"Powell, Ken" wrote:
snip everthing .....
Paul and Vance,
After following this discussion I decided to make a couple of observations (thank goodness Paul keeps things civil) and to make a few comments. As you know I'm not an engineer but at one time I could make a 2-stroke go pretty well (National #8 in the 1988 AMA Hare Scrambles Championship/Class B - wasn't good enough to be an 'A' rider though). Bill Jepson is our real 2-stroke expert so maybe he will correct me if I make any mistakes.
1. A wankel cannot be compared to either a piston 4-stroke OR a piston 2-stroke; a wankel is - well - a wankel.
2. a wankel does operate on a 4-stroke cycle but ... The 270 degree rotational cycle rules out any direct comparision to conventional piston engines. This makes displacement comparisons invalid.
3. 2-strokes - these are not suitable for comparison because:
a.) the lower compression ratios obtainable due to the exhaust port
b.) the lack of control over overlap while maintaining sufficient port size (I'm really thinking of piston ported engines here - some of the other methods allow some flexibility but have other problems). It is interesting to note that a 2-stroke optimised for max power at 7000 RPM will suffer from dismal BSFC at low RPM due to the mixture being pushed out the open exhaust port before the rising piston enters the compression phase.
One last comment. A 2-stroke is a wonderful, durable engine with great performance if you can live with the poor BSFC. You must keep the egt temps under control; too rich you will foul plugs and stick the rings; too lean you will seize or hole the piston.
Ken Powell
Comparing the engines in the sense you are comparing them is valid.
All I am doing is comparing the potential quantity of fuel and air processed in unit
time. In other words HP potential or displacement. Now these engines all have their
advantages and disadvantages. I won't go into them in detail
but IMHO the advantages of the Wankel on balance make it the winner for light
aircraft engines.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.