HarrisonYoung wrote:
Hi Paul,
I'm Harrison Young. I live in Phoenix. We talked for a while at Oshkosh 2003
over greasy chicken dinners. I think you mentioned
that there was someone in Prescott who was just finishing up a
rotary-powered Lancair.
Another question. I talked to someone at Oshkosh who was selling
chain-drive reduction units for V6 conversions. He indicated
that they have quite a bit of flight history and seem very reliable.
He quoted a chain life of 2000 hours, and a sprocket life
of 6000 hours. I doubt anyone has actually ever put 6000 hours on a
set of sprockets (or probably even 2000 hours on a chain),
but what do you think of chain drive for use with rotaries? I expect
they are probably a bit heavier, but my understanding is
that chain drives are more efficient. This is partly evidenced
by the fact that some of those guys are running their chain
drives as a separate oil sump (with no cooling). Any thoughts?
BTW, I didn't get to make it to your lecture on cooling system design.
I was really disappointed about that, but the weather was
turning rough and I decided to leave Oshkosh a little sooner than
originally planed. Maybe next year.
Thanks in advance,
Harrison Young
I think a planetary box would weigh half the weight of a chain box.
The gears themselves, less the box and shafts, weigh only 8 pounds.
There are dozens of Ross and Tracy planetary drives flying with
accumulative hours in the tens of thousands.
I have never seen a chain drive PSRU and I go to a lot of air shows
and look at every airplane without an aircraft engine in it.
I have heard of them used on Geshwender Ford V8 conversions but those
are no longer around. I did not see one at OSH but I could have missed it.
I kind of doubt those life numbers as nobody has flown one for
2000 hours to my knowledge.
To put one on a rotary would be a whole new R&D program as all of our
history has been with the Ford planetary. Why bother? You will not find
a lower cost psru than the one Tracy Crook is selling. The gears themselves
cost less than $200.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.