Subject: High heat resin
From: ACRE
Date: 7/22/2003, 10:33 AM


I beg to differ on the topic of heat and UV being the only thing
that
will
cause plastic to decay. What about chemical attack? Molded in
stress,
stress
corrosion, moisture contamination, dielectric breakdown. I design
plastic
parts for a living. I don't know who the hell Arhenius is, but to me
that
just looks like a standard reaction rate equation applicable to just
about
all reactions. It is exponential, but where is the intercept? At
zero
Kelvin? What is that little constant k? This is far too general a
form
of
this equation to be making application specific conclusions.

 SNIP
Beware the Giant equation with many terms of questionable accuracy
raised to
many powers. Also beware the oversimplified equation. You can
probably
make
this equation work by measuring E, k, and T for a SPECIFIC case. Do
you
have
good data on what these are for various plastics with various
solvents?
Is
it good within 5%, 10%, 30% for all the solvents or combinations
seen in
an
underhood application,  who knows? What happens when you have a 30%
error
for the value of a constant and place it in an exponential equation?
Pure
science meets engineering.

Monty


Thanks Monty,

    Always great to hear from someone with both knowledge and experience
in
a particular area.  From what you related, my polyurethane casting
supporting my throttle body and fuel injectors is undoubtedly doomed to
a
short life.  I have had a chunk soaking in 100 LL gasoline for over a
month
now and no deteoriation is evident to visual observation  - i.e. no
crazing
or film build up on the surface.  Probably should stay away from auto
gasoline with all of its additives.  Again, thanks for the education.

Ed Anderson

I agree Monty did a great job.
You need to heat that gasoline to about 200 F Ed.
Also there is the issue of: Does the plastic material support combustion?

Paul Lamar


Ed,

Don't misunderstand me. For your particular case, you may have no problem.
You are using a two part urethane. These specialty resins can be had in
varieties that will probably work for your particular application. Some of
these resins are very resistant to chemical attack. A lot of times Plastics
are the only thing that will hold up in a severely corrosive environment.
Your manufacturing process is very different as well. You have a very thick
wall on your parts, something that is not possible for economic reasons in
an OEM part. You are not going to have a lot of molded in stress because
your resin is a two part room temp cure type of process. Injection molded
parts are produced by  melting resin pellets with pressure and shear in an
injection press. Then it is shot under very high pressure into the mold. It
is then cooled using a water jacket in the tool. Economics dictates that
your strive for the shortest "shot time". The flow lines created and the
need to solidify the part so quickly can result in a lot of molded in
stress. The location of these high stress levels is the first place to
suffer under chemical attack. Each plastic is unique in what type of
solvents it is resistant to. The point is under the hood of a car there is a
very wide range of solvents that may be encountered. Not to mention the
heat. Glass filled nylon 66 is great stuff. And it will last until the
warranty is up at a minimum, but 20 years down the road you are going to
have a pile of rubble. Most people don't keep cars that long and the
manufacturers know this, therefore they don't care if 10 years down the road
the valve covers crack, warp, or leak. Just like they don't care if the
water pump only lasts 60K miles on average on my Chrysler 318. As long as
the warranty is up no problem.

In your case you have thick walls, airflow to keep the thing cool, and what
little amount of surface degradation you might get should not affect the
structural integrity of the part. I also doubt that where the fuel is being
injected you are seeing temps even as high as ambient, due to fuel
vaporization. Plus the manifold does not sit in gasoline all the time. You
also used mineral fill which helps somewhat. Plus it is a two part urethane,
not a production molded part. I think for what you are trying to do, where
you need to try a lot of different configurations, it makes sense. I
wouldn't expect it to last 30 years under continuous use, but that is not
what you are trying to do. It works great to prototype and then make a metal
one once you hit the magic combo, or maybe you can find an appropriate resin
and make about 5 of them. Just replace them every 3 years or so. That is the
wonderful thing about silicone molds. You can make about 10-20 parts off of
the mold. Just keep an eye on it to look for signs that the plastic is
deteriorating. Make it part of your annual. Airplanes are different than
cars. No need to junk the idea. We are after all flying experimental
airplanes right?

Monty


BTW Monty what Rhino files do you want and send me your address by
private email.

Paul Lamar

The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.