an answer for that right at the moment. It will come
to me I am sure. Why do you think that is?

Why is there a wire support in the bottom hose but not the top?

No problem here. That is an easy one. We are at the end of all 
restrictions with the lowest pressure possible. With the thermostat 
closed the pump is trying to suck an immovable object.

If a higher flow rate is the goal, why are there so many sets of pulleys
available to slow down the water pump?

Two reasons. One: less HP consumed when the flow is not needed. Say drag
racing. Two: pump cavitation due to excessive RPM.

Why are so many circle track supply houses selling restrictors for small
block Chevys? Why did the first Can Am Chevy engine I took down have a restrictor
in it?

Urban myth? :)

If Burt Rutan talks for 6 hours about aircraft design, but never mentions
balancing
control surfaces, does that mean that balancing control surfaces is a bad
idea?

Lynn E. Hanover

You need to read the book Lynn. It is a survey course on modern cooling system
design. I have about a dozen tech papers on the subject. In fact there is
a whole Institute of Mechanical Engineers conference on the subject
periodically. Go to your local university library and look up some of
the tech papers.

Here is a list I have mostly from the 99 conference. 
C543/002/99
C543/028/99
C543/047/99 
C496/035/95
C543/034/99
SAE papers.
930153
920787
920548
931092
920549

Go to the respective web sites and look up the titles.

So far I have not run across the concept of a restrictor.

Here are a few SAE  papers most of which I have not read yet.
Sorry about the quality. My OCR had some problems with the
fine print.


Car underside. upperbon? ano engine
cooling system interactions - and
their contributions to aeroavnamie
drag
£4L Trar&. Xo.? Q~
        860:1: SI-(-§-
Aerodsnarniz end racteristie o Sc??
are NT  86021( SP~~r

\       acuon: t?razca ajuminum radiator to
Ford Temtx iooar-
£417 Tram La. 0 860(44

Caterpillar foleted core radiator
£417 7rans.. Vo.. 95    86(1765

Goolinit ~vsterr, destgr and standard-
izatior. a:     Case    86076t

Exoerimeriral and flign: aeterrninatior
of the soja- aPsorprance tor an OSR
radiator ar e functior of incidence
an~1e
£417 Trans., lU. ~: 860978 (P-1?71

Enhanced evaporative surface for
two-phase mounting plates
£417 Trans., lcd. 05 860979 (P-l~

Evaluation of Space Station thermal
control techniques 860998 (P-l~?

Optimization of heat rejection sun-
sxstem for solar dynamic Bravion
esele power system 860999 (P-i

Transient of temperature rising in
hydraulic system
£41 Trans.. lOS OR 861298 lSPl?Ol

National and intemational measure-
ment techniuues fo- color determina-
tion
£417 Trans.. Vol. 95 861693 (P-184

Environmental avoidance concepts for
steerable space station radiators
        861831

High capacity demonstration of han-
eyco mb panel heat pipes
£417 Trans.. VOl. 05 861833

Prototype thermal bus for manned
space station compartments
SAL Trans.. lvi. 95 861835

Air sensing viscous fan drive perfor-
mance on charge air cooled engines
        £41 Trans., Vol. 95     861944
(orrosiol pCi cut at: Ia: autamobil
radiator tones  862(CI (1-I Y->

-~ comparist. at corrosiot: ott passe-
cc- ca- bodies ii Foruni ane 17?S-
XII Iron. 10. < 8h2(lt IF-I

--a apnaca:oe.sw 0? u can,:.::
oulino t. neac oUt? die-se ruettie
        -Xe :ran,.      .


- os el-nrnet e aicntio-~t-
u~tn:- ite Neoted. br:ztne pro-es- -
orrasiot- resistane: of try alort::nurr
riliators hs applvtng   Nocojo,. ira: -
inc process
N-IL Lrone. ~, at       fTh18(

Impros cc plastic- radiator tani attach-
men metnod      870182

Stres- distribotiot ana stress reloetior.
ir copper brass radiators
S-IL Trans. loS Ot      ~l7(1l83
Ne- teerinolog for copper aii Pest
radiators       870187

Lay- noise compact and efficient cool -
ing system with tangential fta~ fan
SAX iran:.. Vol Of 870983 P.105

hvbrio Honeycomb Panel Hear Rejec-
tion Svstetr.
S-if Irons. Ia. Q~      87141~
Iherma, contra. and orsier the
ERS-i payload   8?1461

intractoetior I numeric:: metroti it
coolne ~-x step slnto latior 8~J 467

Preliminar-, oesign of the Spec So-
lon internal Thcrrnat C ontrey Svsten,
£41 lrano Vol Of 871505

Design and compot er smulatior etf
microprocessor cant rolic. lobricatine
a cooline ?stem far trod diesel
engine
£11 >ana. lol. O~       880485

A nonventing cooling System for
spaee environment extras-chicolar
aetis-its - using radiation and regener-
able thermal storage
£41 Trans., loS 0       881063

Prototype space ereettible radiator sys-
tem ground test article des-elopment
541 irons., VOL 0~ 881066

Snace Station thermal test bed status
and plans
-I-IL irons.. Ic)!. 07  881068

Spice Station thermal control doring
on-orbit assembls
S-IL Trans. VOL 0       881070

Front-end airfoss rate simulation
        881748

Practical experiences v- ith splitter fin
products for OEM and afiermarket
applications    890228

Contact conductance evaluation IV a
full scale space erectable radiatot
pressurized interface   891463

Development of twa-phase fluid loop
systems for future space platforms
£417 Trans., VOL 98 891470

Thermal balance test of EURECA
thermal model   891521

Conceptual design of a liquid droplet
radiator space-flight experiment
        891565
I.      -sriape-~ taifiato: fat niotar:- ci:?
        891784  (P224:

i)anl- -ptis- s ersus single -Past ia/ba
or f-v diitarrtoas?- applteatton <
        8C246(

1 )e-sgr an-. ar-n cat tot. i-s aluatar 0?
at inn-s--to -s ulirit- s-ste-n IC
nte-oion, an: i~e:s s trucks 8~246?

lies- rite,, ca-lint- ?stern
900001 ( SI -F2C

        ti:traetcristie- at axil f-s. Ian ?sit.
diagatial fly- hof-
        h-i! r -on-.. IC;. 0-   900085

State-of-tnt -::r copper ~5ras? radiato-
a: Nippanoenso pin I - Ness radiator
developmenr
        SI-IL iron - 1(1.7 0.)  900405

State-of-the -ar: capper/brass radiator
at Nipponoens - nan Ii - liigt etOCCO-
sian resistise fit: br ness radiator
        SI-IL irons.. Ic.. 00   90040

Determination of aluminum ?-acoum
brazinir furnace conditions by post-
mortem examination of Orazed assert-
bItes
£41 irons. la.. 00      900409

        Pertormanee of p:trallcl floss cotidens-
ers in s cheota- applicaitorn 90059~

lnpros ed ilternied and meenanical
design cr copPer nras radIatOrs
S-IL 7 rot-.. ~. 00 900724

        Slass strain rao testing of automotive -
        radiator brass it engine- coolants
S-IL iron:... Ia. 00
900807 (SP-Sll,

Mittiatorizatian studs at teat exhaust-
tic radiato- o~ lonar hase 901206

loss -temperature thermal control tot
lunar base
S-IL ironic-.. loS 00
        9(11242 (SP-831)

Actise thermal control systems for
lonar anc martian expioratior.
S-XE irons.. lo. 90
        901243 (SP4-31)

j~A~~ora~atTh


ll&rmes thermal control subsystem
design concepts
5.4K irons.. Ic!. 90 901365

EURECA thermal control design and
        performance     901366

Thermal design and analysts of
Columbos pressurised modules
        901369

Modular, thermal bus-to-radiator inte-
gral heat exchanger design far space
station freedom 901435 (SP-829)

The influence of isolating air to air
coolers against failure due to thermal
        expansion       902262

Heat transfer and friction characteri~
tics of turbulator radiator tubes
        S.41    Trants.. lvi. 100       910197

A mechanically bonded AKG-ML
3-aluminum radiator as a direct
replacement for brazed units
        SAF     Trants. VOl. 100        910198

A corrosion resistant alloy for vacuum
brazed aluminum heat exchangers
        SAL     Tranta.. Vol. 100       910591
Recommended space statiotr radiator
orientatiot- profile
5417 irons.. Ill. 100
~ll343 (SP~87s)

Flight perlorm:incr of tie spacelab
Astro- I ntissio:. integrated radiator
ss stem
£41 iron:.. Vol 109     911589

Static etiaracicristle of : tss a-phase
fluiel loop system ~i2(123 (1-246)

-(~(om~uier aided analysis of heat flows
itt vehicie cooling system
920010 (1-248)




920177
Zinc soldered cooper and brass
radiators - Their processing and their
test results
5.4.11  irons.. Iv!. 101

Radiator design and material recoin-
mendations based on failure- mode
analysis        920178

Radiator failure mode analysis in a
high road salt environment 920179

Corrosion of copper/brass radiators-
corrosion       mechanisms-preven~i0~
actions 920180
Accelerated corrosion testing of auto-
mative radiaters of copper
materials - .4 critictil sons-es
5417 irons.. Va! 10! 920181

Simultaneaus computti tion of the~.
external floss around a cat body and5~~
tne internal floss through its engine
compartment
£41 irans.. La!. 101    920342

Heat rejection from high output adia- -
batic diesel engine     920541

The - tubes touching - mult;-ross- radi-
~ ator design   4
        £417 irons.. La;. 10!   920548

- - A Gevelopment of a light weight and
high performance aluminum radiator
920549

Experimental analvsi~ for the (-~~
improvement of radiator cooling air
Dtake and discharge     -
901364~. SAL irons.. lvi. 101
        920787  (SP-918)
Modeling and analysis of the space
station freedom active thermal control
system radiators using SINDA
FLUINT  921145

Space station ATCS radiator rotation
profiles in LVLH, TEAILVLH. arrow
and gravity gradient mode 921146

Thermal design of a liquid droplet
radiator        921205

Thermodiode system application fat
the achievement of loss- temperature
for optic sensors at extemal distal-
bances  921209

Optimization of the mass and hydrau-
lic characteristics of radiators
        921246

Application of FLUIDNET-G svft
ss-are to the preliminary thermal and
hydraulic design of HERMES space-
plane   921293

Radiator/water evaporator heat rejec-
tion system for an advanced extraVe
Iticular mobility unit 921301

iThermal control design of the Euro-
pean polar platform     921326

Conceptual thermal design and arialy-
~is of a far-infrared;mid- infrared
remote sensing instrument 921369

Test results of the share II mid-deck
flight experiment
SAE Trans., Vol. !O1    921407

Knitted automotive heater hose static
equations       930151
EQS AM capillary pumped heat trans-
port system development testing using
FDM     932234

Thermal control subsystem design for
the EQS thermal infrared radiometer
        932237



BTW have you measured the pressure on both sides of the restrictor?


Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.