alventures wrote:
Mark here is what H. Heisler says about the subject in his book Advanced
Engine Tech.
***********************************************************************
Radiator thermostat performance
When the conventional cooling system thermostat
closes, it stops nearly all coolant circulation
through the radiator. Thus, coolant already in the
radiator (approximately 60% of the total coolant
in the system) quickly cools, and this may reduce
its temperature in cold weather to something like
30 deg C to 40 deg C colder than the coolant in the
engine. This stop and go thermostatic control
creates an endless surge of cold quenching
coolant through to the hot cylinder-block. This is
capable of producing a temperature differential.
from the bottom to the top of the engine, of as
much as 40 deg C. Consequently, high thermo-cyclic
stresses are created which distort the cylinder-
block and head and will eventually cause damage
to critical areas in the engine's cooling passage-
ways.<<<
When was this written? I'd say it is pretty much rubbish; and could
only happen in some system with unusual dynamics. Thermostats open
gradually over a small range of temperature; they aren't just on/off
switches. As the thermostat setting is approached, a small amount of
coolant flows from the rad and mixes in the engine. It gradually
increases until the system is at uniform temp.
I also disagree with some of the statement he makes about rad design,
but no need to go into that.
Al
1995. Perhaps he overstated the case but you must admit with the conventional
thermostat closed there is no circulation in the block and you could still have
cold and hot spots.
I would like to hear your take on the rad statements.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.