But it is a safe wager; the odds of there ever being a 1 - 1
comparison
is about the same as winning the lottery.
Al
Agreed, and even if it does cool like nothing else the amount
of turbulence
is unacceptible. We're trying to minimize, not
increase the turbulence. Why do you think people doggedly want to
hang onto their NACA scoops instead of giving them up for a
P-51 scoop?... not everybody thinks P-51 scoops are neat
looking on anything but a P-51.
Sure Perrys works but this is not an apples an oranges
comparison, for one
feeding his prop is like no other canard.
Paul , you are putting optimal cooling success in front of all
other considerations and if I were approaching a rotary install
for the first time would pass on the whole idea if this were the
best way to do it, I don't think people are going to
volantarily go for ugly and draggy turbulent solutions, they are
trying to IMPROVE their planes not put them in the junkyard
wars catagory.
...Chrissi
I received this sort of response many times in my life. You
should have heard
what the car racing community said when we first installed a
wing on a racing car.
Before you let the clutch out on your mouth you should think of
the big picture.
You need to think of ALL possible ramifications of new ideas.
If it don't cool you don't fly. Putting cooling success ahead of drag
and cosmetics is paramount. The best looking airplane in the world is
useless if you can't fly it.
What do you mean "unacceptable turbulence". Everything on your
canard fuselage
aft of 48 inches from the nose is turbulent boundary layer. That is why
non flush riveting is used on most aircraft towards the aft end and this
includes jet airliners. 70% of my 182 is non flush riveted and I will
bet flush riveting 100% of it would not make it noticeably faster.
It is not ugly as you can't see it. I just addressed that issue
with a picture.
Repeating the same subjective bull shit over and over again is
not constructive.
This system is functionally no different in operation or drag
than if it were
located under the engine dumping the air out the bottom of the cowl.
Nobody objected to that including you. Actually it is a bit more effective
as the angle of the rad is better and it is dumping the heated air into
a low pressure area rather than into what might be a high pressure area.
"Draggy" is a subjective word. It matters not if system A it is
only a little more
drag than system B. You must put a number on your contentions.
Like Vance did.
That is the difference between an emotional appeal and a rational
appeal. We are not dealing with emotions here. We are dealing
with engineering.
You must look at it from a quantitative pressure loss point of view.
The amount of drag of this system is going to be a function of
the porosity
of the rad. My calculus professor taught me to think about
the limits. Obviously a very porous screen would cause very
little pressure
loss and drag. A solid sheet of material would cause a high
pressure loss and
air would spill around the edges of the opening causing high drag.
A thin large frontal area low porosity radiator would cause less pressure
loss than a thick small frontal area radiator. It is also more efficient
as the first half of the core does 3/4 of the heat transfer to the air.
This is why the use of thin rads dominates in modern cars.
Mounting the thin radiator outside at an acute angle results in
the same effective
additional frontal area as a thick radiator mounted perpendicular to the
air stream inside a P51 type scoop and duct system. The air velocity
through a thin radiator will be higher than the air velocity through
a thick radiator given the same pressure drop across the two. Therefor
the exit air needs to be speeded up less with a thin rad than it needs
to be speeded up with a thick rad.
One of the problems with a thick radiator is it takes high pressure to
force air through it. In our speed ranges, as opposed to the speed ranges
of the P51 we don't have the high pressures to work with. Pressure is
proportional to the square of the velocity. If our airplane climbs out
at 100 MPH we have a max of .18 psi to work with. If the P51 climbs
out at 200 mph it has .72 psi to work with. Four times higher.
Another problem with the P51 cooling approach is it requires a
duct 2.5 times as
long as the max dimension of the radiator. It also requires a clear space
behind the radiator of 50% of the max dimensions. This makes the over all
volume requirements not possible for fitting inside the cowl.
With the oblique mounted thin rad under the fuselage we can build
a system with the same or less effective additional frontal
area as the P51 scoop and duct. Actually a little less as the
a boundary layer bleed would add nothing to the frontal area
as opposed to the boundary layer air bleed on a P51 type scoop
and duct.
By dumping the heated air into what is
already a turbulent boundary layer we can eliminate the duct
volume required down stream from the rad. Due to the fact that
a Kays and London wedge shaped diffuser requires no
duct length ahead of it we save additional structure
and volume. Not to mention the time it takes to fab
all that duct stuff.
Now having come up with a system that is potential very good at
cooling at low speeds and uses a minimum of enclosed volume
without increasing the effective additional frontal are we can
focus on reducing the drag of such as system.
You made a very good suggestion of doing a special oblique rad.
Having thought about it a bit I think we can reduce the drag
of a large area obliquely amounted thin rad by minor changes to
the fin angle between water tubes. I will do a 3D on this shortly.
Perhaps we can put together a group optimum radiator buy.
Paul said:
We are not dealing with emotions here. We are dealing with engineering.
Then he said:
.... Obviously a very porous screen would cause very little pressure
loss and drag. A solid sheet of material would cause a high pressure loss
and
air would spill around the edges of the opening causing high drag....
A thin large frontal area low porosity radiator would cause less pressure
loss than a thick small frontal area radiator.
Paul,
Engineering and science involve quantification. The terms "very", "very
little", "high pressure loss", "high drag", "thin", "less", "thick", and
"small" in the above paragraph all need quantification before the above
statement has any scientific value. My guess is that the drag and turbulence
from ANY design of radiator hanging out in the wind is going to be very
significant, but thats a gut feel guess, not science.
Perhaps we can put together a group optimum radiator buy.
I'd suggest some scientific experiments with all this before anyone rushes
off a bulk order for specially designed radiators.
Regards,
John Slade
(Still sticking defiantly to my NACA scoop)
You gave me an idea John but it is going to have to wait awhile.
If you construct a particular scoop, duct and radiator system and send it
to me it would be possible, using linear ball bearings and a frame work,
to measure the drag directly by mounting it on the top of the Van.
The dyno is more important and I need to get that working first.
Paul Lamar
The AirCraft Rotary Engine NewsLetter. Powered by Linux.
ACRE NL web site. http://home.earthlink.net/~rotaryeng/
Copyright 1998-2003 All world wide rights reserved.