Ed,
You mention RPM surges on the ground during hot weather
(snip)
Ground runups on 90F+ days produces fairly hot conditions under the
cowl, I
once reached up though the cowling exhaust exit and touch the header
tank
and found it to be very warm to uncomfortable hot to the touch.
Ed:
Thanks for the candid reply to the "recycle fuel" topic.
For all of us, please positively address the issue of vapor and/or air
accumulation in the recycle tank!
We (and you) can't afford for you to push your luck!
There is no way air (or vapor) can get out of the header tank. Further,
the
vapor pressure build-up could stop any fresh gas from entering the tank,
even with the boost pump on.
Keith,
Not certain what you want me to do to "positively address the issue of vapor
and/or air accumulation in the recycle tank". I believe I am to interpret
that to change my current installation. Well, I think I have been up front
that there are some things that can bite you if you follow my route and
don't plan for the possibility of vapor build up. There are other
alternatives and I certainly don't advocate that someone should copy my
approach and if they do - they had better understand the risks and take
steps to alleviate them.
As a side note, the EFI fuel systems of many (most?) new automobiles
(including the new RX-8) DO NOT return fuel to the tank - they don't even
have a header tank for returned fuel. . I think they basically handle the
vapor problem similar to my solution which is increasing the pump pressure
to push the vapor back into solution. Paul (our host) has more information
on that I believe. Paul?
I do disagree with your absolute statement that no air or vapor in the
header tank can get out. The reason turning on the boost pump stops the
percolation of the heated fuel is that the additional pressure forces the
vapor/air back into solution with the liquid gasoline as well as bringing in
cooler fuel from the main tanks. Also if you have observed fuel in clear
lines, it is not unusual to see occasional bubbles in the fuel of low
pressure lines. If the vapor pressure in the header tank exceeded 6 psi,
then I can see were the boost pump might not eliminate it, but so long as
the air is at the top of the tank and the fuel at the bottom - the EFI pumps
have access to fuel.
Once the engine goes to full power the problem disappears as the fuel flow
increases dramatically from the 1 1/2-2 1/2 GPH to much more (like 15-17
GPH) disappearing into the engine and cool fuel pulled from the tank to
replace it in the header tank. At the higher power setting, the engine is
using around one quart a minute of fuel, therefore, the fuel in the header
(approx 1 quart) tank has to be replaced once each minute by cool wing tank
fuel at those power setting. Plus less (heated) fuel is being returned to
the header tank. Whereas at 2 GPH at fast idle the fuel in the header tank
is only depleted and replace once every 7 -8 minutes with most of the heated
fuel being returned to the header tank and little cool wing tank fuel
flowing in to replaced that used. So the risk is highest at low power
settings and lowest at high power settings.
I appreciate your concern, but after flying 200+ hours in Southeast humid
and hot days (some days over 100F), and with another approx 90 hours of
ground run time (test stand and airframe) with the system, I am confident I
understand where the risks lie and have taken steps to alleviate them. I
don't believe in pushing my luck when my butt is at risk {:>). The things I
have done are:
1. Have a dedicated NACA duct with a 2" dia hose pumping air into a
aluminum foil covered enclosure around the fuel pumps and header tank. (This
after I had touched the header tank and found out how hot it got on the
ground)
2. Feel comfortable that my 6 psi boost pump will dominate the 0.5 -1.5
psi vapor pressure in the tank. It is on for takeoff and landing whether a
hot or cold day.
3. Practice power-off landings religiously.
> > This would assure you that the tank is free of vapor, full of fresh
"cool"
fuel, and provide an ability to recover if (the other) wing tank went
dry
and sucked air to the header tank.
I certainly agree that other alternatives are available and do not claim
my approach is superior - although they are none without possible downsides,
more lines in the cockpit, more fittings, more switches to leak/fail,
possibility of pumping fuel out a tank vent, etc.
It will be interesting to see if the new NO RETURN fuel system of newer
automobiles have fuel problems related to heated fuel.
Again, appreciate your concern, Keith.
Best Regards
Ed Anderson
The no return systems are predicated on the high pressure pump being IN the tank.
It might work if the pump is very very close to the tank.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.