Subject: Flight with Downsize Duct. Was Re: Bell shaped inlet corrdinates.xls
From: ACRE
Date: 9/4/2003, 4:14 PM


Ok folks, made the first flight today with my reduced/reshaped
radiator
inlet for the left evaporator core.  The right evaporator core was
left
unmodified to  provide a safety net sufficient to do the pattern and
land if
take off temps exceeded expectations.  Fortunately, that was not
necessary.
OAT on first take off was a humid 85 degrees.  No temperature
increased
noted during ground run up, so launched and made max rate of climb,
not
seeing any abnormal temp increase I left the pattern and continue
Max
rate
climb to 4500 MSL.  Max temp of coolant during climb was 210F
(normal
for
max rate climb at these OAT temps is 205F), Max oil temp was 200F
nominal
for max power climb. Max temps were reached about 2/3 of the way
through
the
climb.

In level flight, my coolant temperatures normally run 5 degrees
colder
than
my oil temp.  Today my coolant and oil temps were the same.  So
average
coolant temp was increased by 5 Degrees F.  Total radiator inlet
duct
area
was decreased from 48 square inches to 33 square inches.  24 Square
inches
for the right inlet duct and 9 square inch inlet for the modified
right
duct. Probably some drag benefit, but did not try to investigate
that
aspect.

I flew to an airfield 50 miles away to have my transponder
recertified
and
when I launched out of it, the OAT (ground level) was 92F

After level off I ran at different power settings to see the effect.

 5800 rpm burning 11.9  GPH at 4500  MSL with OAT at 78F My oil and
coolant
were both 190F.

5400 rpm burning 9.6 GPH at 4500 MSL with OAT 80F My Oil and coolant
were
both 185F

5200 (My normal cruise rpm)  burning 7.25 GPH at 4500 MSL with OAT
80F
My
oil and coolant were both  180F

In summary, the 33 % reduction in total  radiator inlet area
appeared to
have increased coolant temps by an average of 5 Deg above the normal
(the
old duct).  It could be that both the remaining radiator and perhaps
the
oil
cooler are rejecting any additonal load with no problem.

It appears that smoothing out the path for the air from inlet to
radiator
surface has benefited the cooling situation.  It could be that
additional
heat may be rejected by the right (second in series) radiator as the
coolant
it received from the left radiator was probably now a bit hotter. I
also
observed that the plate of the PSRU covers an area 3 " in from top
to
bottom
of the rear of each radiator and the plate is only 2" from the rear
of
the
fins at its closest, so that is obviously not helping flow, the Ross
Bell
housing did not, so a bell housing might improve flow conditions .

 I strongly suspect I would probably  find that a similar  reduction
of
the
right radiator inlet duct to 9 square inches  would see my coolant
(and
probably oil) temps increase considerable more than another 5 F.
OAT at
ground level was 94F when I landed, so not the hottest of days, but
not
the
type I normally prefer to fly in.

>From what I have seen so far, I think it worth pursuing a reduction
with the
right radiator duct.  I will probably not reduce it as much for the
reason
mentioned above. With some other things to take care of, probably
won't
get
to it until later part of Sept at the earliest.  But, I have no
problem
flying with current asymmetrical ducts, so will leave it as is for
the
time
being and collect some more data.

It it appears that some cooling benefit is derived from providing a
smoother
transition from duct to radiator (even if far from a perfect
implementation
of the K&M approach) than my old duct provided.

Oh, yes, as an aside, its been 25 hours since I replaced the spark
plugs
and
right on schedule - on the way back, I got the first SAG (Sparkplug
Attention Getter)  indication.  So it appears 25 hours on 100LL
about
the
average time for replacing plugs in my case.  I finally got a spark
plug
cleaner, so need to clean a set (as the electrods do not appear
worn)
and
see if getting the lead off the ceramic  cone helps any.

Best Regards

Ed Anderson

Ed please don't do anything until you get that cooling temp measuring
system working.
We will learn a lot more about your system when that is working.
Great data. Thanks.

Paul Lamar

Ok, Paul, I agree.  It should be interesting to see what is happening
with
the downsized inlet duct radiator and the larger duct since both see the
same coolant  flow (radiator would see it a bit cooler of course) .  IF
the
downsized duct is still rejecting approx the same (more?) heat than the
larger duct then that would pretty much confirm the improvement.  On the
other hand, if it has simply passed the heat load on to the other
radiator
(and perhaps oil), then the results still seem good, but would not be
quite
as impressive.

A question related to the data collection.  If I can't get the total
system
(including the GPS switch) functioning, I know you said to ship it back.
However, I know the thermocouple system worked as we got to that point
early
on.  Would the temp data without the GPS data be of any value?

Ed Anderson

Sure as long as you manually record air speed and ambient temp.

BTW your recent cooling data was taken under rather benign conditions.
I want to emphasize for the new guys that liquid cooling systems are
extremely
sensitive to ambient temp. Much much more so than air cooled systems.

This is because of the temp differential. Liquid cooling systems are
limited
by the 220 degree F or so temp of the coolant so a ten degree increase in
out
side temp makes much more of a difference than if you are dealing with
a 400 degree F air cooled cylinder head.

Paul Lamar


I certainly agree, I have noticed that I can tell when the OAT has changed
by as little as 5F by noting the coolant and oil temps changes.  So a
relative little change in ambient temp does make a big difference to liquid
cooled engines cooling performance.  Maybe benign by california death valley
standards, but anytime its over 90F here with the humidity it doesn't feel
benign {:>).  But, I'll see if any 100F days show up in the near future and
give it another try.  So far, the data indicates I may be able to reduce my
inlet area and still maintain adequate cooling - although I really do not
believe I can reduce both ducts to 9 square inches inlet, but perhaps 15
square inches down from 24 for each is reasonable.

Ok, Paul in the interest of getting some data collected, I am going to
install the thermocouples and data collector and lap top and get some data.
I normally record engine and performance data as a matter of course ever 15
minutes on every flight (going back two years), but for the data collection,
I'll do it every 5 minutes along with any event changes (power, altitude,
airspeed, etc.).  Besides, perhaps I can later get the GPS portion sorted
out as well.

Ed

OK Ed thanks. When you get done send the whole works back and I will get
it working with a cheap GPS. You can leave the thermal couples in place
for future use. I can always get or make more.

All this is academic of course. IMHO the cheap and simple cooling system
is the wave of the future.

Paul Lamar
 
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter.  Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/            
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.